Put-in-Bay Island Club #11 Su-Th $150-$300/nt, Fr-Sa $225-$1000/nt

Mrs

"The cabin is wonderful. Newly remodeled, right by the pool, quiet, and very clean. There was only 4 of us, but there are plenty of beds to bring friends or the family! Looking for a great place to stay this is the place! What a great getaway!"

Very enjoyable stay

"Great house in a great location. Private but also close to the pool!"

"WEATHER SUCKED BUT FISHING WAS GOOD WHEN WE GOT TO GO "

"We had a great vacation rental experience. The Cabin was clean and supplied with all needed cooking and serving dinner ware. This cabin laid out in an open concept designed with 2 full baths, fast WIFI and large screen TV. Our fantastic host Dottie is very accommodating and personally stops in to ensure our everything is up to par. We stayed for 14 nights and enjoyed these accommodations The complete staff are very friendly and eager to help us out. We are treated as royal guest and would recommend the Island Club rentals to all. We actually book twice a year and look forward to our next visit. "

"Unit appeared to be remodeled recently and staff was very accommodating. We will be returning! "

"Rented a home from Island Club rentals for the family. Short stay. The property seemed well maintained. The Island is small, so there's really no bad location. Close to parks, restaurants, family fun center. Second day and the pool was void of water, so the kids didn't get to swim. Check-in process was easy, would have given it 5 stars but I have yet to see my deposit back. We were careful to follow checkout process. Would stay here again. "

"The house was extremely well kept, clean, and comfortable. The tiki bar was a great bonus to mingle and meet others. Dottie was welcoming and ready to handle any of our wants/needs. Will be returning! "

"most gooder love it"

"The Island Club Rentals is a great vacation place to stay with excellent hospitality. The cabins are very nice, cozy with a modern open designed layout, Most sleep 8 or more people. The cabins are clean, with comfortable beds, dish washer, wash and dryer, multiple bathrooms, you name it they got. The staff is super nice, and accommodating. They check in to make sure our stay is perfect. Dottie (Island Club manager) is the best. I’ve stayed at the Island Club now for 10 years and look forward to next year. "

"Everything was as advertised. "

"My sisters and I had a fabulous time! We will be back.
The golf carts were convenient for sightseeing and a lot of fun. Great customer service!"

"This house is being updated and beautiful so far! Can not wait to see it when it's complete because we will be back!! Dottie takes such great care of us! This house is tucked in just enough but close to the pool and main road making catching cabs and pool time a breeze! Looking forward to our fall trip too!"

"Had a blast beautiful island night life was fun and fishing was excellent "

"Owner, Dottie, met us at the cabin just after check-in to make sure we had everything we needed, and was there in just minutes when we realized we didn’t have golf cart keys. Cabin #11 has 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms; BR1 has a queen and a twin with its own bathroom (his and her sinks, garden tub, stand up shower), BR 2 had 2 queens, BR 3 had a queen and two twins. These may change as Dottie said she’d be remodeling #11 in the off-season. Would definitely rent this cabin again. "

"We had a wonderful time staying in Put-in-Bay Island Club #11. Dottie is so fun and easy to work with. She really cares about her properties. We met some of the nicest people while we were there. Can't wait to go back!"

"The property has had some updates since we last stayed. Good location, nice home."

"just chill place"

"Quick one night stay for the Toby Keith concert, but location and setup worked out great! Would definitely use again for a longer term stay."

"The unit was in good shape. The lamp shade was broken when we arrived but other than that all was good. We really didn't spend much time in the cabin"

"Good overall experience!"

"Overall the experience was awesome! We all had such a great time and the location of the cabin was perfect! I have stayed here before and LOVE being so close to the pool and where the action is. Everyone was so friendly and we will all be back :) "

"We went for a bachelorette party and had a blast!!! So many people to connect with as well as space to have fun! The house was so clean and spacious, and was also only a 5-ish minute drive to downtown! You had your own privacy, but we're close enough to all the fun parts of Putinbay! We will definitely be back and will not hesitate to book with IslandTime!!"

"We have stayed at the Island club several times throughout the years, and it was always a pleasant experience. The accommodations are great for large groups
And the staff is always available should there be any problem or concern. It's more quiet during the week as opposed to the weekends that host a more adult crowd. One problem, it's difficult to have small children share a pool in the heat of the summer with a crowd of loud, inebriated party-goers, the club needs a child's play area."

"We had a great time on the island. We stayed in house 11. Not bad considering all the traffic that goes in and out within a year. Bathroom floors I'm guessing had not been cleaned for some time. But over all house was clean and we had a great time."

