Put-in-Bay Island Club #13

Great spot with good parking

Anonymous from Brillion - Posted: 5/15/2026

Thank you for the great review! We’re glad you enjoyed the location and found the parking convenient during your stay. We appreciate you choosing to stay with us at Put-in-Bay and hope to welcome you back again soon!

Island Club staff

Great time on our fishing trip

Anonymous from Brillion - Posted: 5/19/2025

Thank you! We're glad you had a great time on your fishing trip. Hope to see you back for the next one!

Island Club staff

We were delighted with the space. It was as described and it was especially clean. When you're dealing with high turnover vacation spots like PIB, you're really not sure what you're going to get. We were really pleased. Lots of space, bigger bathrooms, kitchen had everything, several hangout areas, and extremely comfortable beds. Our mattresses seemed brand new - plenty of support and very comfortable. AC was great - cooled down pretty quick. They also made renting a golf cart very easy and were accommodating in every way. We'll definitely stay there again.

Anonymous from Cleveland - Posted: 5/12/2025

Thank you for the fantastic and detailed review! We're so glad to hear the space exceeded your expectations and that everything from the cleanliness and spacious layout to the comfortable beds and quick-cooling AC made your stay a great one. It's especially rewarding to know you felt confident staying with us, even in a busy destination like PIB. We’re happy the golf cart rental was smooth and that our team could make your visit even better. We look forward to hosting you again soon!

Island Club staff

As always, had a wonderful stay at the Island Club. The house was clean and comfortable for our entire family. If you’re looking for a little hidden gem that never disappoints I highly recommend making a reservation!

Anonymous from Cleveland - Posted: 10/25/2024

Thank you for your lovely review! We’re thrilled to hear that you had another wonderful stay at the Island Club and found the house clean and comfortable for your family. Your recommendation means a lot to us, and we look forward to welcoming you back for more great stays in the future!

Island Club staff

Wow! Just wow! This entire house has been redone. It's absolutely beautiful and fit our entire group comfortably. We loved having TVs in every bedroom too. We will request 13 for our next trip!

Anonymous - Posted: 10/10/2024

Thank you for your fantastic review! We're thrilled to hear that you loved the beautifully redone house and that it fit your group comfortably. The TVs in every bedroom are a great bonus! We look forward to hosting you again and will be happy to reserve House #13 for your next trip!

Island Club staff

We booked house 13 for an August stay and were very pleased with the entire experience. We recognized the house since it is right across from the pool. It is conveniently located not far from the Island Club entrance also. The open floor plan in the main area of the house allowed everyone in our party to hang out in one area. We were told new beds, dressers and tables were installed just before our stay so that made the experience that much better. The back patio offered some quiet away from the pool and front road. We would certainly request this house again.

Anonymous from Cleveland - Posted: 9/3/2024

Thank you for your thoughtful review! We're thrilled to hear that House #13 met your expectations and that the new furniture made your stay even better. It’s great to know the open floor plan worked well for your group and that you enjoyed the peaceful back patio. We look forward to welcoming you back and would be happy to reserve House #13 for your next stay!

Island Club staff

We have stayed in house #13 several times. The updates this year are incredible! The floors have been replapcj replaced, new furniture was added throughout the house and even the beds are new. It is beautifully decorated!! We will be back next year!

Anonymous from Cleveland - Posted: 8/31/2024

Thank you for your wonderful feedback! We’re thrilled to hear that you loved the updates to House #13, from the new floors and furniture to the fresh beds and beautiful decor. It’s always great to welcome back returning guests, and we can’t wait to see you again next year!

Island Club staff

The house was ready on time, very clean and had everything that was needed for a great stay. My host was exceptional and very quick with his responses. Would definitely stay again

Anonymous from Green Camp - Posted: 8/24/2024

Thank you for the fantastic review! We're thrilled to hear that the house was ready on time, very clean, and equipped with everything you needed for a great stay. It's wonderful to know that our host's quick responses made your experience even better. We look forward to welcoming you back for another stay in the future!

Island Club staff

Property was accurately described, easy to find, and well-maintained. Would certainly book with Island Club Rentals again. Very thorough description and booking information.

Anonymous from Vincent - Posted: 6/10/2024

Thank you for your positive review! We're delighted to hear that the property met your expectations in terms of accuracy, maintenance, and ease of location. We strive to provide detailed descriptions and streamlined booking information to enhance our guests' experience. We appreciate your feedback and are thrilled that you would consider booking with Island Club Rentals again. We look forward to welcoming you back for another great stay!

