Halloween Bash at the Bay, Oct 26/27 still has houses open! - PS... 2019 Kid Rock Concert is sold out!

Island Club #88 Su-Th $150-$300/nt, Fr-Sa $225-$1000/nt

Type: House
Pets Allowed: No
Location: Put-in-Bay







Travel Dates

Inquire About this home or Additional Lodging on the Island

Leave this field empty

Fill out the form below to get more information.

Arrival Date:
Departure Date:

Share This Property

Click the main image above for larger images
Click Here to Select Your Dates and Book

Nestled in the back of the Island Club, this home has the peace and quiet your group is looking for. The rear of this home is surrounded by a wooded area providing shade and enjoyment. With three bedrooms and two baths, this home can sleep up eight guests. Guests can pull right into their own driveway, with space for up to two vehicles. A coded door lock is very convenient, giving all of your guests easy access to the unit. Upon entry, guests are welcomed to an eat-in kitchen. The kitchen has full-size appliances and all of the things needed to cook and serve a meal. This is an excellent way to save some money during your Put-in-Bay vacation. There is a television with DirecTV service in the living room. A large wraparound wooden deck is a great feature of this home. A picnic table and propane grill completes this area.
The advantage to booking a home is immense with the added space and conveniences. The Island Club at Put-in-Bay is the number one choice for vacation rentals. You deserve to getaway and can do so close to home at PIB!
The weekends at Put in Bay Ohio are popular for the nightlife and getting away from the daily work grind without going too far from home. During the week, you can relax and enjoy Put-In-Bay's slower pace in a family friendly atmosphere. With Island Club Rentals, you can visit Put-in-Bay and enjoy your own home and you can even rent a golf cart onsite to get around. Please let us know how we can make your vacation at Put-in-Bay a great one!


Available Unavailable Check In Check Out
October 2018
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
  01 02 03 04 05 06
07 08 09 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31
November 2018
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
     01 02 03
04 05 06 07 08 09 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30
December 2018
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
02 03 04 05 06 07 08
09 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30 31
January 2019
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
   01 02 03 04 05
06 07 08 09 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31
February 2019
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
      01 02
03 04 05 06 07 08 09
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28
March 2019
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
      01 02
03 04 05 06 07 08 09
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30
April 2019
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
  01 02 03 04 05 06
07 08 09 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30
May 2019
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
    01 02 03 04
05 06 07 08 09 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31
June 2019
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
02 03 04 05 06 07 08
09 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
July 2019
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
  01 02 03 04 05 06
07 08 09 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31
August 2019
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
     01 02 03
04 05 06 07 08 09 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31
September 2019
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
01 02 03 04 05 06 07
08 09 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30


Map may not be 100% accurate.


Start Date End Date Midweek Rent Weekend Rent
10/21/2018 10/25/2018 $150.00 $300.00
10/28/2018 03/28/2019 $9,999.00
03/29/2019 03/30/2019 $225.00
03/31/2019 04/04/2019 $150.00 $225.00
04/07/2019 04/11/2019 $150.00 $225.00
04/14/2019 04/18/2019 $150.00 $225.00
04/21/2019 04/25/2019 $150.00 $225.00
04/28/2019 05/02/2019 $150.00 $450.00
05/05/2019 05/09/2019 $150.00 $400.00
05/12/2019 05/16/2019 $150.00 $400.00
05/19/2019 05/23/2019 $150.00 $625.00
05/26/2019 05/30/2019 $150.00 $675.00
06/02/2019 06/06/2019 $175.00 $675.00
06/09/2019 06/13/2019 $175.00 $607.50
06/16/2019 06/20/2019 $175.00 $750.00
06/23/2019 06/27/2019 $175.00 $675.00
06/30/2019 07/04/2019 $300.00 $700.00
07/07/2019 07/11/2019 $250.00 $700.00
07/14/2019 07/18/2019 $250.00 $700.00
07/21/2019 07/25/2019 $250.00 $900.00
07/28/2019 08/01/2019 $250.00 $700.00
08/04/2019 08/08/2019 $250.00 $700.00
08/11/2019 08/15/2019 $200.00 $650.00
08/18/2019 08/22/2019 $200.00 $650.00
08/25/2019 08/27/2019 $200.00 $675.00
09/03/2019 09/05/2019 $150.00 $400.00
09/08/2019 09/12/2019 $150.00 $500.00
09/15/2019 09/19/2019 $150.00 $300.00
09/22/2019 09/26/2019 $150.00 $300.00
09/29/2019 10/03/2019 $150.00 $400.00
10/06/2019 10/10/2019 $150.00 $250.00
10/13/2019 10/17/2019 $150.00


