Put-in-Bay Island Club #111

The properties conveniently located near the state park, the property is well kept and very clean, the cleaning and maintenance crew that take care of this property or top-notch and very helpful

Anonymous from Kankakee - Posted: 5/23/2026

Thank you so much for the wonderful review! We’re happy to hear you enjoyed the convenient location near the state park and found the property clean and well-maintained. Our housekeeping and maintenance teams work very hard to keep everything in great condition, so your kind words truly mean a lot to them. We appreciate you staying with us and hope to welcome you back to Put-in-Bay again soon!

Island Club staff

Excellent

Anonymous from Berkey - Posted: 5/21/2026

Thanks so much for the amazing review!

Island Club staff

VERY NICE PLACE TO STAY

Anonymous from Lake Villa - Posted: 5/2/2026

Thank you so much for the great review! It's always a pleasure having your group around!

Island Club staff

We had 12 people and it did not feel crowded whatsoever. Very clean and up to date. Lots and lots of cupboard space.

Anonymous from imlay city - Posted: 10/20/2025

Thank you for your wonderful review! We’re so glad to hear your group of 12 felt comfortable and had plenty of space. It’s great to know you found everything clean, up to date, and well equipped. We appreciate you choosing to stay with us and hope to welcome you back again soon!

Island Club staff

Great cabin very nice and clean. Only recommendation would be to have mirrors in the bedrooms as it is hard to share the 2 bathrooms with 12 plus people. Needed more mirrors to do make up, hair etc. The cheap rectangle long mirrors would be a great addition to the back of the closet doors or bedroom door.
Otherwise I will return and it was a great place to stay, easy to get to town.

Anonymous from Powell - Posted: 9/29/2025

Thank you for your thoughtful review! We’re glad you enjoyed the clean, comfortable cabin and that the location worked well for your stay. We truly appreciate your helpful suggestion about adding mirrors in the bedrooms—this is a great idea, especially for larger groups, and we’ll share it with our team. We’re so happy to hear you’d return, and we’d love to welcome you back again soon!

Island Club staff

nice unit, great communication.
all bedroom would be better with dresser and a waste basket in each room.

Anonymous from West Henrietta - Posted: 9/26/2025

Thank you for your review! We’re glad you enjoyed the unit and found our communication helpful. We also appreciate your suggestions about adding dressers and wastebaskets in each bedroom—this is valuable feedback, and we’ll be reviewing it with our team as we look for ways to improve. We’d love to host you again!

Island Club staff

Stayed here with twelve other men for a high school reunion of sorts. Cabin #111 was clean, sufficiently stocked (paid Xtra $100 for linen service), and office was responsive and helpful. There’s not much room to spread out. Rooms are filled with bed and couches. Deck/patio is small (bring Xtra folding chairs). Still, a low cost option that gave us everything we needed.

Anonymous from Edmonds - Posted: 9/23/2025

Thank you for sharing your experience at Cabin #111! We’re glad to hear it was clean, well-stocked, and that our office team was responsive and helpful during your reunion. We appreciate your honest notes about the layout, deck size, and seating—we’ll keep that in mind as we look at future improvements. We’re happy the cabin provided a convenient and affordable option for your group, and we’d love to host you all again!

Island Club staff

Our overall experience was great. The home was very spacious, updated and clean. We had trouble with the lock and management assisted promptly. Golf card access on the property was very convenient. We would highly recommend and revisit!

Anonymous from West Chester - Posted: 9/17/2025

Thank you for your wonderful review! We’re so glad you enjoyed the spacious, updated, and clean home, and that our team was able to quickly assist with the lock issue. It’s great to hear the golf cart access made things even more convenient. We truly appreciate your recommendation and would love to welcome you back for another stay!

