Put-in-Bay Island Club #76 Su-Th $175-$325/nt, Fr-Sa $275-$1100/nt

"The State Island club rentals was very good. Property was clean and in good shape property management company was very complicated. Would recommend staying there to all friends and family."

"Nice place, sure it's wilder on weekends!"

"Home to us was nicer than other homes around. Worked great for our group we would definitely stay again. Island Club is perfect for a group to stay and explore the bay. Pool is smaller than appears in images. If you rent a golf cart rent from Island Club they drop off and pick up. Our group would stay again just not during mayfly season. "

"It was very enjoyable. Clean and friendly."

"It was awesome! Thank you��"

"It was a great experience. No issues with house or property. Rented a 8 passenger golf cart and it was already at the property ready to use."

"Perfect!"

"Nice place to stay and have fun !!! "

"One shower didn’t have a curtain and was filled with bugs. Was a lot of dust in the bedrooms. Also the front door wasn’t locked when I arrived. But other than that it was a good spot. "

"The property was nice and in a good place to access everything. The home we stayed in was comfortable and clean. I would recommend it highly. You also have access to ring Golf Cars on the property so you don't have to drive your car around the island. Me and everybody with me enjoy this day and plan on returning"

"We all had a great time and we were takin care of by the staff. Dottie came to our cabin as soon as we checked in and gave us a list of cabs etc that really helped out. Her son Tony took us everywhere we needed to go. Tge cabin was clean when we arrived "

"It was great, only a few issues but other than that the place was great."

"Great time even though the weather didn't always cooperate. Thanks to Dottie and her staff always there to help out. Thanks to Tracy in reservations for all your help with are changing reservations"

"We had an awesome week stay! House is everything expected and the island rental staff is extremely accommodating, already looking forward to next year!"

"great place, had plenty of furnished items in the cabin wich was great when ya live 1200 miles away. easy to get to"

"Great stay as always. The property is well kept, and the staff is very easy to work with. My only criticism is that the WiFi needs to be improved.

Even with that said, would definitely stay there again!"

"This company was excellent with anything we needed for the entire stay. There was no internet accessible which was inconvenient, but everything else was great. Fantastic location from the boat and close to everything. "

"10th Annual trip with friends, great time with great friends"

"Average"

"Aside from the windy conditions we had a great stay at Island Club Rental. As usual Dottie and her crew took good care of us. Dottie called me personally to make sure my group new all the options when the roads were getting sealcoated"

"good time nice for our group"

"Very clean and comfortable. Recently updated."

"Good pleasant experience will rent again."

"Fun time, nice house with good amount of space. Front deck was large and nice to use. Pool could be a little bigger but close proximity to the house."

"Dirty inside and out. No help on Sun. when we checked in. Appliances,washer, TV, microwave, etc. did not work.On sight manager promised us a full nights refund for leaving a day early, instead of us moving AGAIN! Did not receive refund."

"Very friendly staff checking in to home and getting our golf cart. House was clean location was great not sure I would take small children to this location as the taxi vans drive like their on the Daytona 500 racetrack day and night. Overall a great time was had and we would return. "

"I found the rental in a great location. It was easy to get around on the island. Can't wait to go back."

"It was a rough week to fish but we did fine. It was nice to see the new washer and dryer. We didn't have one last year. The new flooring was also nice. We would like to see a set of bowls which we didn't have any. Also a full set of forks, knives and spoons. Also a nice complete set of pots. Over all the place was clean but we did find mouse dropping in the pots and pans. Also the gas tank for the grill was empty. "

"We enjoy staying here every year."

"Everything about Island Club was wonderful. We will come back for years to come. Many local businesses offered discounts on the welcome flyer. We failed to mention the coupon at time of call, but asked about it upon delivery. We were told it was applied. Later we did math and it wasn't, called the store and they rudely told us sorry about our luck. I would ask Cameo to advertise next time... their customer service has always been better."

"Very satisfied with my stay. Cant wait to stay there again! "

"This is a great place to stay while at Put in Bay. "

"For the price you can't beat it!!!!!! Great location and very suitable quarters. "

"The house we stayed in was very clean when we arrived and was a comfortable stay for the weekend. "

"Fun and convenient"

"Very friendly staff. Willing to go the extra mile to make everything perfect."

"Great place to stay when at Put-In-Bay!"

