Put-in-Bay Island Club #66

We had a group of 16 people and rented this unit and unit 68. This home was perfect for the 5 couples we had in this home and truly loved the large island where we enjoyed cards at night and breakfast with everyone in the morning. We stay at Island Club everytime we come to Put In Bay and love it.

Anonymous from Windfall - Posted: 5/12/2026

Thank you so much for the wonderful review and for continuing to stay with us every time you visit Put-in-Bay! We’re thrilled to hear the homes worked perfectly for your group and that the large kitchen island became such a great gathering spot for cards, breakfast, and making memories together. It means a lot to our team that you continue choosing Island Club Rentals for your island trips, and we can’t wait to welcome your group back again soon!

Island Club staff

We had a blast. The house was clean and the a/c ran well. The kitchen is well stocked with items to use. There is plenty of space inside and outside. We had a group of 14 and didn't feel cramped at all. We'll be reserving again.

Anonymous from Pittsburgh - Posted: 8/18/2025

Thank you for the wonderful review! We’re so glad to hear your group had a blast and that the house provided plenty of space inside and out for all 14 of you to feel comfortable. It’s great to know the clean home, well-running A/C, and well-stocked kitchen made your stay even more enjoyable. We truly appreciate you choosing us and look forward to welcoming you back when you reserve again!

Island Club staff

NEVER EVER HESITATE TO RENT FROM IALAND CLUB! The people are super nice, the area is really fun and they got great golf cart rentals! Highly recommended.

Anonymous from Girard - Posted: 7/15/2025

Wow—thank you so much for the incredible review! We’re thrilled to hear you had such a great experience and truly appreciate your kind words about our team, the fun atmosphere, and the golf cart rentals. Your high recommendation means a lot to us. We can’t wait to welcome you back to the Island Club for another amazing stay!

Island Club staff

This location was a great place to stay. We had a party of 14-15 people, and it had a lot of space, and we did not feel crowded in the house. My only complaint would be that some of the door handles were a little loose and the bathroom light fixture was not on fully (did not affect us at all; just random notes). I would recommend staying here if you have a larger group. Very clean and spacious, all other guests near us were friendly as well.

Anonymous from Waterford - Posted: 6/30/2025

Thank you for the detailed review! We're glad to hear the house was spacious and comfortable for your large group and that you found everything clean and the neighbors friendly. We appreciate the note about the loose door handles and light fixture, and we’ll have our maintenance team take care of those. Thank you for recommending us, and we’d love to welcome you back again!

Island Club staff

This house was satisfactory and met all the needs of our stay. The house is in need of some cosmetic changes. There were parts of walls that were plastered but not painted. Towel racks were absent in one of the bathrooms and one bedroom had to be entered through another. None of these items interfered with the wonderful time we had.

Anonymous from Baden - Posted: 5/24/2025

Thank you for your honest and balanced review! We're glad to hear the house met all your needs and that you had a wonderful time during your stay. We appreciate you noting the cosmetic issues like the unfinished wall patches, missing towel racks, and the bedroom layout—these are helpful details that we’ll be sharing with our team as we work to improve the space. Thanks again for staying with us, and we’d be happy to welcome you back anytime!

Island Club staff

It was a great stay! Slept 15 pretty comfortably.

Anonymous from Malta - Posted: 9/30/2024

Thank you for your feedback! We're glad to hear that your stay was great and that the space accommodated 15 people comfortably. We hope to welcome you back again soon!

Island Club staff

Awesome place! Everyone staying there was so friendly and fun. Not too loud all night either! Definitely will stay again

Anonymous from Vero beach - Posted: 8/25/2024

Thank you for your fantastic feedback! We're thrilled to hear you had such an awesome time and that the atmosphere was friendly and enjoyable. It's great to know that it wasn't too loud at night, making for a comfortable stay. We look forward to welcoming you back again soon!

Island Club staff

We come every year! We enjoy getting a group together and going to Island Club for our stay. Lots of activities, food, wine and natural beauty of the water. Island club has the comfort you need for your getaway.

