Put-in-Bay Island Club #63

Cabin was very clean and comfortable, had decent parking for 2 boats and trucks

Anonymous from Spirit Lake - Posted: 4/27/2026

Thank you for your review! We’re glad to hear the cabin was clean and comfortable, and that the parking worked well for your boats and trucks, that’s always a big plus for fishing groups. We appreciate you staying with us and hope to have you back again soon!

Island Club staff

Great trip. House was clean and very comfortable. Staff answered any questions promptly.looking forward to next year.

Anonymous from Mitchell - Posted: 4/25/2026

Thank you for the great review! We’re glad to hear the house was clean and comfortable and that our team was able to take care of any questions quickly, that’s exactly the experience we aim to provide. We truly appreciate you staying with us and look forward to welcoming you back again next year!

Island Club staff

5 of us did a long weekend girls trip. None of us had been to PIB before, we had a blast and will be back. Paul was a great host and all
The staff we talked to were very helpful.

Anonymous from Lansing - Posted: 8/19/2025

Thank you so much for staying with us for your girls' weekend getaway! We're so glad to hear it was your first trip to Put-in-Bay and that you had a blast. Paul and the entire team truly appreciate the kind words — we’re always here to help. We can’t wait to welcome you back for the next adventure!

Island Club staff

We loved the location of this unit by the pool. The kids loved being able to run in the grass area too. There was plenty of room for our party of 8. The open kitchen/dining/family room was nice for us all to hang out together

Anonymous from Westlake - Posted: 6/14/2025

Thank you for the wonderful review! We're so glad to hear you and your group enjoyed the location by the pool, the open living space, and the grassy area for the kids to play—it sounds like a perfect fit! We’d love to welcome you all back for another fun and relaxing stay soon!

Island Club staff

We had a good experience. House was tidy and cute and paul was easy to contact.

Anonymous from Streetsboro - Posted: 5/19/2025

Thank you for the kind words! We're happy to hear you had a good experience and that the house was tidy and cute. We're especially glad Paul was easy to reach—communication is important to us. Hope to welcome you back again soon!

Island Club staff

Was very good ��, will stay again next year 5 5 5 5 5 5

Anonymous from Spirit Lake - Posted: 5/11/2025

Thank you for the great review and perfect 5s! We're glad you had a very good stay and can't wait to welcome you back next year!

Island Club staff

Loved the location of our cabin. Was awesome to have your own grill on your own patio with your own picnic table.

Anonymous from Columbia Station - Posted: 7/18/2024

Thank you for your feedback! We're thrilled to hear you loved the location of your cabin and enjoyed having your own grill, patio, and picnic table. We look forward to welcoming you back for another great stay at Island Club Rentals!

Island Club staff

Spent a couple of days at Put-in-Bay with friends. We have many good memories of the Island. This stay did not disappoint. We stayed at the Island Club and were very happy with the experience.

Anonymous from Tallmadge - Posted: 7/11/2024

Thank you for sharing your experience! We're thrilled to hear that your stay at the Island Club was enjoyable and added to your good memories of Put-in-Bay. We look forward to welcoming you and your friends back for more great times in the future!

Island Club staff

Simple place, don’t really stay in the house a bunch when you’re in PIB.

Anonymous from ETNA - Posted: 8/23/2023

Thanks for the feedback!

Island Club staff

Had a wonderful girl's trip and the house was perfect! Had enough beds and rooms to have some privacy and two bathrooms for ease of use between us all. The place was clean and had plenty of space in the living/dining room for us to eat and hangout. The AC worked wonderfully and had nice bathrooms and kitchen appliances for the vacation to save money on eating at home. We really enjoyed our time and loved having our own house to enjoy some privacy. Even used the pool which was very close to our location. The customer service was great! And the property was exactly as described and in a good spot. We did go out downtown which was a quick ride in our golf cart that we added on through island club as well