Island Club staff

Island club rentals were great to work with Dotti had always been so helpful with anything we needed, I would be glad to recommend Island Club rentals to anyone we are looking forward to our return trip next year.

Anonymous from Holabird - Posted: 5/10/2023

Hi Dave, thanks so much for the feedback and we appreciate everything! Can't wait to see you back in our house next year!

Island Club staff

Had a great time staying here and got to meet a lot of new people

Anonymous from Platte - Posted: 4/15/2023

Hi Tyler, thanks so much for the feedback and we are so happy you had a great time!

Island Club staff

I loved this rental place. It was just perfect for a family of 6. It had all the kitchen amenities and was very spacious. The place itself was in a wooded lot, we enjoyed waking up early, going for walks and just sitting by the porch with a tea. Having swimming pool just across our room was an added benefit. My kids love swimming pool. The checkin process was super convenient and the resort even had a pickup /drop off for the golf cart rental which was super nice.

Anonymous from Palatine - Posted: 7/22/2022

Ankur, Thank you so much for the wonderful review!

Island Club staff

The unit was clean and comfy. It had everything we needed, including an extremely short walk to the pool!!

Anonymous from Union Town - Posted: 6/28/2022

Judy, Thanks for visiting our little island of Put-in-Bay on your recent getaway. You were definitely a 5-star guest and we are glad that we provided a 5-star experience! We hope to host another vacation for your group in the future.

Island Club staff

Rental was clean and check in and out were so smooth. Highly recommend renting a golf cart from island club!

Anonymous from Sharpsville - Posted: 6/23/2022

Hi Kevin! Thanks for visiting our little island of Put-in-Bay on your recent getaway. You were definitely a 5-star guest and we are glad that we provided a 5-star experience! We hope to host another vacation for your group in the future.

Island Club staff

Nice facility, water heater not turned on and took a while to locate, in closet and had to remove paneling to get to. Light fixture in kitchen almost fell down but we fixed it, it was loose and partially hanging when we checked in.
We had a blast fishing and hope to comeback next year, might want a different cabin then 13 though. Thanks
TT

Anonymous from Canton - Posted: 5/8/2022

Our apologies about the issues arising during your stay. We have let our staff and Island Manager know, and they are working together to get it all resolved. Hope to see you soon again at the Bay!

Island Club staff

We had a great stay and lived the rental.

Anonymous from flat rock - Posted: 9/28/2021

Christian, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

Great location right across from the pool.Unit was clean, just in need of an update.

Anonymous from Strongsville - Posted: 7/12/2021

Marty, So glad you enjoyed your stay on our quaint little island of Put-in-Bay! We look forward to hosting your group in the future!

Island Club staff

Sooo much fun. Our house was clean and had an open floor plan which was great for our family. Mgmt was friendly and accomodating. Our golf carts were waiting for us when we got there and they picked up when we left. One less thing we had to worry about! We ran out of paper towels and they delivered more right away. The island was so lively. Stayed 5 days and loved it! Will be back in fall to see a different version of the Island!

Anonymous from Brunswick - Posted: 7/11/2021

Brian, So glad you enjoyed your stay on our quaint little island of Put-in-Bay! We look forward to hosting your group in the future!

Island Club staff

It was a nice place and had a good time

Anonymous from New Bloomington - Posted: 7/14/2020

The property manager was very accommodating and made our stay more enjoyable. Thank you.

Anonymous from Sagamore Hills - Posted: 6/9/2020

Stayed at this nice home on Put-In-Bay for 3 nights with 6 other friends. Great 4th of July weekend vacation. No complaints about the rental, location, anything. Communal pool is fun. Owners respond very quickly to any needs because there is a manager on site.

Anonymous from Pittsburgh - Posted: 7/14/2019

Very good

Anonymous from Parkston - Posted: 5/5/2019

We had a nice time. House could have been little nicer. Couldn't suit on toilet without seat moving. Didn't have a lot of hot water. No soap for dishwasher.

Anonymous from Columbus Grove - Posted: 8/2/2017

I highly recommend Island Club #13 as your place to stay on Put In Bay. The house was located immediately across from the pool which was very convenient. More importantly, the living room had been updated from the pictures that were online. There were new leather couches, hardwood floor, and a nice new table. I almost thought I had entered the wrong unit! The unit was clean, the owners were great about explaining check in details, and we will be back!

