Put-in-Bay Island Club #1 Su-Th $150-$300/nt, Fr-Sa $225-$1000/nt

"Awesome time as usual."

"Location was ideal, quite, owner collected some items from lot without prior notice."

"weather was generally good for up there that time of year.."

"Awesome awesome awesome house to stay in and located in the perfect spot to the event. Fully furnished and well kept. We will have to come in the summer to enjoy the hot tub. "

"lack of parking is the only negative"

"It was awesome. We loved our home and cant wait to come back again. This is pur 3rd year coming and weve decided to make it an annual event. We even got family that came from Las Vegas..they had a ball too."

"We had a great time in Island Club #1! It was just what we expected! We would definitely return to this rental! "

"Bob is the man, the place was great. Nice location, very clean, large, accommodating. Will be sure to return!"

"we loved every minute of the trip. our home was in the best location and well taken care of, despite the kitchen window...great food, friendly people and the weather was GREAT this year. ready to book for next year."

"There were 37 family members who rented 7 homes in this area for a five night stay in Put-in-Bay. The location was conveniently located to all the activities on the island. The island had activities for our variety of ages - age 3 to age 74! We were there the first week of Aug. and had ideal weather.Outside grills and well equipped kitchens enabled all 37 of us to eat together in the evenings on picnic tables outside one of the homes. Yet we enjoyed the fine restaurants on the island and the "catch" of the fishermen in our group who went deep sea fishing at other times! It is a picturesque island with history, exploring, entertainment, and an opportunity for relaxation. I think we all would readily return to this island."

"The house was very nice on the inside, actually we were surprised how nice for being a rental. The only things we weren't happy about was the window over the kitchen sink was severely broke, and you could see it was broke from the inside. I called and reported it right away so we didn't get blamed for it. Also the table and chairs on the back deck looked like they hadn't been cleaned this year. As it was it rained most of the time and couldn't use them anyway. Overall I would recommend it and would stay there again."

"Beautiful home. Beautiful area! Wonderful people! "

"House #1 was layed out perfectly. It felt much more spacious than it appeared from the outiside. Very close and convenient to the pool. The pool is undersized for such a large community. It's a good place to sit and cool off but do not anticipate doing any laps. The location of the villas is just close enough to the "Down town" area; just a 10 minute ride via golf cart. I would stay here again and will recommend to all my friends. "

"The 8 of has a great time. Some of us it was our first time at Put in Bay. Our house was away from town and worked out perfect. The Island club has its own taxi service, it worked out great only 3.00 a person, drivers very friendly. We rented Island house 1, location was perfect. The out door yard off the sliding glass door and back porch needs some attention. "

"Our Cabin was great. It was very open and fit our group very well. The neighborhood was perfect for a long weekend with friends. "

"The place was clean and a great location. Some issue with ants as we had last year I suggest a strong insect barrier inside and outside in early spring"

"home away from home, very nice cabin."

"The house is beautiful and has everything!
Plenty of room and nicely set up.

The area is almost totally college boys with lots of drinking and heavy partying. The loud music and noise was a problem for our little one (and big ones) at night. The quiet hours are not enforced."

"only complaint about house was... the floors were dirty. Everyone's feet or socks were black from dirty carpets. Otherwise we were happy. Other complaint was other taxis were not allowed to take us to the island club, even drop us off at the entrance. "

"We all had a great time. We have stayed in House #1 before & we love it there. Everything was clean & in good shape. Will definitely rent this house again."

"I, along with my friends who joined me on this trip, were extremely pleased with our stay at the Island Club, but specifically at house #1. Island club was very accommodating; I received emails several weeks leading up to our trip, to the day we arrived, lending very helpful tips to help make our trip the best possible. Island Club also has a smartphone app that I downloaded which helped us navigate the island, gave check in and check out reminders, among many other things. The house itself was impeccable. It was very clean, spacious, and had amenities we didn't even expect to have, such as the hot tub, and an entertainment system that played music in the house as well as on the back deck. We had an absolute wonderful time. We will definitely be back!"

"EXCELLENT HOUSE IS CLEAN AND WELL KEPT!!"

"We enjoyed this cabin so very much! We want to come back and will try for this same cabin!

It is roomy and comfortable! The hot tub is worth the extra money and will pay for the use again!"

"Awesome time!!!!"

"Great weather, great friends and a great house. We had a good time and we will always request House #1. With a few minor problems, the house is always the best part of our stay. It is comfortable and has a great desk to sit outside if you like, which we do like. Wouldn't have it any other way! "

"We loved the place! One of the nicest locations within Island Club. The cottage was very cute, clean, and comfortable. The living room readily accommodated our large group for easy reminiscing. The patio and deck made you want to be outside. The kitchen layout was great for our group; plus, it was well stocked with everything we needed and more. The steam-shower enclosure was a nice touch. A little confusion on the size of beds but all were in nice shape except the one full-size (worked ok for only 2 nights). We had a little issue with the location of the fireplace mantel. The staff was great to work with. We would definitely stay here again!"

"2ND TIME BACK WITH THE FAMILY LOVE HOUSE # 1
WOULD NOT STAY ANY OTHER HOUSE"

"Great Experience. Will be back next year"

"I visit the Island Club every year. The staff is absolutely amazing!!!. They are very patient and tentative. I rent the same house, which is always spotless and beautiful. If you have never been to Put In Bay, be sure to visit soon. The picturesque scenery makes you feel like you are hundreds of miles from home on a private island. I want to thank the staff at the Island Club for making my visit enjoyable year after year. Next stay is only 11 months away....let the countdown begin!!! "

"Very good experience. I will definately reserve the cabins in the future."

"Always such a good time!"

" After an overbooking mix up the property managers put us in rental property #1. The house was very nice and in a great location. This was my 4th year staying at the island club and this years experience would only make me want to return for a 5th. "