"We loved it, we had a few issues at first but they were all taken care of immediately"

"The home was a little rough but we didn't come for the cabin. It's a nice quiet island during the week with fun things for kids to do and a nice playground a short golf cart ride away. The pool was a nice perk. "

"The house was kept in good condition. Everything worked fine. I was very satisfied with this house. I've been coming to the island club for over 20 yrs and this house was one of the better houses"

"We had a great time with our 2 small grandchildren and 2 adult sons at Put-in-Bay. We were close to the pool and the neighborhood was very peaceful and charming. The house was very clean and well maintained!"

"Took 10 guys for a bachelor party for two nights, place was bigger than I thought it would be. Slept all of us very comfortable. Unit was nice and clean all as advertised. Would defiantly go back again!!"

"this past weekend was the best time of my life. i can not wait to come back to visit."

"We really enjoyed our stay at the Island Club, from Jerry and the reservation group to Dottie and her on site help,always very accommodating to are various needs. Thanks for another great stay."

"6 of us went to Put-In-Bay for a guys weekend in mid-April and stayed at this house. There were 6 twin beds and 2 couches. Plenty of floor space as well. All appliances worked properly and the unit was reasonably clean. For those not familiar with the island, you drive to the ferry and take a $7/25minute ferry and then either pay $3 per person for a bus ride or rent a golf cart. We were lucky with the weather, high 60s Friday and Saturday. Sunday was 48, 30mph wind and pouring rain. Not fun fairy ride!!

This unit has a full fridge and ice trays, outside grill and a microwave. We chose to go to the general store and the liquor store and spent good part of time on the deck. Deck is great size and about 40 feet from the other houses. We were lucky to not be around and crazy people, mainly because 80/82 houses in Island Club were occupied by walleye fisherman.

5minute golf cart ride to town for some good restaurants and bars. Tippers was great for lunch, inexpensive and very tasty. I would estimate that only 1/2 of the places were open for the season, as the island technically "opens" on April 1. Island Club was easy to find and great place for the $$. I would highly recommend to anyone who likes the outdoorsy-feel along with the ability to go to town at any point, and won't leave negative reviews if they have to do a little cleaning when they get there and when they leave. I did not need management at all, but I did see them driving around between 9a-6p.

Will be back for sure!!"

"I went with a group of 5 total people and we had plenty of room for more! After unpacking the car and everything was in the house, we noticed a strong foul smell from the hall bathroom. We were tired from our journey getting there and unpacking the car so we just dealt with the smell by using room scent and keeping the door closed. We would have changed houses had we discovered that sooner! The house was fairly clean- you just have to count on the previous house attendants to have cleaned up after themselves for it to be clean when you arrive. The house was spacious and comfortable though. The kitchen only had four chairs at the table so we had to bring in an outdoor chair to sit inside together. It was nice that appliances were available, but things were used and dated. The outdoor front deck was large enough for a dozen people and there was a picnic table conveniently there as well. We brought a car to the island but golf carts were available to rent from the Island Club, if needed. Not far from downtown, we were still close to interesting locations such as the State Park, cemetery, Joe's restaurant/bar. I would recommend Island Club to others! It was a nice getaway!"

"The rental homes we rented were clean, efficient, relaxing atmospheres that allowed our group to experience something they never would have been able to if not for Island Club's generosity."

"Stayed for 2 nights with a total of 10 guests. For what I paid, I was very pleased with our house. There were a few very minor maintenance things that need to be handled, but none of these were bad enough to complain about. At check in I was told that if we needed anything, give the office a call. The grill worked, tv was great, had positive reviews on the beds. Check out was super easy. The app is plain but effective. The pool was cute with lots of chairs and close to our house. We had no problems with our neighbors. The Island Club taxis are great (we called Tony nearly each time we went out) and when they say to call as you're getting on the ferry to the island, they mean it - Tony was there even before we got off the ferry. I will definitely stay again."

"Every thing went well. Any problems was taken care of instantly. "

"The people I spoke with on the phone were very freindly.
The house was very clean besides a black sock sitting in the middle of the floor from the past vistor.
House was a little farther than I assumed to downtown. Taxi price was very reasonable to get to downtown from the house. Key pad to enter house is very hard to see in the dark.
House was very spacious.
Very nice deck on front to enjoy the weather. "

"I was pleased with the size and Location of the cabin, The overall setup was very comfortable. The Cabin was very cozy and felt like a home away from home. I am definitely going to Use there services again."