    • Golf Course,
    • Nearby Grocery,
    • Nearby Medical Services,
    • Perry's Monument Visitors Center,
    • Satellite TV,
    • Coffee Maker,
    • Cookware,
    • Full Kitchen,
    • Microwave,
    • Refrigerator,
    • Stove,
    • Toaster,
    • Air Conditioning,
    • Central Air,
    • Linens & Towels NOT Provided,
    • No Phone,
    • Washer & Dryer,
    • Deck,
    • Gas Grill (Propane Provided),
    • Pool Access,
    • Shared Pool,
    • Yard,
Things To Do:
    • Dining,
    • Nearby ATM,
    • Nearby Bank,
    • Nearby Post Office,
    • Shopping,
    • Water Activities,
  • 2 Queen (1st BR), 2 Full (2nd BR), Full & Twin (3rd BR)

Recent Reviews About This Property

"Very clean good neighbors easy check in and out loved it"

Yolanda D. from Detroit, 07/27/2018

"It was more than perfect, much bigger than expected! The taxi service that is offered for island club renters made getting to and from downtown very quick easy. "

from Brunswick, 07/17/2018

"House was clean. Outside was clean. We had a good experience "

from Ashley, 07/10/2018

"We love the island. The house was nice. A little bit run down but clean."

Robert K. from Downers Grove, 06/24/2018

"My lady and I really enjoyed the house. The rooms were clean and in great condition. In fact, the whole house was clean and in great condition. Having a fully stocked kitchen allowed us to cook whatever we wanted. The bathrooms were roomy and clean. The beds were comfy, perfect for sleeping (and for not sleeping). I also liked the roomy outer deck. I'm definitely going to stay there again."

Julius A. from Detroit, 06/03/2018

"Had the greatest time ever! Will never stay anywhere else on the island. Thank you for everything Island Club!"

from Homer Glen, 05/15/2018

"The biggest problem was the day the we’re doing blacktop work to the road, we had to leave our boat and park far away from our cabin. It was very difficult as we had an older person and also one with bad ankles. They had to walk as the way back, then we had to return to the boat to with the cover, which is very bulky to carry and get the boat covered and secured. Very difficult situation for our whole party and all the other guests."

Mike L. from Whitewood, 05/06/2018

"Parking with a boat is difficult, but neighbors to cooperate to make it work!"

from Menno, 04/29/2018

"Island Club is great to work with. Especially since we've grown in #'s over the last 4 years. Looking forward to our 5th. Anniversary next year!!"

Brenda H. from Mount Vernon, 09/29/2017

"I highly recommend renting this cabin or renting from Island Club. They were so incredibly nice and able to talk or any questions at any point. The cabins are extremely nice and the perfect location to have a family or group of friends visit."

Justin M. from Pittsburgh, 09/20/2017

"Management was great, tv didn't work upon arrival but was fixed quickly. Location was great. Floor in one bathroom could've been cleaner, looked like mold on wall near trim. Wood panel near barstool was busted but not big deal. Upon our departure, realized when we took garbage out, was not emptied before our stay. Overall, I would stay there again."

Kim H. from Metamora, 08/31/2017

"Mid-week stay. Relaxing but it is a vacation get-a-way so it's not something to expect to do on the cheap."

from Leo, 07/04/2017

"I had been wanting to go to Put-in-Bay for years. When I rec'd an email with a special at Island Club homes I immediately booked. So glad I did. What a wonderful island! So unique! For such a small island it is packed with things to do. The Island Club home (#88)was nice and quiet for our June Mon-Wed stay. It was 'clean' but could definitely use a once over for maintenance and replenishing of amenities---ie. rotting door and window frames, lacking dining chairs for an 8-person home, and not enough cutlery (2 steak knives). I would definitely go back though, as I had a wonderful time. We just had to overlook a few things. "

Wendy H. from North Tonawanda, 06/30/2017

"Great experience. Only downside is having to smoke outside during a may fly storm lol. House was clean and had everything we needed. Golf cart included in package was super loud and felt like it was going to fall apart at times but I'm not sure if that is the normal, but the golf cart was super fun!! Overall great time and experience!!"