Anonymous from Akron - Posted: 6/28/2023

Thank you for sharing your wonderful experience from your girl's trip at our house. We're thrilled to hear that everything was perfect for your stay and that our accommodations exceeded your expectations. We're delighted to know that the house provided enough beds and rooms for privacy, allowing each of you to have your own space. We're glad you found the place clean and spacious, providing ample room in the living/dining area for eating and hanging out. It's great to hear that the bathrooms and kitchen appliances met your needs. We strive to provide well-equipped and comfortable accommodations to help our guests save money on dining out during their vacation. We're delighted that you were able to enjoy the amenities and convenience our property had to offer. We're pleased to hear that you had a great time and appreciated the privacy of having your own house. The proximity of the pool to your location must have been a nice bonus, allowing for some refreshing and relaxing moments. Thank you for your kind words about our customer service. Providing excellent service is a top priority for us, and we're glad to hear that we met your expectations. We're also happy that the property lived up to its description and was situated in a good spot for your convenience. Once again, thank you for choosing our house for your girl's trip. We appreciate your feedback and recommendation. We would love to welcome you and your group next stay at the Bay!

Island Club staff

Rental is excellent as always. I’ll see you next year.

Anonymous from De Pere - Posted: 4/24/2023

Hi Charles, thanks so much for the feedback and information. We appreciate it more than you know, and we cannot wait to host you again next year!

Island Club staff

Easy bike riding and safe mostly all flat areas and Beautiful scenery
A lot of friendly and entertaining bars with food and microbrews

Anonymous from Pittsburgh - Posted: 10/13/2022

Hi Richard, we appreciate the feedback and are glad to hear that everything was beautiful for you!

Island Club staff

This picture is not accurate, our cabin was under construction. Our shower and mattress were dirty. Under beds hadn't been cleaned...dirty! There were chairs used as night stands next to beds, the closet had construction materials in it including paint cans, a shop vac that was dirty. There were no lamps, only old overhead lights/fans in bedrooms and in main bedroom when turned on with fan, it made a noise. In entry, was laundry room, the door was falling off utility room. Living & dining were OK.

Anonymous from Akron - Posted: 9/26/2022

Hi Tim, I appreciate your feedback and certainly wish you would have called during your stay so we could have made things right. We have a full staff on the island that is available to assist if something is amiss. Our goal is to work hard so you can enjoy your vacation. Our housekeeping manager met with the team member responsible for cleaning your unit and performed some retraining. If we are lucky enough to earn your business in the future, our office staff would be happy to hand-select a house that would meet your standards.

Island Club staff

We had a great weekend here at Island Club rentals! The house was in good shape, but the house was in the process of getting renovated. My only concerns were that I almost got locked in the bathroom because of a faulty door knob and the back sliding door did not lock so a block of wood was placed as a door stopper that wasn't long enough. But overall a good experience!

Anonymous from Amherst - Posted: 9/26/2022

Hi Jacob, we appreciate your feedback and are happy to hear you had a good stay with us! We are sorry about the door knob, but I certainly you called the office so we could fix that for you! We do hope to host you again though!!

Island Club staff

This place was very clean ! Very spacious and very close to the pool with a large backyard area for games

Anonymous from Cincinnati - Posted: 7/20/2022

Becky, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

Great

Anonymous from wRIGHTSTOWN - Posted: 4/22/2022

We are so glad you enjoyed yourself and had a good time. We look forward to hosting/ having you again soon!

Island Club staff

everything went as planned, property in good condition. Dotty is great! Great upgrade with the cable and WI FI.

Anonymous from Hilbert - Posted: 4/29/2019

Great Stay as always. My 4th year in a row staying at the Island for the Battle in the Bay Volleyball tournament, and first time at #63. Again was not disappointed. Property is very clean and plenty of room for 8 people to stay!

My only complaint is that i think it is time for all the rental properties to have WiFi. I am pretty sure people would be willing to pay an extra 5-10 bucks a night for WiFi. Having Wifi at the pool is nice, but it would be better if it was in the villas also.

Overall, it was still a great stay and would stay here again!! Cant wait for next year!!

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 8/31/2017

Overall it was a great experience and I would stay with Island Club again. Few things I was disappointed with....our grill was in such bad shape that we almost called to have it replaced but didn't want to delay dinner. Almost all the bedroom light switches did not work which made it difficult when the sun wasn't up. There were no smoke alarms at all in our cabin which is not safe. When we arrived the place was clean and ready to go which was nice. Loved our location on the island and we had a yard behind us which allowed us more room so that was a plus. Like I said overall it was a good experience besides those few things which made it difficult at times.