"Overall the experience was great. Carpets were cleaned the day of our arrival and the house was still ready by 4 p.m. My only suggestion would be to provide oven mitts for removing baked items from the oven."

"The vacation rental was very nice. We rented two sis by side for all our family. We were close to every thing. The pool was nice and close to our houses. I would rent these houses again. Love Put in Bay."

"A relaxing little spot in the center in the island."

"This was the perfect house for my bro's bachelor party. The taxi service was especially convenient and everyone had an awesome time. "

"It was a great trip. There was enough to do all week but also a nice relaxing pace to the island during the week."

"We had a great time! The rental was in a good location, very festive atmoshpere. The staff was friendly and responsive to our needs. I would definately recommend it! "

"Will continue to use Island Club in the future...I was not happy about one of our sliding glass doors not locking but overall experience was good"

"We were there for a bachelorette party weekend with 23 of us between two homes and had an absolute BLAST! The homes were well kept and no complaints! We had trouble locking the door one night but management came without hesitation and all was great! We will be back for another trip very soon! Thank you again!!"

"It was a a blast!"

"Everyone was friendly. Island Club taxi service was superb! The house wasnt as clean as I expected it to be upon arrival. The cleaning staff needs to do a better job at checking the kitchen cabinets and cleaning out old food. Other than that...a great weekend trip!"

"As Usual we had a great experience At Island Club starting with Jerry and the reservation group & Dottie with the cleaning and maintenance crew. Being a past resort owner it a pleasure to see the constant care and updates done to each home each year.
Thanks for a great week, looking forward to next year. "

"Overall it was a great experience. The cabin could use a few fix-ups. Screens on sliding glass doors all ripped up, breakers constantly tripping in the bathroom, shower head hardly gives out water etc..."

"Good location, part of a close niche community, making it really easy to get out and bond with all of the neighbors. House was surprisingly well kept and more than adequate for what we needed. "

"It was very nice stay, the weather could of been warmer and next time we will come more in the summer. but overall was very nice time."

"The Island Club was the perfect place for our group of 16 to stay. Lodging was much nicer than originally expected. It was spacious, accommodating, and the staff was inviting. Not being located within walking distance of downtown was not an issue whatsoever, as there were cabs readily available to take us there for very reasonable pricing. My entire group enjoyed their stay!"

"Despite all the warnings I had received about PIB being a party town, I think we must've timed it right to visit the sunday-tuesday of Labor day Weekend, because it was virtually tranquil. We enjoyed touring the quaint shops and winerys. And it was especially nice to be able to relax in the comfortableness of our cottage at the end of the day!"

"The management greeted us and was ready to answer any questions, the house was clean and had everything we needed. Thanks for a great vacation."

"Plenty of room, clean, quiet and safe."

"We enjoyed the vacation and were pleased with the location and pool."

"Very pleasant property"

"We had so much fun! Everyone was so nice!"

"This home was great for our annual group get together. The weather was a bit cool for the pool but its there for you and easy to access. Several minor issues with the house, Doors sticking, light bulbs out, all minor stuff. staff drives by your house constantly so very easy to ask questions. Golf carts delivered right to the door and picked up when checking out. very convenient. We will stay with Island Rentals again. "

"I would like to thank Tony and Jerry for making my job easy. We had a great time. Jerry was very organized and did a great job on the front end getting our trip booked and explaining everything we needed. Tony went above and beyond to make our stay perfect. He needs a raise! Thanks for everything. "

"As always everyone at Island Club were very helpful. Every year we are pleased to see the new upgrades done to the properties, (flat screen TV's, new screen doors, appliances, etc.) Special thanks to Jerry for his help in reservations & Dottie for all her hands on assistance on site. (stopped every time she saw us to ask if we needed anything). Units were spotless when we arrived.
Thanks for a wonderful stay,
Joe G"

"I would tell anyone about our stay in our villa. This is the third time I had stayed in the Island club rentals and would stay many more times. I have to say that they are very clean and bery well kept up. Not sure what the ladies names were that drove arond on the golf carts helping people but they always had a friendly face and were very helpful with any questions or directions we needed. Thank you again for a wonderful and safe home to stay in. We will be doing it again. :)"