"We had a fantastic time. We could not have been any happier with the camp grounds and cabin. There was plenty of room for everyone who stayed with our group and the local amenities were very convenient. The 3 dollar cab rides were great and they were always available within ten minutes of wanting to go anywhere on the island. We really enjoyed island club rentals and would recommend their cabins to anyone looking for a good time. "

"Let me start by saying it was our first trip there and we absolutely loved it. We had a few glitches with some minor things in the cabin and with our golf cart. It took some time away from enjoying the trip but very minor. The property management was very accommodating and couldn't have been nicer about things.Island Club 11 was very clean and great because of the location in the property. Close to the pool which was also awesome and clean, everyone commented about the amount of lounge chairs available. It was nice that everyone had a place to lay by the pool when they weren't swimming. The down side to this unit 11 was the furniture was older and not comfortable with the exception of one bed with a trundle. That mattress my friend said she would have taken home with her. The others were not so great but I have slept on worse. I won't get into details about the living room furniture. I spoke to the property manager they know the issues and I'm sure they will address them. As I said they were very nice and willing to work with everyone. I personally loved the location of the Island Club. Near the State Park which we used to access the boat dock when we took our boat out fishing. On the opposite end of the island as most of the restaurants and stores but the island isn't that big so it was not an issue at all. I would definitely stay with them again."

"As always my sister and I had a great time at Put-in-bay's Island Club. However, this particular house was not as nice as the last one we stayed in and overall not as clean. Will definitely be coming back but will choose a different house. Still a great value!!"

"The property is starting to show is age and could use some general upkeep, such as the outside lights not working. Nothing major just little things. Island Club people are good to work with."

"The house was clean, well taken care of. The staff was exceptionally polite,helpful. Didn't want to leave we will be returning hopefully back to clubhouse #11. Thank you everyone "

"Always have a great time on the island the island clubs home great always nice and clean employees are very nice and polite would recommend the island clubs homes with no hesitation great place to stay"

"I always choose island club for my stay at Put in Bay with friends and family. The location is easily accessible from the Miller ferry and removed from downtown for quiet, but within a 10 minute walk of Heineman's and Perry Cavern. We always have plenty of space for our group and the amenities we need for a comfortable stay: deck and grill, washer and dryer, coffee maker, cable TV, refrigerator, and good AC. "

"The property was neat, but the wifi was non-existent in the property. Only access was at the pool."

"Our party had a fantastic time this weekend staying at Island Club #11! "

"Great location, close to the pool.great to have 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, kitchen, and laundry. Unit is in need of some repairs and updates to couch and mattresses."

"Always been a Good experience with island club rentals. Would recommend to anyone wanting to get away. The house has few cosmetic issues, but will stay there again next year."

"All great"

"we had a great time. place was really nice. customer service was wonderful."

"I like Put In Bay and the town -- very nice. On the other hand, the rental was run down and really like a camp. No furniture matching, the carpet was new but was laid over a hole in the floor and kept stepping on it and tripping, nothing at all is fancy. From the pictures, you think it is a nice place with new stuff -- no way. The couch is leather -- sit on it and you might as well sit on the floor. I feels like and I think in the town has a reputation of being a party village. It is not really where I wanted me, my husband, and 6 teenage girls to be spending time. Lots of parties including bachelor parties. I also read about the horrible murder in July in this area and really gave me the scares. Also, and I think one of the most important, the towels we rented smelled musty like they had not been dried well and put away. Yuck!"

"My family and I had a great time here. Our unit was a little secluded which was nice but we were also very close to the pool area. It was a nice quiet location for some fun family time. The only thing that bothered us was all the May flies in the outside lighting. There were so many that the lights were not visible. "

"We planned a 50th birthday celebration for my wife. Four friend joined us at the Island Club #11. The folks at the Island Club did a wonderful job with customer service as the check in and golf cart procedures went very smooth. The other Island Club guests were a little younger for our weekend but they provided tons of energy and were all very respectful of their neighbors. We had a blast and would certainly return again.
"

"it was a very good experience, we all enjoyed ourself and will definitely do it again. "

"Was able to get the house at short notice. Good island home."

"Housed my Groomsman for my wedding, we had a blast. Great place!"

"It was our first time in put-in-bay and we had a great time! We will definitely be coming back and plan to use island club rentals again and bring our entire group of friends and family next time. We loved the taxi service and ease of being picked up in a very timely manner. We also loved having an outdoor area to hang out. "

"I enjoyed the location and the house was nice....but...the whole time I was there, the house smelled like cat pee. The smell never went away. I believe the owner may have lived here for a while with a cat or a few cats. I am allergic to cats so I had the joy of waking up every morning to extremely itchy eyes. I would defintiely stay at the Island Club again, but definitely NOT #11! If you are allergic to cats or have a very keen sense of smell, I would NOT recommend this house!!!"

"excellent vacation"

" a"

"The cottage and staff were all awesome . We had a great time !!!

"