Put-in-Bay Island Club #6

Reasonable price, met our needs, and very comfortable. Staff responds quickly to any requests!

Anonymous from Tallmadge - Posted: 6/11/2026

This is one of my favorite spots to rent. Great deck with plenty of party space for guests.

Anonymous from Lima - Posted: 9/20/2025

Thank you for the wonderful feedback! We’re so glad this is one of your favorite spots and that you enjoyed the deck and space for entertaining. We’d love to welcome you back for another great stay!

Island Club staff

From the first text we got from Island Club to the super clean house, this was a great experience. The staff was so helpful and courteous - just a wonderful group of people! This unique experience of staying in a home instead of a hotel was such a convenience!

Anonymous from Cleveland - Posted: 9/16/2025

Thank you so much for your kind words! We’re delighted to hear that everything from our communication to the cleanliness of the home made for a great experience. Our staff will be thrilled to know their helpfulness stood out. We’re glad you enjoyed the convenience of staying in a home setting and hope to welcome you back to the Island Club again soon!

Island Club staff

The location was wonderful. Right across from the pool. The information that was sent ahead of time was informative and helpful. The house was clean, roomy, and decorated nicely. I would HIGHLY recommend this place!

Anonymous from Fredericksburg - Posted: 8/20/2025

Thank you so much for the kind words! We're thrilled you enjoyed the location, especially being right across from the pool. It’s great to hear the pre-arrival info was helpful and that you found the house clean, spacious, and nicely decorated. Your high recommendation means a lot — we’d love to host you again soon!

Island Club staff

WE stay at the Island Club every summer and this is our first time staying in unit #6. This has been our favorite unit so far. The beds were comfortable, the kitchen was stocked with cooking and eating necessities and we liked the proximity to the pool. We would stay here again.

Anonymous from Concord Township - Posted: 8/12/2025

Thank you for staying with us each summer—it means so much to have loyal guests like you! We’re thrilled to hear that Unit #6 has been your favorite so far. It’s wonderful that you enjoyed the comfortable beds, well-stocked kitchen, and the convenient location close to the pool. We’d love to welcome you back again next year for another great stay at the Island Club!

Island Club staff

this is our 3rd year at island club. we love it here because it's quiet and away from the bars so when you actually want to relax and sleep you can, but it's just a quick taxi ride to the fun. the only negative thing we have to say is the floors in the house were dirty enough to turn our feet brown. we just wore shoes or socks, wasn't a big deal for us. everything else was great

Anonymous from pittsburgh - Posted: 8/8/2025

Thank you for being a loyal guest and joining us for your 3rd year at the Island Club! We’re so glad you enjoy the peaceful location that’s perfect for relaxing while still being just a quick taxi ride to all the fun. We appreciate your feedback about the floors and have shared it with our housekeeping team to ensure it’s addressed moving forward. We’re happy it didn’t impact your stay and that everything else was great. We look forward to welcoming you back for year four!

Island Club staff

I was very happy with the house. It was exactly as described and perfectly suited our needs. I would recommend this place to others.

Anonymous from Florence - Posted: 6/26/2025

Thank you for the wonderful review! We're glad the house was exactly what you needed and that you’d recommend it to others. We’d love to host you again anytime!

Island Club staff

The rental was very clean. Loved the floor plan, outside deck is set up great with the picnic tables and grill. I regret that I didn’t come better prepared with food to cook. The staff was very helpful. Great little getaway. Planning on returning for a longer stay! Hopefully the weather will be better for us. Thank you for a wonderful vacation.

Anonymous from Lima - Posted: 6/8/2025

Thank you so much for the thoughtful review! We're glad you enjoyed the clean rental, the floor plan, and the deck setup—it’s a guest favorite! Our team is always happy to help, and we’re thrilled to hear you had a great little getaway. We hope your next stay is longer and filled with perfect weather. Looking forward to welcoming you back soon!