Island Club staff

The island was great as always. We took friends who had never been there before. They loved it.
This is the first year we've seen so many cops. The people that vacation on this island don't spend the money we do to have police standing at every corner waiting for you to make a mistake. This is a vacation and we want it stress free. Entirely to many cops pulling people over. We're not sure if we will return because of this.
There is no reason for all the paid parking. After spending thousands of dollars to stay and renting golf carts it is rediculous to have to fight that hard to find a place to park.
Between all the cops and the greediness of the island with the parking we're not sure if we will be back or not.

Anonymous from Lost Creek - Posted: 9/2/2025

Thank you for bringing friends to the island and for sharing your candid feedback. We’re glad they loved Put-in-Bay, and we’re truly sorry that the heavy police presence and parking situation took away from your experience. While we don’t have any control over law-enforcement activity or municipal parking policies, we definitely understand the frustration with the City of Put-in-Bay. We’ll continue to advocate for a guest-friendly experience, and if you decide to return, please reach out to us before your trip—our team can share up-to-date tips on getting around, where parking is typically easier, and transportation options to help keep things stress-free. We appreciate you staying with us and hope we can welcome you back for a more relaxed visit.

Island Club staff

Fun family vacation

Anonymous from Battle Creek - Posted: 8/12/2025

Thank you for sharing! We’re so glad you had a fun family vacation with us. We’d love to welcome you back again soon for more great memories!

Island Club staff

The only thing that could be improved was the cleanliness of the floors.

Anonymous from Medina - Posted: 8/1/2025

Thank you for your feedback! We're glad you enjoyed your stay overall and truly appreciate you pointing out the issue with the floor cleanliness. We’ve passed this along to our cleaning team to ensure it’s addressed moving forward. Your input helps us improve, and we hope to have the opportunity to host you again soon!

Island Club staff

We rented 3 cabins for a long weekend. The people at island Club made the process very easy. The cabins were in great shape and exactly what we hoped for the weekend

Anonymous from Eighty Four - Posted: 6/16/2025

Thank you for the kind words! We’re so glad to hear the three cabins were a perfect fit for your weekend and that the booking process was smooth and easy. It was a pleasure having your group, and we’d love to welcome you back for another great stay!

Island Club staff

Excellent

Anonymous from Berkey - Posted: 5/19/2025

Thank you! We're so glad to hear you had an excellent experience. Hope to see you again soon!

Island Club staff

Great house, had everything we needed and more. Perfect space for our party. Ariana was an amazing help! The best hostess I've ever worked with! I recommend this house times 1000 and will be back to stay at Island Club.

Anonymous from Kirtland - Posted: 5/19/2025

Thank you so much for the glowing review! We're thrilled the house had everything you needed and more—and we'll definitely pass along your kind words to Ariana. She's a rockstar, and we're lucky to have her on the team! We're so glad your party had the perfect space, and we can't wait to welcome you back to Island Club again!

Island Club staff

This place was exactly what we needed for 12 guys on a fishing trip! The only issue is Parking is tight for 3 trucks and trailers. The property staff was extremely quick and courteous in taking care of any issues we had.

Anonymous from Mc Bain - Posted: 3/31/2025

Thanks so much for the great review! We're glad the house was a great fit for your fishing trip and that our team was able to assist quickly when needed. We really appreciate the feedback about parking. Due to limited space, we highly recommend fishing groups bring only one boat and one truck when possible. If needed, two trucks and boats is the absolute max we suggest. We do our best to accommodate everyone, but parking can be tight—especially during busy weekends—so keeping vehicle numbers low really helps. Thanks again, and we hope to have you and the crew back again soon!

Island Club staff

Love the place

Anonymous from Kennerdell - Posted: 9/9/2024

Thank you for your feedback! We're thrilled to hear that you loved the place. We look forward to hosting you again in the future!

Island Club staff

We booked this island club house for my bachelorette party and it was so nice!! Very nice kitchen/living room space for everyone to gather. Our van driver day one even told us we picked a good one!