Nastashia B. from Dayton, 06/25/2017

"Me and my friends had a great time. This atmosphere was awesome and it was very laid back. The rules were easy to follow, even when management were making their rounds. No one was rude to us. We have been coming back to this place for four years and every time has been great. I never had a complaint from anyone staying with us as well. "

Wesley S. from Greensburg, 05/31/2017


Gerald C. from Edgeworth, 09/03/2016

"We had a great experience. The Island Club was just what we were hoping. Thanks!"

Morgan G. from Cleveland, 08/09/2016

"We really liked the location of the house, we had to clean out the drawers as some party favors were left behind!! The beds were comfortable carpet could use a good cleaning problems with the golf cart but issue was resolved and day 2 with GC went great!"

Virginia B. from Waldo, 07/31/2016

"Nice rental, great pool, can't beat the price."

Brittany A. from West Chester, 07/11/2016

"Everything was great , thank you "

from Eastlalke, 07/11/2016

" Great getaway with family to celebrate parents 68th wedding anniversary. Liked that our unit was set back behind the others with lots of privacy to the rear. It was quiet and very comfortable. Golf cart was delivered and picked back up from our unit for no extra charge. Only complaints… No screens on bedroom windows, no dishwasher, not enough towel racks in second bathroom, bowed plastic picnic table, not enough barstools to sit around dining table. Otherwise, enjoyed the mostly new furniture and cute nautical themed decorating touches."

Anne D. from Spartenburg, 07/03/2016

"I didn't have to worry about anything. The golf cart was in the driveway whe we arrived at the house and the were there within minutes to pick it up when I was ready to leave.the house is at a good location and has about everything you need to getaway and just relax. We made breakfast and lunch at the house to save some cash and had dinner in town. We will defently be staying there again. "

from Yorkville , 06/29/2016

"Had a wonderful time with our friends. Loved the property location and layout. Hope to stay again next year in same unit."

Don O. from Pittsburgh, 06/23/2016

"Vacation rental was all the comforts of home, including washer & dryer. Nicely located. Tucked away in the back with wooded view. Was peacefull,relaxing and safe. A great family spot!"

from Greenfield, 06/11/2016

" We booked this place to stay for our family's very first vaca. We have 2 toddlers (3 & 4) and didn't want to stray too far from home or for too long. So we chose Put-in-bay Island Club for 2 nights. This cabin was in the back corner, in the case that one of the toddlers had any meltdowns. We didn't want to disturb anyone. The house was great.

Our only hiccup was that our fridge didn't quite work as well as we had hoped, so our first hour there we had to call matinence. Believe it or not, they replaced the fridge right then and they were so nice about it, like it was nothing. "Oh, we were planning on putting a new one in. Would it be a bother if we came in and did it for you now?" Well no it wouldn't, Sir. Thank you! So they brought it in and set it up for us. Now, that's service!

The house was clean and quiet. I was sad to leave so soon. There was NO outside noise that drifted in. We didn't even hear outside noise on our first night when our neighbors had a get together, so I'm hoping that my toddlers didn't bother anyone sitting our porch time.

We Loved the grill and spent a lot of time on the porch that wrapped halfway around the cabin. The fully stocked dishes are always a huge plus! I think we'll be back. Thank you for a wonderful trip!"

Faith I. from Cincinnati, 06/08/2016

"The house was perfect for four fishermen. We had two boats and if our neighbors would have been there, parking would have been a problem. My only complaint is that the unit did not have sheets and towels and they charged us $75.00 for those items, which seems excessive to me."

Jim W. from Hixson, 05/08/2016

"Had an enjoyable time, but parking was an issue. There was not enough room for parking boats. By removing some trees/shrubs the parking could be improved greatly!"

from Menno, 05/01/2016

"very nice. we will be back"

Jolene R. from Pittsfield, 11/19/2015

"First we had to adjust our thinking because we booked a condo in the water and ended up in the cabin in the woods. That being said the company was very accomodating giving us a free night for our inconvienence. The property itself was large enough but very much in need of tlc. There was paint splattered over the kitchen cupboards. Damage to others, pit marks in the fridge. We also had to do some cleaning of surfaces in the bathrooms and kitchen. "

from Fairview, 11/04/2015

"very nice place. The unit required some maintance,back porch light not working, not enough propane for the grill,and the grill burners were pretty well burnt up and very rusty, no mop to clean floors upon leaving."

from West Mansfield, 10/07/2015

"Overall had a great time. This property needs an overhaul.The pictures displayed were deceiving- No screens-the stove did not work-the glass plate for the microwave was missing-no picnic table-no grill-only 3 dining chairs-and the place needed a good scrubbing"

from Mentor, 09/29/2015

"We had 8 girls stay for a weekend and we had a blast. The house is perfect and fits groups very comfortably! Totally worth the money"

Kelly J. from Lincoln Park, 08/13/2015

"We rented cabins 88 and 90 for a family get together that included 7 adults, 4 young adults and a baby. The space and sleeping arrangements were great, plus the cabins shared a green space. Could have used a few more kitchen utensils and things like hot mitts and dish towels. Screens were not in good shape so we could not open windows to enjoy the nice breeze. The pool and community were nice and management and maintenance were very friendly and efficient. Overall had a great stay."

from dearborn, 08/07/2015

"This is our fourth year coming to Island Club. Would recommend to anyone!"

