Put-in-Bay Island Club #96 Su-Th $150-$300/nt, Fr-Sa $225-$1000/nt

"Cabin was clean and well stocked. Fridge doesn't quite close all the way and there's a Squirrel in the ceiling. "

"Great stay! "

"The house was laid out well. All but one mattress (double) was comfortable. We had no hot water in one bathroom but they fixed that less than an hour after I contacted them. Over-all I would rent again."

"It was not so great due to the rain☹️"

"House #96 was pretty much what I expected. After a call to get some light bulbs replaced witch the maintenance person quickly brought over our stay was very pleasant. "

"Great place! Clean, spacious, great price and close enough to down town. Will rent again."

"Loved the location, it was clean, would stay again, 1 small thing - mattresses need to be updated, very uncomfortable, but we will be back."

"Loved Loved Loved the house rental. Very comfortable and lots of room. We had no issues at all while we were there. Will be booking again for a future stay."

"We had a group of 8 and this is exactly what we needed, away from the congestion of the downtown area but not too far away. House was clean and had the amenities we needed for our short stay. "

"The cabin was very well put together and especially clean. Amenities were great and plenty of room to sleep. Only suggestion is the update the mobile app to reflect the new lock combinations. We will definitely be back next year."

"Overall very good. Need a few light bulbs replaced. Master shower very little pressure. Refrigerator needs light bulbs. Appliances worked good. "

"Very relaxing "

"There were a total of four on a relaxing weekend. The cabin is a little dated and could have been cleaned better but I can’t complain too much because of t is a cabin in the woods. Staff was very accommodating and answered all of my questions promptly and respectfully. "

"We were pleasantly surprised with this rental property. Very spacious, clean and well stocked for 6 adults. The location was nice, far enough back so there wasn't much traffic. Management was helpful getting checked in and it was very convenient that the golf cart was delivered for us. Would recommend this property and will probably stay again ourselves too. We enjoyed the State Park, Joe's bar, the winery and brewery, and all the sites from the golf cart. "

"very nice place updated with a very well stocked kitchen"

"The home was clean and comfortable. We always enjoy our time at Island Club. Highly recommended for groups that do not want to spend a lot of money on eating out since you can cook right at the house. "

"The cabin was in need of some updates. Shower in master bedroom had to be unclogged, & a water leak need fix. Thank goodness for the Island Club property Management had someone over in the matter of minutes to snake the drain and fix everything. There where a few other things that need attended to, but when you only manage the property and don’t own it, it’s hard something to get the owners to do updates. Island club was an awesome area to stay. Loved the island and good times with friends. "

"It was great. It was a short getaway for myself, my mom and sister. We hope to go back to #96 next year. "

"Overall had a pleasant stay."

"This year the rental experience was not good. We dealt with bed bugs, flooded kitchen/utility area, and broken handle on oven.
Because of the bed bugs, 2 of us had to sleep in a different house. The flood was caused by the washer drain hose not properly inserted into the drain. The handle on the oven fell off when we opened it."

"It was an awesome time "

"We had a great time staying here. There was plenty of space for everyone, and it was very easy to get around the island. The island club taxi made it very easy to safely go anywhere we wanted. "

"I had a great exeperience staying at the Island Club. The place was very clean and prepared for us. It was worth the price tag to have our own space and be able to grill out and keep our own food. All the staff was very friendly and helpful. Would recommend to a friend. "

"My friends and I stayed at Island Club rentals for my bachelorette party and we had a blast! The cabin was just the thing for staying there nights up on the island. The Island Club resort had the mini party busses that we used as transportation all over the place! "

"So much to do on the Island. We love it there. Like this property for the privacy even though it's not real close to the pool. Management was great."

"Very nice and close to downtown Put In Bay. Cabin was everything we wanted and expected. Very quite in the evening which we liked. We made Hooligans Irish restaurant are favorite place to meet for lunch. Did a lot of bike riding on the island. Just had a very pleasant time."

"The house I stay at was very roomy. I love the fact it has a washer/dry/cable/ central air.I didn't give it a five star because it wasn't clean and the floor in the restroom need to be replaced, but overall price was unbeatable for a house the holds eight people."

