Put-in-Bay Island Club #15 Su-Th $150-$300/nt, Fr-Sa $225-$1000/nt

"My husband and I visited Put-in-Bay for the vintage car races in September 2021. We rented number 15 and absolutely love the place. When we arrived it was one row off from the pool and close enough to the entrance to come and go quickly from our vacation home. The vacation rental was very clean and decorated wonderfully. It even had an electric fireplace that put off heat and gave great ambiance. This three bedroom two bath was very spacious. With the master bedroom on one side of the house and the other two bedrooms on the other side of the living room. This would provide great privacy if you brought your children or another family. We even were able to have a fire out back one evening which was a welcomed surprise. We never got to use the large deck and grill but they both would have been a great addition if we would have stayed longer. The check-in and check-out process was extremely easy. We would highly recommend staying and vacation rental # 15!"

"Good location in the complex, very clean"

"We took a mid-week trip to Island Rentals #15 and had a perfect vacation. Property manager was extremely friendly and helpful with getting checked in and answering our questions. The unit itself was just as pictured. The location by the pool was a plus. We had no problem staying with 2 families of 4. Hope to be back again. "

"This home was clean, recently renovated & charming. We enjoyed the stay in the home & at the club. It was bright & cheery and appliances were new, water was hot. The only downside was with 4 adults & our Roku TV the internet service was sketchy.
It was our first stay at Put-In-Bay and we found it very enjoyable. We had 3 generations in the home, and we all were happy with the experience. "

"Fun times and a nice place!"

"The perfect location for a long weekend getaway with couples. Amenities included and renovations to this unit were all great. Very cute, open and spacious. Great for a group of 6-8. Property was as presented in description and very clean. Owner even stopped by to say hello and was very friendly. Great location to everything as well. Totally recommend for family, couples or may try it for a girls getaway! Only suggestion would be to add a mirror to each bedroom since only two mirrors in whole place, one in each bathroom. Especially if hosting a girls weekend! Oh, and a can opener, did not find one or read that we had to bring own. Thanks for a great stay!!!"

"Dottie is awesome and her cabin is one of the nicest we've stayed at. Will rent again!"

"The house was perfect. Bedrooms spacious. Location good. Dottie the owner was very kind. Her personality was terrific. My family and I could not have been happier with the home or the staff. Thankyou for everything."

"The house was absolutely perfect! The owner was there when we arrived and was so nice to us! Everything qas decorated cute. Clean. Couldnt have been any happier with everything! "

"House has the cutest decor, comfortable furniture and we more than had enough space for 8 of us! Its up to date and modern. Its close to the pool and its not far from all the restaurants and bars. We had a great time! We would definitely stay again. The one thing that would have been nice is if the bedrooms had mirrors also so it helps with getting ready. Such a great place and a fun weekend! "

"we had a fantastic stay. The cabin was very clean, beds were very comfortable, and the location of the cabin was right across from the pool which was perfect. My family stayed a week and honestly we would have stayed longer. Felt like home away from home. Met the owner of the cabin and she seemed very nice and she actually cared about the property. We are definitely looking to book this cabin again next year. "

"Our rental home was gorgeous great job on the remodel. The beds were comfortable, the home was very clean. I will stay here again, management was there to greet us upon arrival and everything was as described."

"House 15 was beautiful- looked like a brand new home. Very modern, farmhouse style. Very clean and well supplied. Reserving, checking in and out was a breeze. We needed a new propane tank for the grill and was delivered right away- great service! We will for sure stay at the Island Club again and hopefully in 15. This house is perfect for couples or a family. "

"Our stay was wonderful and the staff were great. The property we stayed at was very dated. The furniture and interior were not up to date or very nice. The property was very clean and everything worked out."

"The best getaway you could ask for"

"We had a fantastic time in Put-In-Bay. Island Club #15 has a great location. It's close to the entrance and a few steps from the pool. The Island Clubs are a short cab or golf cart ride from downtown. The outside patio was great for grilling out and relaxing."

"It was a very good 9 days"

"It was a great place to stay with friends. The grill was extremely useful."

"N/A"

"The Island Club is great but #15 is way outdated. The pull out couch immediately fell to the ground when pulled out. We had to use the cushions from the couch to keep it up. There were random patches in the wall everywhere. The back door in the laundry room does not lock. We really enjoyed the environment in the neighborhood! Just disappointed in #15 for the amount we paid compared to the others we saw while Mingling with others. Everyone was very nice and welcoming and the staff was helpful when needed. "

"Our trip was great and the location of the Island Club was perfect for the type of crowd we had. The club requires you to bring sheets and pillow cases, but that really was the only negative I can think of. Shuttles buses run all the time and everyone has a good attitude at the club."

"Epic"