Island Club staff

Pleasant, from maintaining, to front desk and management everyone was willing and egar to help.

Anonymous from Perry Hall - Posted: 6/4/2025

Thank you for the kind words! We’re so glad to hear you had a pleasant experience and that our maintenance, front desk, and management teams were eager to help. We truly appreciate your feedback and hope to see you again soon!

Island Club staff

quiet away from the loud nonsense of the main strip. easy to get to the bars and have fun but also nice to relax without noisy neighbors

Anonymous from pittsburgh - Posted: 9/27/2024

Thank you for your feedback! We're glad you enjoyed the peace and quiet away from the hustle of the main strip while still having easy access to the fun. It’s great to hear you could relax without noisy neighbors. We hope to welcome you back for another relaxing stay!

Island Club staff

We had a very nice time and it was very convenient having the golf cart rental on the premises.

Anonymous from Avon Lake - Posted: 9/23/2024

Thank you for your review! We're glad to hear you had a very nice time and found the on-premises golf cart rental convenient. We hope to welcome you back for another enjoyable stay!

Island Club staff

Our rental was right across from the pool which was very convenient.

Anonymous from Upland - Posted: 8/24/2024

Thank you for your feedback! We're glad to hear that the location of your rental right across from the pool was convenient for you. We hope it added to your overall enjoyment, and we'd love to welcome you back for another great stay!

Island Club staff

We had a great stay and no issues , the cabin was clean had everything we needed and can't wait to return !

Anonymous from Cincinnati - Posted: 6/10/2024

Thank you for your fantastic review! We're thrilled to hear that you had a great stay and found everything you needed in the cabin. It's wonderful to know that you're looking forward to returning. We can't wait to welcome you back for another delightful experience!

Island Club staff

The vacation was awesome, however, the house can use some updating and/or fixing.

Anonymous from Buffalo - Posted: 5/7/2024

We are so glad you guys enjoyed your time during Spring Fling and hope to see you back again soon! We are also going to let the owner know about the suggestions so we can make the house better for you and other guests!

Island Club staff

Wonderfully quiet and relaxing

Anonymous from Webberville - Posted: 9/25/2023

Thanks for the feedback!

Island Club staff

Clean, convenient, home away from home

Anonymous from Sherwood - Posted: 8/31/2023

Thanks for the great feedback!

Island Club staff

We had a wonderful time staying for my birthday. We were there for 4 days 3 nights with 6 adults and there was plenty of room to go around! We especially appreciated the beautiful kitchen with the essentials as we made large breakfasts each day at the rental. The staff is super friendly and helpful, and very very timely to get something fixed for you if you need it. All in all a great place to stay!

Anonymous from Grand Rapids - Posted: 8/24/2023

So happy to hear that you had a wonderful stay in our units for your birthday! We glad that everything was nice and beautiful and that our staff was helpful whenever you needed it. Thank you again for staying with us in our rentals and we hope to see you again for another birthday trip!

Island Club staff

Everything was exactly as expected. Great location and amenities.

Anonymous from Avon - Posted: 8/9/2023

We are so happy to hear that everything was as expected and we hope to be able to see you again with us soon!

Island Club staff

So our cabin was directly aftoss the street from the pool with a huge porch and grill, two tables and plenty of seating. Super spacious inside, planets of couches to relax on and a large island perfect for meals and socializing. There were 6 of his so we all got our own bed and the space was clean and updated.

Anonymous from Lakewood - Posted: 7/15/2023

Thanks for the kind words and great review! We are glad to hear everything was spacious enough for you and your group! We hope to see you again with us for your next trip!

Island Club staff

Wonderful stay was a great cabin.

Anonymous from Akron - Posted: 6/27/2023

We appreciate the 5-stars as you were also a 5-star guest! Thanks once again for staying with us in our property. We hope to see you back at your next stay at the Bay!