"Nice home, exactly what we needed."

"we had a great time and the house was good"

"The vactation rental experience was terrific. We had a shuttle that came every 15 minutes which was great for travel to and from attractions. I enjoyed my stay, and plan on returning. If the weather would not have rained two out of the three days I would have gave my stay 10 out of 10."

"the home was not a very clean house at all the carpet needs to be cleaned the floor in kitchen needs to be clean the house needs repairs i was not happy about the house being dirty "

"We were looking for an inexpensive weekday getaway and we found it at Island Club. The only problem was the kitchen floor was horrible and in need of replacing. Funny enough the guy came to measure the floor for a laminate replacement so it looks like it is going to be updated...which is good. The shower in the master didn't drain so I went and bought cheap flip flops to wear in the shower. Other than that it was clean. It definitely needed some updating and some items taken care of (the one sliding door didn't work) but all in all.....a great place to stay where you don't have to spend a ton of money."

"Amazing"

"There was a young man by the name of Nick walking around playing guitar and singing. You need to hire this guy, he had everyone laughing and singing. Nick made a good time a great time! This guy is the next 'MAD DOG". Hope to see you all this fall when we return. Thank you for your hospitality. "

"Was very comfortable"

"Friends and family from Texas came to Ohio to enjoy Put In Bay. Great place for multiple people to stay. Will check out another cabin next time we come!"

"This was a great trip. "

"We stayed during the week and the Club was very busy with families. It was away from the party crowd and much quieter than other places we have stayed on the island. When we had a problem it was always attended to immediately. "

"a +"

"Fun get away destination. Great for groups to hang out and enjoy the summer days. Staff was very responsive to our requests but our requests should have never been needed. The guest shower knob was broken so our guests couldn't use hot water for the first few days in that shower. Cabin bathroom floors were not cleaned when we arrived. Aside from towels renters will need to remember to bring a dish towel and sponge to do dishes. I knew we needed to bring our own sheets and towels but I didn't think to bring a dish towel. I think little fixes in the cabin would go a long way considering the price. Like properly attaching electric outlets to the wall. Otherwise nice getaway location."

"Great mid-week stay at the Island Club. Mid-week can't be beat. No major crowds and obnoxious partiers to deal with . House was a bit dated and needs some modern updates, but overall no complaints. Island Club management and staff are truly great to deal with. They work hard to mske sure you have the best stay possible. "

" We celebrated our daughter's 25th birthday! We are extremely happy with our decision to book a weekend at this resort. The Island Club resort is perfect for groups of people and all the neighboring guests were very friendly and fun! We certainly recommend this resort! "

"Our 9th Consecutive opening weekend"

"!"

"Awesome!"

"I would definitely consider going back in the future. The whole process was stress free and I felt like everyone I talked to in setting the trip up and while I was there acted in a professional manner. I liked the convenience of having the taxi shuttles running throughout the day and it was cheap which was a major plus. I think my only regret is that me and my friends didn't stay longer. "

"It was great except for the mildew or moldy smell in this unit our other unit was fine across the street. J "

"We stayed up at the Island Club for a bachelorette party for the weekend. The Island Club was the perfect location for the 18 of us! We rented a few houses which worked out great and allowed us to stay in and cook on Friday night, then go out on the boardwalk Saturday. It was great and I would recommend staying here!"

"The Island Club was a great place to stay, the staff was very professional, upon arrival we realized we had no towels, we told the lady that drove by to check us in, we had towels in 10 min. Do not let the distance from the strip deter you, there are taxi's constantly driving through the Island Club, Tony was our guy, a call to him, and you are partying in 10 to 15 minutes. Also, they are pretty good about keeping the noise down later in the night, the Island Club is a great place to enjoy PIB, within a half hour of our arrival, we knew the people in all of the houses around ours. One other advantage it is very close to the miller ferry. Check them out, its worth your time."

" We rented two homes they were good and clean and well kept,had everything that 18 fisherman could ask for. Everyone had a great time and will be back next year. We have been staying at the I-Club for the last ten years "