Island Club 4-Person Golf Cart #40

Fantastic

Anonymous from Muncie - Posted: 9/13/2025

We have been coming here for years and stayed at many places but have to say as a group we love the Island club condos the best. Always clean and has all the amenities we need for our stay.

Anonymous from Euclid - Posted: 8/7/2025

Excellent stay, clean and perfect spot for old friends to get together!

Anonymous from Hudson - Posted: 8/20/2019

the cabin was great, it's situated back in the woods and is very tranquil, but still within walking distance of the main bar/restaurant scene.

Anonymous from Lakewood - Posted: 6/12/2019

Great place to stay! Awesome back yard with fire pit for friends and family

Anonymous from Zanesville - Posted: 9/26/2018

The rental was clean upon arrival and had all the amenities listed available. Our neighbors were considerate and nice. Duff introduced himself the first night and was available if we needed assistance.

Anonymous from Belleville - Posted: 7/24/2018

Thanks for the review Whitney! Duff and his family are great hosts and we are glad you enjoyed the trip.

Island Club staff

I had a great time at the house. It was clean and convenient, minus the swarm of mayflies! Haha!

Anonymous from Chicago - Posted: 7/11/2017

A great place to stay if you are looking for the perfect relaxing Put-In-Bay getaway and are trying to avoid the crowdedness of some of the other rental places. Having your own fire pit was great, staff was extremely friendly and helpful, and it is in walking distance from downtown. Would highly recommend/stay again.

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 7/5/2017

The cottage was everything I expected. Beautiful area, quiet and only a minute golf cart ride from downtown. I would definitely stay here again :)

Anonymous - Posted: 10/4/2016

Duff took time out of the day to introduce himself and welcomed us to the island. Condo had plenty of room for the 6 people we had with us. Everyone on the island was polite.

Anonymous from Florence - Posted: 9/27/2016

5 of us stayed here for 3 nights. It's a huge cabin split into 3 sections. Guests can rent side 1 or 2 and the owner stays on the upper level. The cabin exceeded our expectations with big rooms, a beautiful landscape, and a very friendly owner. It's simple out there and there is no wifi and terrible cell reception so be ready to actually get some quiet! Definitely rent a golf cart to get around, cabs are typically 3$ a person but it's so much fun to drive around and see the place. Wear socks, my only complaint is the carpet was dirty, our feet were black the whole time. We thoroughly did a pest and bed bug check and there was nothing to be found. No DVD player so if you plan on letting kids watch some movies bring a portable however the tv does have dish. We will be renting this again for sure and it's worth the cost if you need a relaxing place to stay!

Anonymous from dayton - Posted: 7/8/2016

Had a wonderful time on the island. I was very happy with booking this place!

Anonymous from Valley View - Posted: 9/29/2015

We had a very enjoyable time on the island.
The rental was nice but its primary use was to have a place to rest my head after a long night of partying.

Anonymous from Canton - Posted: 9/1/2015

We had 6 people staying in the cabin. It was beautiful. You go through trees to this very private property that was spacious and had a huge backyard with trees all around. There were bed sheets, towels, coffee, coffeemaker, toaster, washer, dryer. It was also only 1 mile from downtown. Would definitely recommended.

Anonymous from Farmington - Posted: 8/13/2015

Absolutely loved staying here. Would do it again in a heartbeat!! Very clean and comfortable! Wish there was TV in the bedrooms but that wouldn't stop me from staying here!

Anonymous from Crown Point - Posted: 8/9/2015

Piece & Quiet lived up to it's name. The rental was very clean & comfortable., very spacious, and very well laid out. One of the only rentals that offer towels & linenes. The owners were on the property and very courteous . Would definitely book again if we return.

Anonymous from Fairfield - Posted: 7/30/2015

This home gives you exactly what the name suggests.....Peace and Quiet! Very well maintained yard. We stayed in unit 1 and were extremely pleased. The unit was very clean!!! The beds were very soft and comfortable. The owners live in the upstairs unit and greeted us upon arrival. They were very friendly and helpful. You can hear them walking around upstairs but it was not an issue for us. We really enjoyed the bonfire pit located on the property. Very peaceful and private. Would highly recommend this rental!!