Island Club staff

The 6 of us were here to fish on Lake Erie. The location and accommodations were great. The parking was a bit troublesome but we made it work. We plan on returning so that says a lot.

Anonymous from Rhinelander - Posted: 5/20/2023

Thanks for the feedback Mark and we are happy that you had a great time! Can't wait to see you return!

Island Club staff

Very good, was stated to have parking for two boats/trucks and really only had room for 1. Electrical outlets and outside water spigot not ideally located

Anonymous from Hilbert - Posted: 5/2/2023

Hi Bob, all parking within the Island Club for more than one boat is going to be hard. I know Dottie is always there to be able to figure out parking for an extra boats, and it has worked out very well. Glad your stay was still good overall.

Island Club staff

Cabin was clean and neat.

Anonymous from Madison - Posted: 4/27/2023

Hi Ray, thanks for the great feedback and we hope to see again next season!

Island Club staff

Our Unit was clean and comfortable, would definitely come cack

Anonymous from Middletown - Posted: 10/11/2022

Hi Holly, thanks so much for the feedback and we are happy to hear it was a great unit for you! Hope to host you again next season!

Island Club staff

The club is very easy to find. Very quiet in early October. The cabin was clean, spacious. We paid for linens and they were clean and soft. The beds were very comfortable. The furniture was clean and comfortable. We had no interactions with the staff. Keyless entry was a breeze.

Anonymous from Apple Creek - Posted: 10/9/2022

Hi Susan, thanks so much for the great feedback! We are so happy to hear everything went smoothly, and our rental place was perfect for you!

Island Club staff

Stayed here with 7 girls. Great open area for entertaining. A few more hooks in the bathroom for towels would have been great! In the master there is an open area that another mirror could go or counter with a mirror. Would make is more convenient for multiple girls to get ready in at the same time. The staff is absolutely wonderful here! Will definitely return!!

Anonymous from Westland - Posted: 10/4/2022

Hi Tierra, thank you so much for all the good advice and feedback! We appreciate it more than you know and have let the owner know about some of the great extra features that should be added. We hope to see you and your group again next year!

Island Club staff

We had only stayed one night but it’s perfect for a little vacation ! Has a lot more in it than expected but very appreciated. Very clean and neat.

Anonymous from Harrod - Posted: 9/27/2022

Hi Kiya, thank you for your great feedback, we hope to see you again next year!

Island Club staff

The house was great as for location in reference to getting to attractions, paper supplies provided, and other items that were provided. We had a great time. A disappointment was the items that were wrong with the building. I understand that unless a renter informs you, you are unaware of it. But someone comes to clean and should notice it. I called to let you know of a # of items wrong with the building. Just saying. It was a great vacation to the area.

Anonymous from Macungie - Posted: 9/26/2022

Hi John, we are happy to hear that you had a great stay with us! We are also working on fixing all these issues in the off season. Other than that, we hope to see you again soon!

Island Club staff

Overall pretty good experience, would definitely like to visit again! The only negative was that the WI-FI didn’t work and the futon bed in the main area was broken.

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 8/23/2022

Hi Nicole, We appreciate the feedback. We certainly wish you would have called the office immediately during your stay so we could have made things right. If there is ever a reason that you are not satisfied during your stay, don't hesitate to call the office. We have a full staff on the island and can send someone over immediately to address any concerns. Our goal is to work hard so you can enjoy your vacation. We hope to host you again soon though!

Island Club staff

The customer service was excellent, and the house and furniture were great.

Anonymous from COVINGTON - Posted: 7/27/2022

Troy, Great to hear! We pride ourselves on excellent customer service!

Island Club staff

Had a GREAT 3 nights !! Place was great , clean , Ac and lots of room will definitely be back next year ❤️

Anonymous from Buffalo - Posted: 7/26/2022

Great to hear Shannon! Thank you so much for staying in our home!

Island Club staff

My family and I had a great stay. The rental was clean and comfortable. The staff was incredibly friendly and accommodating. They were constantly up keeping the landscaping and grounds. The pool was great. We would stay here again!