Elyse F. from Parma Heights, 08/05/2015

"very satisfactory"

William D. from Saint Clairsville, 08/03/2015

"We had a good time. The house worked out great for all of us. There were some minor things needing updated but nothing interfered with us having a great time. Two smaller bedroom doors would stick and the person on the inside could not get out without help. Stopper for large tub was AWOL. Some minor fixes to the house would make the "look" better but again nothing interfered with our time there. TV was a very old style but worked. Beds were very comfortable. Propane grill was not usable as the burners were rusted out. The house was clean but would not say spotless. Walls and corners in bathroom could use a good scrubbing. Two of our group fixed the TV cabinet that was a little ****-eyed when arrived. The management staff was very quick to respond to an issue we had with one of our golf carts the first day. We couldn't have asked for faster response. They were very courteous and helpful. "

Mary L. from Greenville, 06/29/2015

"We stayed here for a get away for our adult children and more importantly our 7 year old grandson. Spent a day at Cedar Point Park & 2 days on Put in Bay.
Next time, I would do one or the other. Too much travel involved going back and forth to Cedar Point. There was enough to do with our grandson for one day on Put in Bay, but not much more than that. "

from Alsip, 06/20/2015

We had a great time everything was good"

Ron W. from Beaver Dam, 05/12/2015

"we had a great weekend"

Kara T. from West Salem, 11/03/2014

"This house really needs a deep cleaning, the bathroom walls were dirty near the toilets, the water didn't drain well in the showers and the house itself was cheaply made. It was fine for a weekend with the kids, as we made our own fun, but it felt like we overpaid even though we were on a bargain weekend rate."

from Vermillion, 10/14/2014

"It was a lot more than I expected. Beautiful cabins."

Reginald P. from Columbus, 10/06/2014

"We have stayed at several houses in the Island club and this was in the best shape. Clean, comfortable beds!"

from Jamestown, 09/30/2014

"This is the third year our group of professional women have stayed in Cabin 88. We like that it is located in the back of the Island Club. The cabin backs up against the woods and is generally in a quiet location. However, this year the cabin smelled of mold and was just stinky. We asked for air freshener but that didn't even touch the smell. I think it may be time to look for a different cabin for next year."

Kathleen M. from Tiffin, 09/17/2014

"We've been staying with Island Club Remtals for several years now and do not have a single complaint! The houses are clean, comfortable, and convenient. Perfect for groups to get away from the 9 to 5 chaos life that most of us live. The pool is a great place spend the afternoon as there's always something interesting going on. Best place to stay on the island and we'll be coming back year after year no matter what."

Bradley F. from Columbus, 09/09/2014

"Not a place for a family vacation. More like spring break. My group didn't mind but it is definitely a nonstop party at the island club"

from Elkart, 09/04/2014

"Just wanted to say that your employee Dottie was extremely helpful and she has a wonderful personality.
Some things need attention:Dirty behind the couch, windows needed cleaned, more lamps required. (We are readers) Need a railing on the front steps. Need a screen door at the entrance.Berry tree needs to be cut down. Berries all over the car and tracked into the home. Need basin and dish drain for the kitchen sink. Some trash in the back of the house needs picked up.
On the positive side, the rooms are roomy and very comfortable. Love the wrap around porch. #88 is wonderfully situated. Quiet and relaxing.I would highly recommend this place to my friends and family. We very much enjoyed our stay. Loved Golf Carting! My new sport! "

Gerald C. from Edgeworth, 08/16/2014

"We had a great time at Put-in-Bay and enjoyed this property. It was a great location on the island and was very quiet. It's also family friendly (at least during the week) and the pool was great. The grill was kinda dirty (had greasy water inside it), which only meant a quick cleaning, but it would've been nice not to have to clean up the mess. The picnic table wasn't very good and probably needs replaced. The TV was a small tube model from the 90's. I mean, a decent flat screen TV is only $500, so...? and the living room had a strange setup. The sink hose was broken, but I was able to fix it myself. The rear left burner on the stove didn't work. It might sound like a lot was wrong, but since we spent so much time outside, we only considered these things minor inconveniences. "

from Cincinnati, 08/10/2014

"Great place for the money!"

