Put-in-Bay Island Club #62

My relation and I had a great time staying on the Island. The fishing was good and the cottages were great to stay in. Might want to consider something better for discarding fish waste.
We will be back next year.

Anonymous from Whitelaw - Posted: 4/23/2026

Thank you for your feedback—we’re really glad to hear you had a great time on the island and enjoyed both the fishing and your stay in the cottages! We also appreciate you bringing up the fish waste disposal. We understand it’s not the most convenient part of a fishing trip, and it’s something we continue working on with the township to improve. With the volume during peak season, it can be a challenge, but we’re actively looking at better solutions moving forward. Thanks again for staying with us, and we’re looking forward to having you back next year!

Island Club staff

The place was great! The only issue was no remote for the ceiling fan in the master bedroom. We used a fan they had that was super loud but I like the noise to sleep to.

Anonymous from Xenia - Posted: 8/18/2025

Thank you for the great review! We’re glad you enjoyed your stay and that the place worked well for you. We’re sorry about the missing ceiling fan remote in the master bedroom, and we appreciate you mentioning it so we can get it replaced. Happy to hear the backup fan still helped, even if it was a little loud! We hope to welcome you back again soon.

Island Club staff

We’ve stayed at a lot of places on PIB and this cabin is definitely at the top of our list! Very clean, updated and super easy to book. Would recommend 10/10

Anonymous from Wakeman - Posted: 6/28/2025

Thank you so much for the fantastic review! We're thrilled to hear this cabin is at the top of your PIB list and that you found it clean, updated, and easy to book. We appreciate the 10/10 recommendation and would love to welcome you back anytime!

Island Club staff

Cabin 62 for a first time staying on the Island was a very good experience. We had 2 people drop out because of cancer procedures but all in all everyone else was pleased. I lifted one of the toilet seats and the plastic pins in the back broke off (seemed as if it were broke before). No gas for grill but someone ran one a tank to us in 15-20 minutes. Lots of fisherman staying in cottages with similar goals were very nice and great conversations made it more enjoyable. We will be back next year with our grown up children to make it a family trip.

Anonymous from Whitelaw - Posted: 4/24/2025

Thank you for sharing your experience and choosing Cabin 62 for your first visit to the Island! We're glad to hear the trip was enjoyable overall, and we appreciate your understanding about the quick fix with the grill tank. We’ll take a look at that toilet seat right away. We’re already looking forward to welcoming you and your family back next year for another great stay!

Island Club staff

Our cottage with spacious quiet and felt like new. It was very clean with many updates. The beds were comfortable and had adequate space for a larger family. Staff were friendly. We had an initial problem with getting in with the code, but they resolved it quickly. Wi-Fi is not so good making it difficult to communicate with staff so just be aware you may have to walk around to make a call. The pool on the property was very nice and not too overcrowded making it enjoyable for the kids. Highly recommend renting golf carts as the distance into town is not walkable. The kids loved going everywhere on the island with a golf cart.

Anonymous from Alden - Posted: 7/25/2023

Thank you for your fantastic review! We're thrilled to hear that you had a wonderful stay at our cottage and enjoyed the spacious and quiet surroundings. We take pride in maintaining our properties to feel like new and we're glad to know that the updates made a difference in your experience. We're delighted that you found the cottage very clean and comfortable for your larger family. Providing a welcoming and enjoyable space for our guests is our top priority. We apologize for the initial problem with the code, but we're glad to hear that our team resolved it quickly for you. Your comfort and convenience are important to us, and we're pleased that the issue was addressed promptly. Thank you for your understanding about the Wi-Fi. We'll take this into consideration and explore ways to improve the connectivity for our guests. It's wonderful to know that the pool was a hit with the kids and that it provided an enjoyable space without being overcrowded. We're glad your family had a great time! We truly appreciate your recommendation of renting golf carts to explore the island. It's a fantastic way to get around, and we're delighted that the kids loved the experience. Thank you for choosing our cottage for your stay, and we can't wait to welcome you and your family again in the future. If there's anything specific you would like for your next visit or if you need any assistance, please don't hesitate to reach out to us directly.

Island Club staff

WE had a great time and had everything we needed. It was very relaxing and had no problems!

Anonymous from GROVE CITY - Posted: 7/26/2017

House smelt stale once we arrived, but after we freshened it it the property was great. Was a 6 minute drive to downtown which made it very convenient to drive back and forth. Would recommend this house to others!

Anonymous from Lorain - Posted: 7/18/2017

Always easy working with everyone at Island Club makes it even easier for us to come back year after year.

Anonymous from Hilbert - Posted: 5/8/2017

Have stayed before, everything was as we expected and some improvements were made.

Anonymous from Hilbert - Posted: 4/25/2016

Not too shabby. Not too shabby indeed.

Anonymous from Irwin - Posted: 7/6/2015

It was a great stay. A little difficult parking the boat and truck but we managed. Sleeping was very adequate. Two very weak spots in living room floor.

Anonymous from Larrabee - Posted: 5/21/2015

The house was clean and ready when we arrived. The staff of Island Club is always great!, Easy to get ahold of and quick to help with any issues. The only concern was the floor of the home is getting soft in a few spots.

Anonymous from Hilbert - Posted: 4/27/2015

We all had a great time and the unit was in a great location. The unit was compareable to its description on line We used the taxi service which was convenient to downtown.

The only issue we had was the appearance of the deck. It wasn't very clean but other then that it was great. We recommend this unit.

Overall we were very satisfied.

We'll be back in 2015!

Anonymous from Lowellville - Posted: 7/29/2014

It was nice. The master bathroom had some standing water in it and the carpet/bed was a bit dirty. Grill also didn't work at first but we had a guy come over quickly to help. That was good. Overall, I was definitely satisfied with our stay.

Anonymous from Chicago - Posted: 6/24/2014