Anonymous from Clinton - Posted: 7/2/2022

Hi Gillian, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

As usual we had a fabulous time at the Island Club. Looking forward to 2023.

Anonymous from Buffalo - Posted: 5/11/2022

Super happy to hear the feedback, and we can't wait to host you again in 2023!

Island Club staff

Really enjoyed our stay. Have been fishing at Put in Bay for over 30 continuous years now and Island Club has the best to offer on the Island. Always a clean and well accommodated house and easy access to everything we need as fisherman.

Anonymous from Dakota Dune - Posted: 5/9/2022

We always love hearing great feedback from our loyal and returning customers! So happy to hear you had an amazing trip, and as always, we look forward to seeing you at the Bay again soon!

Island Club staff

The property description was accurate. The house was clean and well maintained; it was the nicest one that I have stayed in so far. I definitely recommend this house. Perry's Cave was very cool.

Anonymous from Guysville - Posted: 10/26/2021

Jamie, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay,Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

What a great time we had... the house was perfect for the 6 of us. The location was the best - we were able to greet everyone when they came into the Island Club!

Anonymous from Grove City - Posted: 9/15/2021

Stephanie, Thank you for staying in our property! It was great to host you and your group and we hope that you come back again soon!

Island Club staff

Good experience

Anonymous from Monroe - Posted: 9/13/2021

Darice, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

The island clubs was very nice, there were a couple minor things that were broken and dinged up from previous guest but other than that the place was very clean and the A/C worked great on those last couple August muggy days.

Anonymous from Bowling green - Posted: 8/31/2021

Logan, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

Perfect except for clogged bathroom sink.

Anonymous from AKRON - Posted: 8/28/2021

Gina, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future! Glad maintenance was able to quickly assist with the unexpected clog!

Island Club staff

Me and my kids have enjoyed staying the the Island Club. This year was our third year and we had another fun 4th of July Weekend.

Anonymous from Middletown - Posted: 7/7/2021

Marvin, So glad you enjoyed your stay on our quaint little island of Put-in-Bay! We look forward to hosting your group in the future!

Island Club staff

Had a great time. Loved the cabin, it was clean and close to everything

Anonymous from Springboro - Posted: 7/3/2021

Jennifer, So glad you enjoyed your stay on our quaint little island of Put-in-Bay! We look forward to hosting your group in the future!

Island Club staff

The stay was pleasant and quiet as usual. The pool was clean and relaxing. The workers were nice and professional. The house was clean and everything in working order. Would stay again.

Anonymous from Grove City - Posted: 5/29/2021

Nicole, Glad you enjoyed a peaceful stay. We look forward to hosting another trip for you in the future!

Island Club staff

Our accommodations were very roomy, pool was clean and quiet and cabin was in great location. Would recommend a cabin broom and mop as the floor was not cleaned between renters. Will return everyone was super friendly!

Anonymous from Eastlake - Posted: 5/27/2021

Brenda, Thanks for the feedback. All houses should have a broom and mop. We will replace those items in this house. In the future, if there is anything you need during your stay, please call the office. We have a very attentive staff on the island and we can be at the house within minute to replace items that the house may be missing. Glad you had a good time on the island! We look forward to hosting another trip for you in the future!

Island Club staff

As always, we had a great time. The staff are all so accommodating. We have been coming for at least 15 years for this event and plan to continue.

Anonymous from Buffalo - Posted: 5/5/2021

Jeanine, We appreciate the compliment to our staff! We take pride in ensuring our guests have a great vacation. So glad your group had a great time! We look forward to hosting another trip for your group again in the future!

Island Club staff

All guests enjoyed their time up at the island. It was more enjoyable than expected with the current situation. All kept us update on everything. The house was perfect for all 10 of us.

Anonymous from Versailles - Posted: 8/11/2020

Wonderful!