Anonymous from Hilliard - Posted: 10/18/2023

Thank you for being a valued and loyal guest at Island Club! We truly appreciate your continued support and are thrilled to hear that you and your group enjoy your annual stays with us. It warms our hearts to know that you find our resort a perfect blend of activities, culinary delights, and natural beauty. Creating memorable experiences for our guests is our top priority, and we are delighted to have been a part of your getaways. Your kind words about the comfort and amenities at Island Club are greatly appreciated. We are committed to providing a relaxing and enjoyable environment for all our guests, and it's wonderful to hear that we have met your expectations.

Island Club staff

Needed a larger unit for 11-12 guests. This property fit the bill.

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 9/28/2023

Glad everything was great for you and your guests!

Island Club staff

Vacation rental was very nice for our weekend getaway! Nice open living space and the patio was fantastic we spent a lot of our time out there! Did not realize that two bedrooms were connected but it was not a make or break! Rental was clean and in great shape for us when we arrived!

Anonymous from North Ridgeville - Posted: 6/27/2023

Thank you for taking the time to share your positive feedback regarding your recent weekend getaway at our vacation rental. We're thrilled to hear that you had a very nice experience and enjoyed the amenities we offer. We're delighted that you found the open living space and the fantastic patio to be highlights of your stay. It's wonderful to know that you were able to spend a significant amount of time outdoors, taking advantage of the beautiful setting and creating lasting memories. We apologize for any confusion regarding the connected bedrooms. While it may not have been what you were expecting, we're glad to hear that it did not significantly impact your overall enjoyment of the rental. We appreciate your understanding in this matter. Maintaining cleanliness and ensuring our accommodations are in great shape is a top priority for us, and we're pleased that you found everything to be clean and well-maintained upon your arrival. Providing a comfortable and inviting environment for our guests is something we take great pride in. Thank you once again for your kind words and for choosing our Island Club Rental for your weekend getaway. We truly value your feedback, as it helps us to continually improve and provide exceptional experiences for all our guests.

Island Club staff

Nice house with plenty of room for entertaining.

Anonymous from Mentor - Posted: 10/10/2022

Hi Jack, thanks so much for the feedback and we hope to see you again soon!

Island Club staff

Perfect as always

Anonymous from wRIGHTSTOWN - Posted: 4/19/2022

We are so glad you enjoyed yourself and had a good time. We look forward to hosting/ having you again soon!

Island Club staff

Was enough space for all the people we had and we actually had hot water...was great and would definitely stay again

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 11/9/2021

House worked out real well nice and clean. Needed a broom and vacuum.

Anonymous from Parkston - Posted: 4/23/2021

Hi Gale, Thanks for letting us know so we could replace the broom and vacuum. We look forward to hosting another trip for your group again in the future!

Island Club staff

My family had a great time. The rental property management team were very responsive to our needs and even delivered our golf carts to the door!

Anonymous from North Fort Myers - Posted: 11/12/2019

Great location

Anonymous from Cincinnati - Posted: 6/12/2019

The property was a little dated and there was no twin sized trundle bed as listed in the property description. We also had an issue with a leak in one of the bathrooms. I contacted the property manager they were able to resolve our issues very quickly. Overall our experience was satisfactory.

Anonymous from Westerville - Posted: 4/30/2019

Amazing experience on island as well as our stay at island club rentals.

Anonymous from Frankfort - Posted: 9/11/2018

Although this property was in a great location and had plenty of room to accommodate our party of 15 (10) adults and (5) kids the bedding situation wasn't exactly how described. There was only 1 twin size bed, no twin trundle, and a twin not so clean mattress in a closet. One of the bedrooms smelled so molded, and mildewed that we couldn't sleep in it . It had my allergies going crazy. My eyes watered for two days after leaving. There was also no broom or dustpan at the place, so after calling and waiting for 30+ minutes for one to be brought to us we finally had to walk over to get one. There was several items left from past guest including clothes behind the washer. The dry needs a second go around in order to fully dry the clothes. I would recommend this property to others with a little fixing up. Maybe removal of the carpet in the bedrooms would help with the smell.