Anonymous from Stow - Posted: 8/1/2017

We stay at the Island Club every year for our annual Lake Erie fishing trip. The staff are wonderful and the accommodations are just what we are looking for. Will book again next year!

Anonymous from Malone - Posted: 5/8/2017

I was in town for a PIB guys trip in August, and man was it a great time! The pool being at the club was a plus as well, because if you didn't want to travel downtown you could always party on site. Definitely using again.

Anonymous from Akron - Posted: 8/10/2016

Had a great time overall and was very pleased with the condition of the house. The grill had plenty of propane and the house had all the amenities that we needed for our weekend stay.

Anonymous from Cleveland - Posted: 7/6/2016

Great for a group of friends.
A great alternative to staying in a hotel

Anonymous from Amherst - Posted: 6/9/2015

We had a great time lots of fun good people partying. Had a blast just one issue with one of our 2 golf carts. The one was so slow we didn't even use it.

Anonymous from Ypsilanti - Posted: 5/12/2015

The Fall Ball at The Island Club is always a great event with fun people and first class lodging.

Anonymous from Marblehead - Posted: 10/21/2014

This was just a party haven. We were on a dead end street and every time we had to get to the house, we had to go through about 20 guys playing corn hole and some kind of Frisbee game right in the middle of the street. Also our "neighbors" were having sex on the back deck and doing things most people would not consider okay. I am just grateful I did not have any little ones along. I thought this was a family oriented weekend with the boy scouts camping at Perry's Monument, but it sure did not turn out that way. I know I will not rent from this place again, and I don't believe I will ever return to Put-In-Bay.

Anonymous from Bentleyville - Posted: 9/9/2014

The house was nice but the back door sliding door did not lock which I was unhappy with. Sense we brought a lot of things and money to spend. Other then that it was nice. And the boys around us were under age which seemed to be annoying when they were banging on our house at 4 am

Anonymous from Luisville - Posted: 8/5/2014

This was the PERFECT location for me and 7 college friends! We loved having a back porch to do our own entertaining on, but the pool was also a nice place to hang out. The house was very clean and served its purpose for us! It's not high end by any means, but for a bunch of college kids, it was perfect. We want to come back every year, book this place, just do it !

Anonymous from Burbank - Posted: 7/22/2014

This home is very big, and I love the wrap around deck. However, they should consider replacing the carpet with linolium or something simliar. The carpet is really gross. There was crusty puke on the carpet in my bedroom from the last guest that was there. The other suggestion I have is that they consider removing all of the tall grass around the swamp that's in the backyard. It blocks the view of the pool, is filled with garbage, and attracts TONS of bugs, frogs, and other wildlife, which sort of puts a damper on the deck idea. Other than that, I love the Island Club. I always have a great time. I've been five years in a row, and I will continue to come back. The property GM, Dottie, is amazing. She is so sweet, very helpful, and very welcoming each year. The taxi drivers are awesome as well! I would definitely recommend staying at the Island Club. With exception to the carpet in this year's rental home, I've always walked in to a clean home. Their staff does a great job cleaning the home, bedrooms, and bathrooms :) :) :) whis is very important to me. I would definitely recommend staying at the Island Club if you're visiting Put-In-Bay!!!

Anonymous from Trenton - Posted: 7/16/2014

It was so much fun well worth the money spent. Cabs are very convenient. Just wish the place was a bit more clean and a couple of pieces of furniture where already broke when we entered the location.

Anonymous from Sylvania - Posted: 6/3/2014

The home was ready when we arrived and was in a condition that I would expect it to be in. Management was helpful and the taxi's were extremely convenient. I would recommend the Island Club to anyone looking to have a good time in Put In Bay.

Anonymous from Cranberry Twp - Posted: 7/15/2013

Unit had several broken pieces of furniture however other units nearby seemed to have nicer furniture and be in better shape. Would stay with Island Clubs again just not with Unit 63.

Anonymous from Grove City - Posted: 5/28/2013