Anonymous from Greendale - Posted: 8/5/2024

Thank you for your wonderful review! We're thrilled to hear that you enjoyed the Island Club house for your bachelorette party and found the kitchen and living room space perfect for gathering. It's great to know that even your van driver complimented your choice. We look forward to welcoming you back for future celebrations!

Island Club staff

House was missing enough eating utencils for 16, no chefs
knifes, no hand towels. Management was quick to bring the items after requesting them. One Bathroom had very slow shower and sink drainage

Anonymous from Medina - Posted: 8/20/2023

Thank you for the feedback and we are glad that those missing items didn't cause you an unpleasant stay. We are happy to hear our management staff was quick to bring whatever you needed to your unit. We hope to see you staying with us again in our rentals, and hope you enjoyed the rest of your week!

Island Club staff

Good layout for lots of people. Giant kitchen island with lots of kitchen storage but minimal kitchen utensils/cooking ware. Nice outside patio space with plenty of seating.

Anonymous from Solon - Posted: 8/13/2023

We are glad that everything was nice and as expected when you got there! Thanks for staying with us and we hope to see you again!

Island Club staff

It was clean and nicely put together some things looked to have been just wear and tear but overall very cute

Anonymous from Sandusky - Posted: 7/29/2023

Thanks for the great feedback and we are so happy that you enjoyed your stay with us! We are looking to fix most of that wear in tear during our off season this year. Glad everything was still very cute and we hope to see you back with us again soon!

Island Club staff

It was a great place to be.

Anonymous from Saint Clair - Posted: 7/4/2023

We are happy to hear that it was a great place for you and your group! I specifically love that house myself, just because of location and how roomy it feels! We appreciate you staying with us and hope to see you again next year!

Island Club staff

We love Island Club, we stayed in 111 this time and it was spacious enough for everyone in our group, we love sitting around the huge kitchen table and playing games! The convenience of the golf cart rental is great and of course the kids always love the pool! Thanks for the great stay!

Anonymous from Logan - Posted: 6/19/2023

Thanks for all the great feedback! We are so happy to hear that is was spacious enough for everyone and kitchen table was big enough for games! We hope to see you again soon for your next trip!

Island Club staff

Clean as always everything worked and nice place to stay.

Anonymous from Huron - Posted: 4/27/2023

Hi Jeffrey, we appreciate the feedback and glad it was a nice stay for you!

Island Club staff

Awesome

Anonymous from Pinckney - Posted: 10/19/2022

Hi Mark, thank for the feedback!

Island Club staff

We go with 3-4 other couples and have a great time every year.

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 10/13/2022

Hi Patrick, we appreciate the great feedback and we always love having our returning customers with us!

Island Club staff

Great place to stay at just to have fun and go out during the night!

Anonymous from Grafton - Posted: 9/28/2022

Hi Noah, thanks for the feedback and we hope to see you stay with us again soon!

Island Club staff

We reserved club house 95 or 97, a 10 person rental. It was so ran down found black mold in the closet. All edges and corners of the house had nasty build-up along with spider webs. We were completely disappointed especially since our last visit we stayed in there condos and they were very well kept up. Called the staff to see if we could move to a condo but they were booked so they moved us to the biggest island club house they had. It had 5 bedrooms with 2 beds each. It was very nice and clean. The staff was very friendly and accommodating. So I recommend the condos over the club houses. Because of the condition of the first place they wanted to place us I cannot give more than three stars but the upgrade was very nice.

Anonymous from Risingsun - Posted: 9/25/2022

Hi Krystle, our apologies about the first house again. As we need to make some updates on it. I'm glad that our staff could accommodate you and your group to a nicer, bigger cabin, that was much better. We certainly hope to host you again in either another beautiful condo, or another well kept up cabin house!