Anonymous from warren - Posted: 9/9/2018

Nothing but positive things to say. We had some extra people join last minute and everyone was very accommodating

Anonymous from Westerville - Posted: 7/24/2018

Thanks for the positive review Neolon! We look forward to having your group back in the future.

Island Club staff

What a great spot! We had a group of 12 of us and it was the perfect size and location for us! Easy to go out and get back with their taxi services.

Anonymous from Woodstock - Posted: 5/29/2018

Hi Ryan! Thanks for staying with us! We're glad you enjoyed it!

Island Club staff

Island club 66 was a good place

Anonymous from Van wert - Posted: 5/15/2018

Thanks for the great review and for staying with us at Put-in-Bay. We hope to see you back again soon!

Island Club staff

Worked perfect for are 3 week stay well priced

Anonymous from Holland - Posted: 5/7/2018

Hi Landon! We're glad to hear that you enjoyed your stay. We hope to see you again soon!

Island Club staff

The house was perfect for what we needed! We had 16 guests and most of them had never been to the Island before. We had an absolute the entire weekend and Dottie was fantastic with all our needs and Pomps was the man taking us where we needed to go whenever we needed to go since our golf carts didn't work. The only issues we had were with the golf carts. We didn't even get to use them because of all the issues they were having (needing replaced due to not accelerating, steering going out of one, etc.) Other then not being able to use the golf carts we paid for, the house was great!! We will definitely be back!

Anonymous from Ashland - Posted: 10/21/2017

We had so much fun at #66 . Room for everyone.. and great seating for a big group of people . I love island club !!

Anonymous from Westlake - Posted: 10/25/2016

My son's bachelor party with 12 other fine young gentlemen.

Anonymous from Lafayette - Posted: 10/11/2016

Cabin style great location. They get there cleaning fee no matter what and nothing provided but good time .

Anonymous from Denver - Posted: 9/23/2016

The rooms were small but well designed to get the maximum amount of people in. The AC worked great. Good amount of tables and chairs even dishes. I think there was a wild party before us. There were beer cans and bottles behind the dresser, doors coming off the hinges and missing toilet paper holders.

Anonymous from Whitehall - Posted: 7/22/2016

Property was clean and fully stocked with cooking supplies (pots & pans, dishes, cutlery). My only complaint regarding the house is that there are 3 bathrooms but only one has a towel rack which means that you have to throw towels & washcloths either over the shower rod or just lay on the counter tops. Also, none of the bathrooms had toilet tissue rollers. Both of these problems could easily be remedied by someone making a small purchase from a dollar/discount store.

Also, on my first day in the house the Direct TV wouldn't display many of the channels that it was supposed to and by the last day there were maybe 10 that you could watch. There are many trees around the property and I believe this contributed to there not being a good signal.

Anonymous from Cincinnati - Posted: 7/18/2016

Big house that sleeps plenty of people. Taxi's are always around to go wherever you need. For a get together with all your friends, it's just what we were looking for. Also come with a propane grill to do some cooking out! Everyone really enjoyed it! House wasn't in the greatest of shape though, so if your looking for somewhere nice, this isn't it. If your looking to party, this is the one!

Anonymous from Bellbrook - Posted: 7/13/2016

It was fun did the trick for a bachelor party

Anonymous from Highland hts - Posted: 7/11/2016

The house was great for the price. Stayed during the week and enjoyed all the space. However, the Satellite had trees blocking it, so only got some channels, no biggie, except we didn't get the Cavs Nat Champ game! Otherwise small issue with golf carts that they made up for.

Anonymous from Prospect - Posted: 6/29/2016

Good place to stay if you want to be close to the action.

Anonymous from Chilton - Posted: 5/17/2016

Enjoyed our stay. Place is conveniently located close to everything. Staff was very accommodating.