Angela S. from Canfield, 08/09/2014

"coming to island for over 15 years - family grew and we opted for larger home. Spent the first few hours recleaning and sanitzing home - was not impressed with cleanliness. Nice to have a space to ourselves - nice side yard to play in."

from Cincinnati, 08/09/2014

"The property management company was great! They accommodated my requests last minute and were excellent and easy to work with. The community of cabins were great. We had an excellent time for my best friend's bachelorette party and it was less expensive than staying at a hotel and we all had more space and a kitchen. I would definitely recommend it!! We will be back for sure."

Sara R. from Columbus, 08/05/2014

"I thought the house was o.k. This house was suppose to be and upgrade from the house I had originally booked on line. The house needs a good over all cleaning. ( Floors, counters, cabinets, etc. ) There were crumbs in the cabinets and on the couch. Ants in the Kitchen. No drain plugs in bath tubs or kitchen sink. The deck needs a power wash. Grill was nasty. Grease all over it. Propane was not hooked up and no propane in tank. The ash tray bucket was full. We had a good time. We didn't stay at the house a lot. I just expect a place to be clean clean when you rent a place. If this place was cleaned up. Maybe new spreads and fix things that are broken. I would stay there. We ate at the Old Forge They had Great creapes.

from POWHATAN, 07/21/2014

"Had a nice time. Liked the idea we got golf carts to see the island.

Did have a few problems: on our last day TV didn't work and no one to contact after hours...back door was screen on front door to let air in."

Marshall S. from Allen Park, 07/18/2014

"Excellent house! Great floor plan...open kitchen and living room. Comfortable beds and couches.
-Kitchen: stove - one burner didn't work.
Had some ants on the counter.
+Taxi drivers were very responsive!
Would definitely stay at Island Club again!"

from Hilliard, 07/18/2014

"My family and I have been coming back to the Island Club (Cabin #88)for the past 4 years. It is always a great experience. Dottie, Jerry and the whole staff are wonderful. The pool is clean and the perfect temperature. The cabin is always clean and for the price you can't beat the this for a week long stay. I always recommend the Island Club to my friends."

Paula R. from Kent, 06/30/2014

"Family friendly, quiet location away from town. Pool water was perfect temperature to cool off. Nice sized house and comfortable. Maintenance promptly responded to minor issues. One stove burner did not work."

from Mentor, 06/20/2014

"It was a very nice trip and cabin was spacious. The only negative thing I have to say is our cabin needed some maintenance. A few light bulbs were out and the ceiling fan in living room and lamps in there were not working .One of the bathtubs had a leaky faucet that dripped constantly."

Shannon M. from Groveport, 06/20/2014

"Awesome time"

from Pittsburgh, 06/10/2014

"Loved the location. Quick cheap taxi ride to the bars. Staff and neighbors were great. "

Kevin S. from Berea, 05/31/2014

"The location overall is pretty good, just don't expect to be downtown where all the action is. The unit itself was ok overall. The furniture, beds, and kitchen were in good condition. The bathrooms could use some updating and better cleaning. The washing machine was filthy and the entryway could have been cleaner. I don't know how often the trash pickup comes through, but it was pretty stinky when we arrived after the Memorial Day weekend, can only imagine how stinky it can get in the hot summers if was that bad after the weekend. Overall I think the places are a nice stay and would probably stay again for the right deal. It is not a five star place for sure but not a junky place either. "

from Little Hockey, 05/31/2014


from Cincinnati, 11/06/2013

"An interesting place occupied by weekenders as well as summer long tenants. Good staff and service. Stocked with bare minimum of essentials. BYO towels, bedding, etc. Could use an updating and airing....better lighting would be nice."

from West Salem, 10/10/2013

"I love going in September to Put In Bay it is quiet and relaxing. The Island homes are back in the woods and it is tranquil."

