Call 216-898-9951 to book for 2024! Big summer weekends are already nearing capacity, don't miss the Put-in-Bay event you're eyeing, book now!

Village Bakery & Cafe

Village Bakery & Cafe
104 Delaware Ave.
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456 419-285-5351

Village Bakery and Cafe is “The Island’s Only Bakery”. If you need a wedding cake for your Put-in-Bay wedding, Village Bakery and Cafe is your best and only option. Pauline has been the owner here for 21 years and knows her stuff. Village Bakery and Cafe are sure to be here for many more years to come if Pauline and her staff continue to cook up such scrumptious edibles on a summerly basis. Not having a wedding? Well, you can still eat breakfast. Stroll by in the morning and give it a sniff. You won’t be able to resist coming in for freshly ground coffee and pastries such as butter croissants, apple turnovers, scones, and all manner of muffins.

Village Bakery and Cafe Sweets

  • Cakes
  • Turnovers
  • Croissants
  • Scones
  • Muffins
  • Cinnamon Rolls
  • And much more...

For lunch you can have a tasty sandwich, pizza bagels, or even a quarter pound all-beef hot dog. Save room for dessert. The headliner here is the Cassada Cake (from the Arabic qashatah meaning “bowl”). It’s sponge cake with a custard / strawberry filling and whipped cream topping. No other Put-in-Bay restaurants can compete with Village Bakery in the arena of cake wars. Aside from the variety of sweets and sandwiches they also offer a selection of healthy salads!

Village Bakery and Cafe Salads

  • Village Salad - seasonal greens, tomato, ham, cheese, pistachios, and craisins
  • Tuna Salad - Starkist brand tuna, celery, sweet relish, onions, mayonnaise, and sour cream
  • Chicken Salad - roasted chicken, celery, sweet onion, sour cream, mayonnaise, and ranch
  • Vegetarian Delight - seasonal greens, tomato, cucumber pistachios, and craisins

Come in on a Sunday for Pauline’s cinnamon rolls. Get there early as there tends to not be enough to go around. All delicious yums are handmade, so personalized orders are not a problem and, in fact, encouraged. Having your own event? You won’t believe this, Village Bakery and Cafe not only caters but makes a professional habit of it. Deli trays, lunch and dinner buffets, and large party trays: they’ll bring it right to your grateful guests. Village Bakery and Cafe wants to make your event special. Call to cater your next party!