Put-in-Bay Island Club #53 Su-Th $150-$300/nt, Fr-Sa $225-$1000/nt

"Had a great time on the Island "

"Loved this place. Would rent again. The round kitchen table was perfect for us. Great for dinner conversation."

"My family ans I were all extremely happy with our current stay. We stayed in #53. It had everything we needed. "

"Great place to stay easy to find little to pricey since I had to bring my own bedding and was offered to add on another day for 1/4 of the price for 1 nite but it was a great place very friendly interaction with rental with island club and very informative with messages.
Does have a washer and dryer in rental "

"The overall stay was very pleasant. The unit was clean and comfortable. I went to great effort and expense to make arrangements for fish cleaning off site. I was shocked to see fish cleaning taking place outside at many of the units. This was obvio0usly tolerated as it went on for my entire trip. Being open about the realities of what can and cannot be done at Island Club would have been more honorable on your part."

"We got moved to a different place this year. This house was better than last years place but the parking was a bit more challenging. Challenging everywhere I guess. Very satisfied with the prompt response from management on a minor issue we had. Looking forward to next year and hopefully we can get this house again. "

"Was as advertised. Great location on island. Would definitely stay here again"

"Dotty is the best!!"

"Overall the cabin was sufficient - spacious & adequate. 8 of us stayed as was the limit. There wasn’t enough room in 1 bedroom to sit luggage on & not enough space to get in on one side so had to crawl onto beds, but they were comfortable. Floor in entire cabin was very dirty. Could not go barefoot & several of us threw away our socks as they were too black to launder. The skylight had a huge leak which drained down the ceiling onto the window above the sink & onto the window sill & into the sink. (We had a storm so saw that). There was a nice lg. deck that we spent a lot of time on. The place is nice but needs some cleaning & maintenance. "

"We loved our stay. The rooms were more roomy than expected and the kitchen was stocked with tools and equipment. We used the outdoor gas grill & ate at the cabin every night and used the pool a couple times too. We were able to access plenty to watch on the TV and the wifi service was strong. "

"We had a really nice time. Spent lots of time downtown, bur the house was comfortable and we liked the area."

"We have been staying at the Island Club for many years now and I really appreciate how Dotty makes sure everything is taken care of. Any issues that might arise are taken care of promptly! "

"As expected the house was in great shape when we arrived and Dottie took care of us from the time we arrived till our departure. Already looking forward to our next trip back to the Bay and staying at the Island Club!"

"We also try to rent unit number 53 due to its cleanliness, sleeping arrangements and open concept. We have never had an issue with this unit and it is always ready when indicated.


Highly recommend this house!"

"We enjoyed the stay on the island"

"Unit was perfect for the 7 of us.
The only thing missing was a broom/dustpan and a vacuum in the unit to clean up through out the week and before we left.
Removing the small tree at the back of the parking space would help backing in a boat and truck also"

"Very clean nice very friendly staff "

"As always, our stay was an enjoyable experience. I can't say enough about Dottie who always makes us feel welcome and a part of the Island Club family. Thanks again to the Island Club and Dottie for another great Labor Day weekend...already looking forward to our next trip to the Bay!"

"Unit 53 is a great unit with an abundance of space, number of beds, always clean inside as Nd close to all venues. We never have any issues as we try to rent this unit every year when available. The only item they may want to update is to replace the one board on the picnic table. Other then that, I highly recommend this unit!!You won’t be disappointed!"

"Great place to stay the only downfall was that the place said it come with bath towels and it did not have any bath towels at all nowhere to be found ."

"Great! Will definitely do this again!!"

"The location of the island club is great, very easy to get to and fun to drive to and from in our golf cart that was ready at our cabin when we arrived. The unit was adequate, nothing fancy, but worked for our short stay. Our biggest issue was mice in the cabin, noted on our first night which made it difficult to get comfortable and sleep well. "

"It was absolutely amazing, my husband and kids wanted to stay an additional day and thanks to Joshua who was able to keep us in the same home..."

"Nice cottage. Very comfortable. Everything we needed"

"The condo was clean and in a quiet spot. Great set up for 2 families! "

"We had a great time (nothing new) we always have a great time at the bay. "

"We had a great experience with our cabin! Everything was very neat and tidy when we arrived! "

"It was amazing as always! This is the third time my family & I have stayed here and I would recommend it to anyone! It's super clean & the staff is very friendly & helpful. "

"I love the Island Club rentals. This is our second time and we like the fact that we are far away from downtown and the all night noise. We love the night life but not when we are tired"

"Had a good time at the island club #53 fishing and partying with friends"

"Enjoyed the stay very much, met new friends and looking forward to meeting them again next year. Everyone was so nice and pleasant to be around. It was like everyone already new each other. Such a friendly environment. My rating is a thumbs up (5)in all categories !!!"

"we had a great time exploring the island the weather was perfect! We will defiantly be back!"