Theresa G. from Potersville, 10/03/2013

"no issues with getting to property etc.however upon arriving found that house needs a very good cleaning.very musty smell.water pressure low,and all men will tell you if the wife is not happy no one is.she did not feel comfortable with the cleanliness at well as other guests."

from Vermilion, 10/02/2013


Joseph C. from Waterford, 09/19/2013

"Good time!"

from Brookpark, 09/05/2013

"Nothing special but nice for a short stay. Went during the week. It would probably be a little loud on the weekend. Bring your own cookware. We had 6 large boiling pots but no skillet. "

from Akron, 09/05/2013

"I would have appreciated a check list when we checked in,to note what was not working. There were no stopper in the bathtub. There were no blankets, or a a broom. There was mold on the window frames, one burner on the stove did not work. Overall the stay was good, appreciated the golf cart. Neighborhood was quiet. Hours of the office should be provided, we had questions about keys for the golf cart which could not be answered until Monday, we arrived on Sunday evening around 6. Would have liked a view."

from Ann Arbor, 08/29/2013

"Was a nice place for the whole family to stay, would go back again. Management was nice and timely to every request."

Sarah O. from Dearborn, 08/15/2013

"Enjoyable to be here.Some items need attention: More lamps We are readers.Need a screen door on main entrance.All else was good.
Nice place to stay"

Gerald C. from Edgeworth, 08/09/2013

"I am going to be honest... I do not remember anything about the stay at the island club. I do remember arriving and it was a nice place, but that's it. "

from FARMINGTON HILLS, 08/09/2013

"We had a great stay at the Island Club. Our cabin gave us plenty of privacy, but also allowed us to interact w/ neighboring guests.

We really appreciated the convenience of the Island Club Taxi. Tony was an all-star helping get our group around the island all weekend, and providing recommendations on restaurants and other things to do on the island."

Austin M. from Metairie, 07/17/2013

"This is the 4th year we have stayed in this house at the Island Club. Jerry, Dottie and the staff are great and the place is clean and quiet. If you have any problems they are there within minutes to take care of it. I would and have recommended the Island Club to all my friends and co-workers. We will stay at the Island Club every time we stay at PIB."

Paula R. from Kent, 07/16/2013

"First time visiting this area, very good vacation. Will be coming back and staying here again. "

Cynthia L. from Shelby Township, 07/12/2013

"my friends and I come to PIB every year (this is our fourth year coming). the first two years we stayed at harriet's house (DO NOT RECOMMEND, owners are insane) and last year and this year we stayed at the island club. we stayed in #1 last year. #88 wasn't bad. there is NO yard to play outdoor games (like cornhole) so we buddied up with our neighbors in #90 and used their yard. sheet pans. everything else was awesome! the workers and taxi cab drivers are professional and great company!"

Jaclynn Y. from Garfield Heights, 07/09/2013

"The front 2 burners on our stove did not work and there were no tub stops for either tub."

Emily B. from Cincinnati, 06/16/2013

"We were in cabin #88. . . .the cabin was pleasant enough for the price. We had one main complaint that someone should take care of ASAP. There is a very noisy nest of birds living in the exterior wall of the side of the cabin w/ two bedrooms. You can see the hole they are using from the outside.

Amy H. from Tipp City, 06/08/2013

"staff was very accomadating and helpful on request. good place to stay for reasonable price. could have picked up trash in yard and emptied garbage can from last renter. overall good stay. i will rent again."

Anthony B. from Fond Du Lac, 05/23/2013

"We had a wonder time! No one in our party had ever been to the island before and we were all pleasantly surprised. The staff at the Island Club were all very accommodating and professional. We had an issue with one of our bathroom sinks when we got there so I made a phone call and it literally took the maintenance man 2 mins to get there and take care of the problem. We rented a golf cart for our day exploring which was in our driveway as soon as we arrived but we also used the taxi clubs service and both were wonderful. The beds were very comfortable, furniture very nice, and the kitchen was well stock with all of the utensils and pans anyone would need. We are more than happy with our decision to stay at the Island Rentals and WILL be returning SOON :) "

Kiersten Y. from Gnadenhutten, 05/14/2013

"We stay here very year its always been a great place. Fishing was a little tough this year but everything else was fine"

Ron W. from Beaver Dam, 05/13/2013

"It is a great spot if you don't have a boat, it is tricky getting a boat backed in the driveway when the other two cabins are occupied. The dryer needs a little KP also. Other then that I liked the location."

Mervin S. from Wentworth, 05/06/2013

" Excellent atmosphere"

Kevin S. from Toledo, 04/09/2013


Cabin #88 First weekend of this October . How much would that cost for Friday and Saturday night?

Asked On 07/08/2016 Answered on 07/11/2016

If you enter your dates into the reservation fields on our website, it shows live availability and pricing!

Ask A Question