Island Club staff

The location was great; far enough from all the noise of downtown but close enough to visit easily. The house itself was nice and the large kitchen was great. Overall, it was clean except for the floors which needed a good mopping. The supplies were sufficient; we did discover some things that were missing that would have been good to have such as hangers, a colander and a small bedside table in each bedroom. The size of the house was great for our group of 12. The only other concern was the lack of garbage removal when the can was full.

Anonymous from Hamburg - Posted: 8/8/2022

Hi Kelly, I appreciate your feedback and certainly wish you would have called during your stay so we could have made things right. We have a full staff on the island that is available to assist if something is amiss. Our goal is to work hard so you can enjoy your vacation. Our housekeeping manager met with the team member responsible for cleaning your unit and performed some retraining. If we are lucky enough to earn your business in the future, our office staff would be happy to hand-select a house that would meet your standards.

Island Club staff

Clean, comfortable, nice mattresses, kitchen was well supplied, plenty of room

Anonymous from Kankakee - Posted: 5/18/2022

Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

Cabin was very nice and clean like every year

Anonymous from Huron - Posted: 4/10/2022

We are glad you enjoyed your stay and can't wait to host you again!

Island Club staff

We had so much fun. The island club rental 111 was perfect for our 15 people. The house was super nice and accommodating. Our neighbors were also very friendly. The house had everything we needed for the 3 night stay. There was some stains on the carpets and a broken piece of wood in the bed frame, but they assured that if the bed became unsleepable they would come to fix it. Overall a great experience.

Anonymous from Angola - Posted: 8/24/2021

Brittany, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

Beds for everyone, large island in kitchen and nice side yard for corn hole. Taxi will take you anywhere you want to go for $3.

Anonymous from Irvine - Posted: 8/18/2021

Daniel, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

Great place to stay and was plenty of room for the 15 people we had.

Anonymous from Waunakee - Posted: 8/3/2021

Andy, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

It was great. The location was great the cabin was big perfect for our family!!
The only thing I wish they had was a cover over the patio!

Anonymous from Coral Springs - Posted: 7/30/2021

Heather, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

Booked house for a bachelorette party and was very impressed. Had plenty of room for the guests and a large kitchen/living room and patio that allowed all the girls to meet and catch up.

Anonymous from Urbana - Posted: 6/8/2021

Kaitlyn, We are glad you had a good time on the island and look forward to hosting another trip for your in the future!

Island Club staff

Very nice and worth coming back for another vacation

Anonymous from Lagrange - Posted: 4/13/2021

Hi Christopher, We look forward to hosting another trip for your group again in the future!

Island Club staff

Cabin was very nice could use more water pressure but other than that it was nice. It had plenty of room for all 8 of us. It could use a light in living room was dark but understand that with the amount of people it sees it may not last.

Anonymous from Huron - Posted: 4/12/2021

Hi Jeffrey, We look forward to hosting another trip for your group again in the future!

Island Club staff

WE had a great vacation weekend here. Weather was a little chilly, but that didn't stop the fun. The place was great. Big enough for the 11 people we had and plenty of room to spread out during the stay and relax or play games at the big snack bar. Overall great stay.

Anonymous from Lowell - Posted: 10/6/2020

Brought the family and had an amazing time. We love it.

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 7/31/2020

Hi Lamar, Glad you had a great time staying in our home. Your group was wonderful and we look forward to hosting another trip for you in the future!

Island Club staff

We stayed at this rental as a last change from a different one to be able to invite additional friends. Very nice place.

Anonymous from Northwood - Posted: 6/28/2020

Had a great time

Anonymous from Alsip - Posted: 9/3/2019

good

Anonymous from erie - Posted: 8/23/2019

There was plenty of room for the family and extended family! The open kitchen/living area concept was perfect for all of us to be together!

Anonymous from Naperville - Posted: 8/11/2019

Fun time

Anonymous from Somerset - Posted: 8/2/2019

We enjoyed our stay at The Island Inn.
It was spacious and we had plenty of room for our family.
The kitchen sat all of us, and we never felt crowded.
There was plenty of beds for all of us and the pool was nice.
Thank you

Anonymous from N/A - Posted: 7/3/2019

We had a great time.