"Our stay was such a great experience! We will be coming back to this cabin again!"

"We had such a great time, our entire group had never been to the island before. It was a great experience, we loved that there was a pool for the island club renters and that we had our own grill. All the beds were surprisingly comfortable. "

"This is my family's second time staying in this home, and we love the cleanliness of it and it's very opened. The owner did some updates from last year which is very nice! I would ask for a second tv in the home and that my only complaints is the tubs did not have stoppers and to please please put a screen up for the front door to help keep the bugs out. "

"My stay was perfect, nothing but a good time. I'll be renting here again next year. "

"Had a very nice time at island club. Very clean, very quiet,nice furnishings, very easy check in, needs a bit of TCL to the outside to make more appealing."

"Our home was nice but there was a terrible odor that took about a day to air out. We believe that maybe it was the left over smell of weed?? "

"Overall a great experience. Our family had a great time on Put-In-Bay. Admittedly, the furniture seemed quite worn and dingy/dirty. We began using our shoes in the house consistently due to the floors being so dirty. The floors really need cleaned well and the carpets too. Our feet and socks were grossly black with dirt after walking on the floor a short time."

"It was great"

"The location was great! Cabin itself was all new and updated. We were even allowed to check in early with our kids. Very kid friendly and Dottie was especially helpful
Will definitely stay here again - thanks guys!"

"Thank you island club rentals for a wonderful weekend stay,everything from the service of booking and while staying was great! The cabin was beautiful, we will be back again next year!!"

"Overall we enjoyed our stay. The only concern I have is there was no pot holder or baking pan/cookie pan in the kitchen. The back door would not lock."

"We had a great stay in our Island Club rental home!! It was clean, comfortable and had everything we needed while we visited the island. There was plenty of hot water for everyone to get a hot shower and all the appliances and the grill were a nice bonus!! Thank you and I hope to stay again in the future!!"

"totally enjoyed our vacation rental, ours was especially nice because the deck was on the back and was nice and private. fun family time place was clean and tidy"

"It was decent for put in bay. The place was clean and quiet. There were not any major issues the only negatives were the coffee maker was broke and the tub shower wasn't draining well. Overall a nice stay. We got our safety deposit back within a week."

"Staff was great, very helpful. Location was ok, wish we were closer to town. Unit needed lots of TLC, inside and out. "

"We had a great time. The island is beautiful and there's so much to do, even for families."

"I have to say we had the best trip ever. The island club manager was awesome an helped us when we needed. Def coming back.. thanks for the stay!!"

"awesome place to stay on the island! Great house and great service! "

"The place was nice. Some cob webs in bigger bath room. But everything else was good.you should have a matt in the rest rooms."

"Been staying at island club for about 12 years and it been nothing put a very good place to stay."

"Enjoyed our stay."

"The place was wonderful and the staff was so flexible with my party and I The fact that I had a shuttle available to me for most of the weekend was awesome! "

"Very enjoyable. "

"ISLAND CLUB IS THE BEST ON THE ISLAND BY FAR! MANAGEMENT COMPANY IS FANTASTIC"

"Loved our stay here! Everyone was so helpful and understanding! I will certainly be back again next year! "

"Home was clean and had nearly everything for an enjoyable stay. Will come back next year."

"Great beds."

"great, property suited us well"

"This was my first time staying at Put In Bay and we had a blast. There was 7 of us and we had plenty of room. Only a 5 min golf cart drive to town made it nice too. We only cooked in the kitchen a couple of times but it made it nice known we could anytime we wanted. The regular list price on these rooms were a little high for me, but we got the LivingSocial which I thought was a fair price."

"lots of light bulbs burnt out. two outside front, and one in back. Also a couple indoors. Would like to have more info on attractions in the area, other homes we've rented have a folder with info."

"Had a great time. grandkids are still talking about there experience at the club. can't wait for next year. will stay longer, I'm sure."

"We stayed in units 53 and 55 for a bachelor/bachelorette party. Everyone enjoyed the units and had a blast! Dottie and Jerry are great to work with-any questions I had were answered immediately! Would recommend the island club for any weekend in put in bay!"

"Pleasantly surprised by rental. Great place to stay while in Put-in Bay good amount of space will definitely return "

"This past weekend I stayed at the Island Club! The staff on site was awesome and helpful when I had questions. The inside was very clean and I loved the furniture in the family room. The stay was incredible. I also love that they use a lockbox. This way the guests staying can come in and out freely and our stuff was locked up. The front patio was the only feature of the house that I wished looked a little cleaner. Having a nice back patio was secluded and private, at first we were disappointed it was in the back, but it worked out being better for privacy. "

"Pool was great and house was roomy for all 6 of us. Deck and porch need repairs. I fixed the lid to the grill and the picnic table was a shhet of plywood. The resort was clean and we enjoyed walks. Missed wifi and a toaster. But we plan on returning."