Anonymous from Middleburg Heights - Posted: 7/11/2017

House was clean. We were pleased. Out side water bib needs fixed .

Anonymous from Parkston - Posted: 4/27/2017

We had a great time. The place was clean and we also enjoyed the nee couches. The only this we wish was better was the fishing.

Anonymous from wRIGHTSTOWN - Posted: 4/18/2017

Clean, comfortable and accurately described regarding location, layout and amenities.

Anonymous from Harrison Township - Posted: 9/27/2016

House was nice and spacious. Pool was just across the street and was busy on the weekend. Island club made our stay enjoyable and refunded the deposit promptly. The island club app was helpful. Will book again.

Anonymous from Oregon - Posted: 8/24/2016

The ease of renting an Island Club home, along with the prompt service, location, and value is wonderful. The rental was relatively clean, but the accommodations were not up to my normal expectations. It was definitely more like cabin camping than staying in a resort.

Anonymous from North Ridgeville - Posted: 6/23/2016

there were no major problems with the property but the place needed some work. The walls were patched in a couple of places but not sanded or painted. The main (large) burner on the stove did not work and was missing the support under it. There were burns in the carpet. All-in-all it met our needs for three guys on a fishing trip but I would not have wanted to bring my family on a vacation to this property. Dottie was very helpful and easy to contact.

Anonymous from Devils Lake - Posted: 4/16/2016

Our stay was very fun and the people that work for island club were all so nice and very helpful. I would recommend this place to anyone and everyone, especially younger adults who are looking to have a good time. Everything was nice and neat when we got there and clean. The only problem we had was the outlets, many of them did not work and our phones could not charge. Out of all the outlets in the house (there was a lot) only about 3 worked. We didn't let this ruin our trip though! Overall it was a great stay and I can't wait to go back!!!

Anonymous from Fairborn - Posted: 6/17/2015

I took the 6 girls - sister - nieces- daughter-in-law------from my family to the Bay for a long weekend just because. We toured the island, hit many of the tourist attractions and sampled some local food and wine. A great weekend!

Anonymous from Fremont - Posted: 6/16/2015

Best time ever, house was clean , enough beds and Dottie the house manager is the bombbbbbb... So nice and professional ..

Anonymous from Buffalo - Posted: 5/13/2015

Again,all good.
Property was clean and ready to go.
All the people we met were very helpful and friendly.

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 9/21/2014

The Island Club was located close to town. Taxi service was readily available and our driver Tony was awesome! We enjoyed our stay in #13!

Anonymous from Middlebury - Posted: 8/26/2014

Clean and lots of room

Anonymous from Vermillon - Posted: 7/22/2014

My friends and I went down July 10-14,2014 and we had an amazing time. Thank you to Dottie and her staff at the Island club. I highly recommend this place. It was very easy to get cabs. The location was amazing right across from the pool!!! I also recommend The Mist pool and staff ask for Brooke in VIP.
Thank you again we had a GREAT time!!!

Anonymous from Chicago Ridge - Posted: 7/15/2014

We rented the Island Club #13 house from 20-22 June 2014. The location was excellent, across from the pool and a few miles from downtown. The house was fine for a short stay. It was clean and all amenities are as described in the site. Furniture/decor could use updating. As advertised, the house can accommodate eight; however, the dinner table can only sit six. The house does not have some basic electronics found in rental properties at this very high price range ($1500/weekend) such as stereo system or DVD player. It also lacks a fire extinguisher, which is a safety concern especially if the kitchen and/or grill are used. Although WiFi is advertised near the pool, it did not work. Dottie, from customer service, was very helpful throughout the reservation process and during our stay.

Anonymous from Bellbrool - Posted: 6/29/2014

There were holes in the walls, trim missing, some damage from previous tenants. We never got our WIFI to work. But that didn't stop us. I was a great unit and very please with all the staff.

Anonymous from Battle Creek - Posted: 5/20/2014

Fishing have always appreciated the housing

Anonymous from Parkston - Posted: 4/29/2014

We have a large group come in once a year and Dottie, Tony and the Island Club gang always take great care of us.

Anonymous from Toledo - Posted: 8/15/2013

The property is aging but in clean condition. It is in much needed updating if you want to continue to charge the price you are charging. We tried to use the grill and it took almost an hour to cook a hamburger. It was ridiculous.

Anonymous from Moon Twnship - Posted: 7/3/2013

The house woeded out very well wish the weather would hve cooperated.

Anonymous from Parkston - Posted: 4/29/2013