Anonymous from Wapakoneta - Posted: 10/31/2019

We enjoyed our stay in the Island Club #6. The house was clean, and in a very convenient location for our stay.

Anonymous from Strongsville - Posted: 10/12/2019

we came with 2 other couples for a birthday and had a great time! was a little inconvenient to have to bring your own sheets,towels...etc. next time we will be more prepared. overall great experience and would stay again!

Anonymous from Pinckney - Posted: 5/22/2019

The stay was nice.

Anonymous from Mishawaka - Posted: 10/2/2018

Good time. Prompt Taxi's to downtown which is convenient

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 8/29/2018

The house was very roomy and clean. Although we did have a little mouse problem. There was some Garbage under one of the beds. We could have used more garbage bags and toilet paper. Our overall stay was great and we will probably come back next year.

Anonymous from Angola - Posted: 8/25/2018

Great place! Had so much fun. right across from the pool. Rent a golf cart and tour the island, it is so worth it!! Clean, grill was great.

Anonymous from Kent - Posted: 8/9/2018

Girls trip! 7 of us. Villas were very roomy and clean. Staff was great too. Loved sitting out on the deck at night. Can’t wait till next year!

Anonymous from Randolph - Posted: 7/20/2018

Nice to hear that you had such an amazing trip! We look forward to having you ladies back again next year!!

Island Club staff

Very clean and maintained house, couldn’t ask for a better location on island with a bunch of good neighbors. Will be back again this year if not this year next year. I’ve been to put n bay for 4 straight years.

Anonymous from piqua - Posted: 7/1/2018

Great size for our family. Very convenient to pool. Only wish there was wi-fi in cabin.

Anonymous from Covington - Posted: 6/29/2018

Hi Kara, thank you for staying with us! House #6 has a great location close to the pool which adds to the fun of a stay on the island.

Island Club staff

The rental unit was as expected and described, with nice amenities and accommodations and recently renovated. It was in a good location (pool is basically right next to it) and it was easy to take a taxi from the development to anywhere we wanted to go. Wi-Fi and reception were not good but we weren't there to play on our phones and computers. Easy process to rent and good price, would recommend for families and (more so) getaway weekend for a group of friends. Thanks for a good weekend.
-Ben

Anonymous from New Albany - Posted: 6/26/2018

Hi Ben, thank you for staying with us and recommending our properties to other families and groups! Sometimes it is nice to unplug and enjoy the relaxing ambiance of island life.

Island Club staff

The cabin was renovated in a nice location. Staff was pleasant, but when they said they would bring more paper towels and trash bags, they were not received. Overall great experience.

Anonymous from Twinsburg - Posted: 5/22/2018

Thanks for the great review and for staying with us at Put-in-Bay. Thank you for mentioning the housekeeping, we have alerted the manager and resolved the issue. We hope to see you back again soon!

Island Club staff

It was all good as always

Anonymous from Shiocton - Posted: 5/8/2018

Hi Bob, thanks for choosing to stay at the Island Club. We're glad you enjoyed the house!

Island Club staff

Great value and amenities. Would definitely rent again.

Anonymous from Clearfield - Posted: 8/17/2017

This was our 2nd year in this cabin, I find your staff to be very accommodating we love the location and the furnishings of this place. The house in general was clean except the floor both times was filthy, thankfully there was a mop and bucket in the laundry room.

Anonymous from Erie - Posted: 7/23/2017

Phenomenal staff & very clean cabin! It was perfectly placed off the main strip for a family to stay! We will definitely be coming back next year :) we even rented two golf carts that were dropped off right at our cabin, huge convenience when you're traveling with little ones

Anonymous from Monroe - Posted: 6/26/2017

I would stay here again. Great location by the pool. Close to perrys cave. We ran out of paper towels and property staff brought us more within 5 minutes of our call.