Anonymous from Beavercreek - Posted: 7/11/2015

We had a great time on the island and Peace and Quiet was a big part of that! The owner was very friendly and greeted us upon our arrival. The view was nice and the yard well cared for. The house had everything we needed and I think it is one of the few that provides linens and towels...a huge plus for travelers looking to reduce their baggage! We will definitely look for open weekends at this home for future visits :)

Anonymous from Bucyrus - Posted: 7/6/2015

we had a wonderful time. the rental was great. very clean and everything was ready for us. the only complaint I had is that the lighting for night around the cabin was very dark. I noticed some lights but they were burned out.

Anonymous from Bedford - Posted: 6/21/2015

This duplex was very nice and very clean. The staff was friendly and helpful! We loved how it was far enough away from downtown but was still in walking distance. It was a beautiful property overall!

Anonymous from Louisville - Posted: 5/19/2015

We had our executive retreat here for 8 people and it worked out great. Best location on the island if you want to be away from the party!

Anonymous from Haines City - Posted: 9/30/2014

Great house with complete privacy we had our own cabin in the woods.

Anonymous from Akron - Posted: 9/29/2014

Great experience overall. Minor miscommunication between owner and rental company at arrival but it was resolved quickly.

Anonymous from Broadway - Posted: 9/2/2014

The place was great. However there should've been disclosures that the family owning the rental property was living permanently upstairs. We were not under the impression that we were going to have full-time neighbors but rather to be at a location that was both peace and quiet away from other people. It was not enjoyable to have the owners come down three times during our time there to complain about something. We won't rent here again. Not fun to feel like you're constantly monitored or walking on eggshells. For what we paid to rent both sides of this property, we should have received more privacy.

Anonymous from Cincinnati - Posted: 8/27/2014

Loved the location and views. The house was spacious for our needs and beds were comfortable. Cant wait to come back next year.

Anonymous from Fremont - Posted: 8/8/2014

it was the right name for the place we stayed. Its nestled in the woods was very nice and clean. Had all your amenities that u needed right there. Would stay again..

Anonymous from Cincinatti - Posted: 8/3/2014

WOW!! This rental was super clean, well maintained, and the owner's were beyond helpful and pleasant during our stay. I will absolutely refer others coming to the island and return there myself each time I come if it is available. It was "peaceful, quiet" and wonderful!

Anonymous from Copley - Posted: 7/18/2014

Everything was great. Bedrooms would be a tight fit if you were bringing eight adults, but we were only with four so it was fine. Nice place.

Anonymous from Maria Stein - Posted: 7/7/2014

The management was incredible and always available for questions. The property was clean and new in appearance. The location is great, close to all the attractions, yet cozy in the woods with an amazing yard and porch and grill and firepit. It felt like you were in a different hideaway once on the property. Everything was excellent! The group that I traveled with can not stop talking about going back!!

Anonymous from New Lenox - Posted: 6/10/2014

Nice place. Enjoyed our stay. Quiet,comfortable and clean accommodations.

Anonymous from Bowling Green - Posted: 10/25/2013

The rental unit was awesome? The only suggestions I have is more TV stations other than HBO and perhaps dressers for clothing. The unit was clean and the locations was perfect. Can't wait to go back!

Anonymous from Mc Keesport - Posted: 7/8/2013

Very big place. Nice large rooms. Thank you

Anonymous from Springfield - Posted: 6/27/2013

Really enjoyed our stay. The Peace and Quiet was amazing accommodations!

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 6/23/2013

Wonderful property and wonderful stay. Everyone was friendly and helpful. Looking forward to coming back.

Anonymous from Portsmouth - Posted: 6/11/2013

Place would have been perfect except, you are not alone at this rental. People live above and below this rental unit. We wanted to be secluded and were disappointed when we arrived and found out the landlord stays right above you. Also, the second floor deck is not part of the rental as the pic suggests. Overall the was nice but...for the price...I'd keep looking.

Anonymous from Romeoville - Posted: 6/7/2013

The location of "Peace and Quiet", surrounded by trees as in the midst of a forest, yet only a mile from Put-in Bays many attractions, was ideal for us.

Anonymous from Hudson - Posted: 6/2/2013

VERY NICE! RENTED BOTH SIDES. WOULD RENT AGAIN.

Anonymous from Toledo - Posted: 5/25/2013

Very happy with the whole experience, from check-in to check-out. Management was great!

Anonymous from Brooklyn - Posted: 5/7/2013