Anonymous from Celina - Posted: 5/22/2019

We had a good stay at the Island Club. We were there on our annual fishing trip and this was our first time actually staying in the Island Club. Cabin #111 is very nice and we really liked the large kitchen island! Overall it was clean, spacious and worked out very well. I wish the kitchen was a little more stocked with everyday items such as a potato peeler, strainer, paring knife, etc. Also this time of year it is full of fishermen and the the streets are lined with boats so trying to maneuver a boat around and into our parkings spot was very difficult. Who thought putting in landscaping in the center of culdesacs was a good idea? Very difficult for any vehicle to make the circle little lone with a boat. So the cabin itself is very nice but not ideal if you have a boat.

Anonymous from Brandon - Posted: 5/20/2019

It was awesome, everything went smooth. Got our deposit back, easy access to downtown. All neighbors were super friendly! Spacious, all needs met.

Anonymous from Richmond - Posted: 8/29/2018

We had a great stay. The property was clean and the layout was great for a large group. The kitchen didn’t have the cooking utensils like frying pans etc we expected and the ones they did have weren’t great. If you are planning on cooking, bring your own. The house is in a great location away from
Downtown if you are looking for a bit of quiet.

Anonymous from STANMORE - Posted: 7/24/2018

Hi Kelly, glad you enjoyed the layout of the house for your large group. If you ever need additional kitchen supplies, you can always call our office and we can provide most items.

Island Club staff

The house was perfect for our group and the employees did everything to accommodate us.

Anonymous from Trufant - Posted: 7/15/2018

Thanks for the glowing review Andrew! We pride ourselves on having friendly, efficient staff members who help make our guests feel welcomed.

Island Club staff

Had a great time at Island Club.
Great Staff and the house was perfect.
Looking forward to planning our next trip.

Anonymous from Chagrin Falls - Posted: 7/11/2018

Hi Anthony, thank for staying with us and complimenting our staff! We pride ourselves on having an attentive, courteous staff to help our guests enjoy their stay. We look forward to a having your stay with us again!

Island Club staff

This property worked well for our large family group. We loved the giant table. This was a new adventure for our family, and we had MANY questions. The management was very helpful and answered all out questions. My only suggestions would be to provide pot holders in the kitchen, and a few more towel bars or hooks for bathroom towels.

Anonymous from Sheffield Lake - Posted: 6/30/2018

Hi Sharon, we are glad you enjoyed your stay in the Island Club! We are always happy to answer any questions our guests may have in order to help them plan a memorable trip.

Island Club staff

We enjoyed our stay! We appreciated the large roomy kitchen, large TV for watching the Buckeyes, 5 bedrooms & 2 full baths. Service was prompt when we discovered some missing items from the cabin. We also appreciated the 2 golf carts we reserved being on delivered on site when we arrived & the convenience of leaving them for pick up instead of having to return them. It helped us have a quicker departure. Our only complaint would be how dirty & stained the carpet was and the broken door knob in rear bedroom. Someone did a poor job trying to repair the know with duct tape.

Anonymous from Dayton - Posted: 10/20/2017

Cabin 111 was a perfect fit for our group. It was incredibly nice on the inside and a great location. I called the rental place multiple times before and during our stay and they were always extremely helpful. Can't them recommend them enough!

Anonymous from Canal Winchester - Posted: 9/28/2017

The house was large for 14 dudes to sleep in. Very clean, and the staff is great to work with. Water pressure is very low in the showers, but overall I would recommend this house.

Anonymous from Cincinnati - Posted: 9/12/2017

What a great vacation home! Everything was perfect. All of my guests for the bachelor party enjoyed their stay and had nothing but great things to say. Thank you guys so much.