Anonymous from Cincinnati - Posted: 6/22/2017

The owner was arround and asked if we needed anything .. Also staff helped us move our freezer back in to our truck Doty was also arround to c if we needed anything ....Very nice helpful people ...My 12th year there ...C u guys NXT year ...Bob Singler...

Anonymous from Shiocton - Posted: 4/23/2017

A bit group of us went out to PIB for my husband's 40th birthday. We rented two houses to house. I assumed that they are typically "party" rentals, but this one was much more modern and clean than I was expecting! I was very pleasantly surprised.

Anonymous from Ashtabula - Posted: 10/12/2016

Overall, I was satisfied with the total Put in Bay experience

Anonymous from Fort Wayne - Posted: 10/4/2016

Rented house #6 it was the nicest house I've stayed in at Island Club. Everything was great!

Anonymous from Youngstown - Posted: 9/27/2016

We were very pleased with our house, it was very nice with a very nice setting. The price was very reasonable compared to hotel pricing on the island.

Anonymous from Marion - Posted: 9/24/2016

will be back every year. change nothing one of the most funnest places to go in the whole Midwest i always recommend it.

Anonymous from South Bend - Posted: 9/15/2016

I split a cabin with several people, and it was clean and spacious! Looks to have been renovated since my last stay 3 years ago. Well worth the price, definitely recommend!

Anonymous from Winterhaven - Posted: 9/13/2016

The home was newly renovated and clean. Far enough away from the loudness of downtown but quick to get to through the taxi service.

Anonymous from Galesburg - Posted: 8/9/2016

Had a few minor problems but management took care of fairly quickly. loved location. Pool was just the right temperature and we could swim at night

Anonymous from Parma - Posted: 8/7/2016

This was our first time at Put-In-Bay, and we could not have picked a better place to stay. We will be returning next year.

Anonymous from Erie - Posted: 7/25/2016

We were quite impressed with the homes nice renovations, however when my kids were barefoot in the house their feet were black with dirt, not sure if the floors/carpets have ever been scrubbed. Also the wifi never worked for us which was frustrating, when I called they said it would be reset and would only work by the never worked.

Anonymous from Twinsburg - Posted: 7/16/2016

First of all the booking process was fantastic! Super friendly and efficient. The property was clean. There was a broken picnic table when we arrived that was repaired within 10 minutes of our arrival. We cannot say enough positive things about our experience!

Anonymous from Cleveland Heights - Posted: 7/7/2016

Cottage #6 is the best location, The cottage was immaculate. Kitchen is well stocked. Beds are comfy-cozy. Plenty of space for everyone to sit n watch TV, also to sit and enjoy a meal together. A few minor things needed to be taken care of, other than that, it was a great experience. The staff was so very very friendly :)

Anonymous from Cleveland - Posted: 6/23/2016

We loved staying here, it's so clean and beautiful, I love how we r farther from downtown but not that far! It was a blast I can't wait to come back next year!!!

Anonymous from Streetsboro - Posted: 6/12/2016

I had a nice time. The unit I had was recently renovated and very nice. I would also like to mention Dean. He was very helpful when something needed attention. Thanx Dean.

Anonymous from Mogadore - Posted: 6/10/2016

Everything was nice the cottage was nice and clean I love the way you guys have all the cleaning supplies and everything we needed already there it was a beautiful place to stay and I can't wait to stay again

Anonymous from Dayton - Posted: 6/6/2016

We had a wonderful time in Put- in- Bay! We loved the big deck and being right across from the pool! The golf cart was great for going to get ice or sightseeing around the island. Having so many beds was perfect for all 8 of us to be together in one house.

Anonymous from Union - Posted: 6/4/2016

Been staying there for 11 years ...could CV not b more impressed with the staff ...Dotie and the guys r like family and will do anything possible to help out ...liki getting boat parts from mainland ...they will go above and out of there way to help people ...thank u ...Bob singler

Anonymous from Shiocton - Posted: 5/1/2016