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 9/25/2015

The house was in a good location and was one of the few that had enough space for a large party. The process itself was very easy and seamless. My only complaint is the condition/cleanliness of the house. First of all they don't tell you to bring your own hand soap so we didn't but then didn't have any and they were unable to provide any. Second- there was mold on the ceiling in the bathrooms and paint peeling in places. We also saw a mouse in the house which was pretty gross. So overall- professional staff, easy transaction, great location, but certainly not overly clean.

Anonymous from Mansfield - Posted: 8/5/2015

Our rental served its purpose. We had 14 guys here for a bachelor party. The property was not the cleanest and there were several bugs throughout the home when we arrived. We also saw a mouse in the living room on Friday night. Overall the property was in fair condition. Our trash can was completely full when we arrived however so we had no room to place our trash. I would recommend this property for bachelor parties but that is about it. If you are expecting something a little nicer then this is not the place for you.

Anonymous from Fishers - Posted: 7/18/2015

Clean...Plenty of room...Cold AIRCONDITIONING. Would stay at #66 again.

Anonymous from Ravenna - Posted: 7/7/2015

This is very nice and cozy house. Our group had a great time on this tiny island just before July 4.This condo is close to a state park, biking rental, gemstone mining (cave touring), momunment, kayaking, winery, and many nice shopping stores. The island is quiet and has a lot of fresh air. I feel that this is an ideal place for relaxation. This is a place where you can get away from the noisy environment and your busy life.

Anonymous from Carmel - Posted: 7/5/2015

We had a wonderful time! Even though the weather was poor and we stayed inside all day Saturday - the accommodations allowed for easy hang-out in the dreary weather!

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 6/30/2015

This was a great place to spend any summer weekend w/ friends and family. The cabin offered everything a party of 16 would need. I would highly recommend this place to anyone, and hope to be back soon!

Anonymous from Fort Myers - Posted: 5/28/2015

Our AC was broken but the maitence crew was more than happy to fix it for us and as soon as they learned about our problem they were on it right away and offered us various solutions. It was much appreciated to know we were a priority. Every staff member there was extremely nice and helpful. Thank you very much

Anonymous from Olmsted Falls - Posted: 5/22/2015

Had a great stay would be nice to have kitchen towels and wash clothes supplied with house. A mop would also be nice to clean better before we left. We didn't have these supplies and therefor didn't get all of our deposit back.

Anonymous from Saint Marys - Posted: 5/12/2015

Although a bit outdated everything was clean and comfortable. The staff was incredibly friendly and accommodating. My group and I absolutely plan on returning.

Anonymous from Oak Park - Posted: 10/8/2014

It was an overall great experience. The only thing that was bad was the air conditioning on the first night. It did not work and was extremely hot. The next day it was fixed and much better.

Anonymous from Olmsted Township - Posted: 8/19/2014

Our villa was clean but we did have a few maintenance issues. The shower was out of service in one bathroom and the electrical outlets did not work in this bathroom either. But the maintenance and management team was on it! We called to let them know our issues and they immediately were at our villa trying to fix the issues. We ended up only having 2 showers for 16 people which was quite inconvenient but the kindness from the staff was so amazing we were able to enjoy our stay! I hope the other tenants that stay at the Island Club enjoy the remarkable service they offer and stop causing damage to villas so when others check in they can to have a great experience. We stay in different villas at the island club but we always stay loyal and come back due to the management staff!! Thanks for another great year!

Anonymous from Canton - Posted: 8/12/2014

We rented houses 65 and 66. We had a wonderful experience. The homes were clean and we were very satisfied with the accommodations.

Anonymous from St. Henry - Posted: 7/5/2014

We arrived to a TERRIBLE smell in the house. It was musty to the point you could not inhale. Very disappointing arrival. Open windows and fans all weekend helped, but it was not the experience we'd hoped for. We were glad it was addressed quickly. Location was great and other than the smell, the house was fine.

Anonymous from Pittsburgh - Posted: 7/1/2014

Plenty of room for three households. We'll be back.

