Check Out our Put-in-Bay Island Club June Specials! We have special deals for just about everybody, especially Teachers! Call 216-898-9951 for more information.

Frosty Bar Gifts

Frosty Bar Gifts
252 Delaware Ave.
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456 419-285-3278 https://www.frostys.com/

Frosty Bar Gifts is the mecca for all of your dedicated Frosty Bar gear. Once you try their eclectic food options, like pizza, subs, gyros, or breakfast specialties like Billy’s Banana Pancakes, grab an ice cold beer and head outside to Big Man’s Burrito Stand situated in the rear of the property. If you have a picky eater in your party, or you just want variety in one stop, Frosty’s is the ultimate destination! Prefer to eat on the go or where you're staying? Frosty Bar now offers online ordering from your phone or computer. After you’ve eaten, rush to the gift shop to show your spirited love for all things Frosty.

Outdoor Fun at Frosty’s

  • The Backyard at Frosty’s Bar
  • Big Man’s Burrito Stand
  • Live Entertainment


Conveniently Located Shopping
Hop on a golf cart and cruise the downtown Delaware Avenue strip. There are multiple shops to choose from, like Cruisin Tunes for all of your music. Stop by The Candy Bar and enjoy mountains of sweet treats like ice cream, fudge, cookies, and all sorts of nostalgic candy. Lovella Fashion Apparel features a wide variety of high-end sunglasses, swimwear, handbags, and more! All of these great shops and more are located within a stone’s throw on centrally located Delaware Avenue.

No matter which fabulous retailer you visit first, you will want to see them all and browse their unique offerings. Each Put-in-Bay merchant has a specialty that stands out. Del Sol, for example, has more than 600 items that change color when exposed to sunlight! Once removed from the sunlight, they return to their original color. The Great Lakes Tobacconist is another example of a Put-in-Bay specialty. He creates Put-in-Bay inspired smokes and tobaccos, hand rolled in the Dominican Republic.

Shop until you drop. And then shop some more! Visit our lodging page and BOOK Now!!