Anonymous from Trenton - Posted: 9/6/2017

I originally booked a 4 BR cabin but there was an issue with that cabin the day we were set to check in. I was contacted that morning and was informed I would be upgraded to a 5 BR cabin. I was very impressed with the new cabin and now I would not want to come back unless I got to stay in this beautiful cabin. A WONDERFUL experience for my wife's 40th birthday weekend with friends!!

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 8/23/2017

The stay was nice
House was clean
One of the bedroom doors was pieced together on its hinges.
As we opened the door it fell off the hinges and could not be put back on.
Please call and advise what will be done with that.

Anonymous from IRA TOWNSHIP - Posted: 8/8/2017

Thank you for the review. We are glad that you had a nice time. It is unfortunate that you destroyed the interior door and shower area.

Island Club staff

Great house to entertain family.

Anonymous from Federal Way - Posted: 7/26/2017

WE really enjoyed our stay...roomy, attractive, and the Island Club is nice to work with, they provided the golf carts we needed, and delivered them to our door. They provided paper products and dishwasher soap...we should have packed bathroom soap and more paper towels for hand washing.

Anonymous from AKRON - Posted: 7/14/2017

BEING A NEW UNIT SOME AMENITIES WERE MISSING. KITCHEN WILL SEAT A LARGE CROWD, AND THERE IS A LOT OF SLEEPING ROOM

Anonymous from Lake Villa - Posted: 5/17/2017

We were originally renting island club 100 I believe was the number but there was an issue with the hot water heater 2 days before we were to arrive. I received a call informing about the situation and then told we would be upgraded for a bigger house for no additional cost. We had 12 guys there for a bachelor party and it was great! Atmosphere on our road was great. We met a bunch of neighbors and had a blast. The staff there is incredible and will do anything for you. The welcomed us and greeted us like family and then we asked for a specialty kitchen item and they were glad to bring one to us right away and no charge of course. Highly recommended! Will return for sure!

Anonymous from Marengo - Posted: 11/12/2016

very nice, nice home, and the staff was very helpful.

Anonymous from Dry ridge - Posted: 10/4/2016

Newly remodeled cabin was very nice. Layout of house was good, plenty of room in kitchen and living room for everyone to hangout. Outside area was also great, provided grill and picnic tables. Pool is just a short walk from all cabins. Great place to enjoy Put in Bay, close to everything but far enough from the downtowm area to relax.

Anonymous from Broadview Heights - Posted: 9/13/2016

I threw a bachelorette party for my sister and 18 of her friends. Jerry from Island Rentals really helped us out by letting me know about the brand new house being built. From the outside it looked like any other house in the neighborhood but inside it was amazing! The kitchen and living room couldn't have been more perfect to accommodate every guest. My biggest fear was 18 women getting ready to go out for the evening but no on ever felt crowded and there was plenty of room for everyone. The staff was very helpful answering emails right away and the taxi service was prompt and always willing to help out. We'll definitely be back to stay in #111 again! Thanks for everything.

Anonymous from Cincinnati - Posted: 8/24/2016

We loved staying at the Island Club #111. I would never bring a family to stay here (I probably wouldn't bring to put-in-bay at all), but it is absolutely perfect for a bachelorette/bachelor party or a weekend getaway with friends. The majority of the people we saw were there for a party. It was so perfect for us! The kitchen was spacious, beds were comfortable. My only complaint is that with 16 women... 2 mirrors in the entire house was not enough. Bring your own if they don't add door mirrors in the bedrooms.

Anonymous from Westerville - Posted: 8/23/2016

House was clean, new, and big! Couldn't believe our entire group could all stay in one place.

Anonymous from Lakewood - Posted: 8/18/2016

Everyone had a great time

Anonymous from Fremont - Posted: 7/26/2016

Excellent. Staff and their suggestions were very Helpful

Anonymous from Titusville - Posted: 7/15/2016