Anonymous from Baltimore - Posted: 6/30/2014

Our experience went well at #66. We had everything we needed and had a great time.

Anonymous from Willoughby - Posted: 6/29/2014

The home was beautiful, clean, and confortable and the taxi drivers were amazing!!! House needs to be stocked with more tp : )

Anonymous from Fairview Park - Posted: 6/24/2014

Overal was a great experience. A little expensive but overall worth it! The back deck of our house needs to be looked at! Rotten wood and one of our heavy set friends fell right through while walking. Scratched his leg up pretty bad but over all place was great!

Anonymous from Middletown - Posted: 5/27/2014

Had a great weekend!

Anonymous from Circleville - Posted: 10/22/2013

Only complaint I have was not a lot of toilet paper given (there was 15 girls) Overall wonderful experience and will come back again! Thank you :)

Anonymous from New Castle - Posted: 9/22/2013

My $100 bedding was thrown on the floor in a bag. We had differant size beds and it was a chore to get the correct size on the beds. I would have thought that bedding be placed on each bed for $100. Other than that everything was nice.

Anonymous from Cape Coral - Posted: 9/13/2013

The environment and stay was great! Dottie the GM was AMAZING and made the experience extra great! We had a large bachelorette party and everyone had a good time. The taxi service to and from Island Club was fast and cheap! My only complaint was the cleanliness and appearance inside the cabin. Some rooms were nice but others were very outdated and crowded. Still, the place was perfect for a large group weekend getaway!

Anonymous from Blacklick - Posted: 8/29/2013

We enjoyed our stay at the Island Club. The staff was very helpful. The beds were very comfortable. Supplies were adequate but cleaning chemicals need to be labeled.

Anonymous from Stryker - Posted: 8/17/2013

We come to PIB every year and always stay at the Island Club! We love the houses and our own private pool.

Anonymous from Lenexa - Posted: 8/15/2013

good boys weekend, lot of fun.

Anonymous from Essex - Posted: 8/9/2013

We had a great time! Cabin had new beds - pleased with utinsels/silverware/dishes in kitchen. Will do it again!

Anonymous from Lafayette - Posted: 8/5/2013

MINUS: The unit (66) was not as clean as I hoped---carpet needed vacuuming under/behind beds, there was a broom but no dustpan. Kitchen was not "stocked" as I had hoped---not very many pots/pans of various sizes, not very many serving utensils, and no grilling utensils.
Refrigerator was missing shelves. Windows/doors were missing screens.
PLUS: Nice grill, large patio with picnic tables, washer/dryer in unit.

Anonymous from Lisle - Posted: 8/3/2013

All will to help. Just give them a call they will get what you need.

Anonymous from Stow - Posted: 7/30/2013

We are a group of 16 and we had the best time at Island Club resort. Dot was just amazing she went above and beyond to make sure our stay was amazing. The other staff was also amazing.We would highly recommend this resort to anyone. Thankyou Island Club, Dot, & staff for an awsome time we will be back.

Anonymous from Crystal beach - Posted: 7/15/2013

We stayed two days and had 5 couples. It said there was 5 bedrooms so we thought it would be perfect. The only issue was the one bedroom is more like a large closet with no ventilation. So the one couple slept in the living room the second night. There r limited kitchen supplies and we didn't think to bring wash clothes for dishes. Other than that it suited the purpose... Wish it was a little cheaper. Nice place, nice employees , nice atmosphere.

Anonymous from Taylor - Posted: 6/30/2013

It was a great time, the house was perfect for us. Had plenty of room to move around and not be all bunch up together. There was a couple things already broken when we got there. but other then that i can complain.

Anonymous from Toledo - Posted: 6/19/2013

We all had a fun time. Taxi drivers were great and Jerry was available and helpful in the days leading up to the stay. Keep up the good work.

Anonymous from Mentor - Posted: 6/12/2013

Management is so wonderful and always helpful. I have been coming to the island club for over 6 years now, never had a bad experience. I recommend it to everyone I know!

Anonymous from akron - Posted: 5/7/2013