Put-in-Bay Island Club #67

spring walleye fishing trip

one suggestion - the tree by the driveway causes lots of issues parking. also you have a squirrel living under the house, his hole in the side of the house is by the back deck. Just FYI thanks

Anonymous from Mitchell - Posted: 4/17/2026

Thanks for staying with us and for the helpful feedback—we really appreciate you pointing these things out. We’ll take a look at the tree by the driveway to see what can be done to make parking easier, and we’ll have our maintenance team address the squirrel issue near the back deck right away. Hope you had a great spring walleye trip, and we’d love to have you back again!

Island Club staff

Stay was good.
Been there several times. We had different cabins this year. We like our previous ones better.

Cooking utensils are better this year... thank you.

Anonymous from Mitchell - Posted: 5/2/2025

Thank you for your feedback and for being a returning guest — we truly appreciate it! We're glad to hear the cooking utensils were an improvement this year. Sorry to hear the new cabins weren't quite your favorite, but we’ll do our best to get you into one of your preferred units next time. Looking forward to welcoming you back again!

Island Club staff

family and friends for an end of summer weekend
excellent place to stay

Anonymous from Lancaster - Posted: 9/16/2024

Thank you for your review! We're thrilled to hear that our place was perfect for your end-of-summer weekend with family and friends. We hope to welcome you back for more great stays in the future!

Island Club staff

The house was clean & comfortable. It should be noted that the dryer is not vented outside. The vent tube is just laying on the floor behind the dryer. The handle is also broke off the refrigerator.

Anonymous from Winneconne - Posted: 5/8/2023

Hi Joe, thanks so much for the feedback and I let the Island Manager know about the vent and handle on the fridge. Hope to see you again next stay with us!

Island Club staff

The place is in the right location during the fall ball. The place suits our needs.

Anonymous from Monaca - Posted: 10/6/2022

Hi Terri, thanks for your feedback and we are so happy you had a great "Girl's Weekend." We hope to host another Girls trip for you guys again soon!

Island Club staff

We loved staying at the house and will most definitely stay in the area again. Everything was accurate according to the description (the beds were a little small - not accustomed to full size beds, but we realized that they are the only size that will fit in the bedrooms.) The house could have been a little cleaner, but overall we were satisfied. We made a couple of maintenance requests (outside garbage can was missing and kitchen sink faucet was loose), but we texted the number and they sent someone to take care of this. We rented golf carts from the Island Club which were waiting for us when we got there....very convenient. We would recommend the Island Club to others.

Anonymous from Harrison - Posted: 5/17/2022

We are happy to hear you had a wonderful stay! I have informed our Island Manager in regards to doing a better job with the cleaning, and she apologized, and will be better in the future. We are also glad to hear that your issues got resolved fast.

Island Club staff

same as review for 65

Anonymous from Tilley Park - Posted: 5/9/2022

Glad to hear you had a great experience!

Island Club staff

Everything was excellent. The cabin was clean and ready when we arrived. This is our second year back and will continue staying on the Island!

Anonymous from Sioux Falls - Posted: 4/12/2022

We are extremely pleased that you enjoyed your stay, and we hope to have and host you again soon!

Island Club staff

First visit was not sure what to expect. Over all a good place to stay and visit.

Anonymous from Loveland - Posted: 11/2/2021

Kelly, Thank you for staying in our property! It was great to host you and your group and we hope that you come back again soon!

Island Club staff

Had a great ladies time with family and friends

Anonymous from Monaca - Posted: 11/1/2021

Terri, Thank you for staying in our property! It was great to host you and your group and we hope that you come back again soon!

Island Club staff

We have stayed multiple times with Island Club rentals. All have been very enjoyable

Anonymous from North Royalton - Posted: 10/12/2021

Michael, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

The cabin was perfect for our family. It had everything that we needed and was super close to the pool.

Anonymous from Marysville - Posted: 9/18/2021

Megan, Thank you for staying in our property! It was great to host you and your group and we hope that you come back again soon!

Island Club staff

Would recommend and stay again.

Anonymous from Middleburg Heights - Posted: 8/14/2021

Brian, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We hope to host another trip for your group in the future!

Island Club staff

Great time cleaned well supplied units. Dottie responded to all our request as usual



dottie

Anonymous from Tilley Park - Posted: 5/16/2021

Joe, So glad your group had a great time! We look forward to hosting another trip for your group again in the future!

Island Club staff

Stayed for 9 nights while fishing on Lake Erie. The accommodations were great with ample room. It was nice to have a place you can cook and eat without having to go into town to eat out every time. Brought a 21’ boat and the driveway accommodated it just a little tight.

Anonymous from Sioux Falls - Posted: 4/13/2021

Hi Eric, Glad you had a good time! If you ever need help finding additional parking for your boat, our island manager Dottie can help. You can always call the office and we will give you her cell. We look forward to hosting another trip for your group again in the future!

Island Club staff

Ok loved the laid back atmosphere, being on an island, no commercial business and most of all the gulf carts. So much fun, will definitely be going back.

Anonymous from Elkview - Posted: 7/26/2020

Hi Alison, We are glad that you enjoyed your stay with us. Your group was wonderful and we look forward to hosting another trip for you in the future!

Island Club staff

Bachelor party. Room was spacious and clean. Perfect for a group of 6-8 people.

Anonymous from New Castle - Posted: 6/16/2020

Great experience from start to end. No complaints at all. Z and Josh are the absolute best to work with. Houses are clean, modern and cozy.

Anonymous from Allen Park - Posted: 6/10/2020

The place is nice and this is the third year we have been here in the same rental

Anonymous from Monaca - Posted: 10/8/2019

OFFICE WAS VERY HARD TO GET AHOLD OF WHEN WE WANTED TO CHECK OUT.. wE NEEDED TO KNOW WHAT TO DO ABOUT THE GOLFCART WE RENTED OTHER THAN THAT IT WAS A GOOD PLACE TO STAY

Anonymous from Lafayette - Posted: 9/26/2019

We had a great experience here. everything was promised, plenty of room, island taxis were always available for a 3$ ride. The staff was great, I would stay again

Anonymous from petersburg - Posted: 9/1/2019

quiet and peaceful for the most part. so nice to have the golf cart waiting for us and ready to go.

Anonymous from Delaware - Posted: 8/17/2019

Outside of us having trouble with the internet it was a great place to stay. Its a little far from downtown but definitely manageable. Great place to stay with for a large group of people.

Anonymous from Toledo - Posted: 8/2/2019

Place was clean. No issues with anything and we all enjoyed the stay.

Anonymous from Mount Pleasant - Posted: 7/23/2019

Great location! Staff was great too! Def will go back. House was good but def a rental.Pool was very nice.

Anonymous from Belmont - Posted: 7/14/2019

This was our first time renting House 67. We loved the location and the house was a great size for 8 girls. We had plenty of room with 2 bathrooms. The kitchen, dining, and livingroom have an open concept which allows enough space for socialization. We were told laminate flooring, and new furniture for the livingroom were going in this house which will be a great enhancement. A hightop table in the dining area would be awesome too.

Anonymous from Westland - Posted: 5/9/2019

Always a pleasure

Anonymous from Fort Pierre - Posted: 4/21/2019

Great stay as always. The property is well kept, and the staff is very easy to work with. My only criticism is that the WiFi needs to be improved.

Even with that said, would definitely stay there again!

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 9/5/2018

It was a good time me and my friends had a blast

Anonymous from Cincinnati - Posted: 9/5/2018

Property was clean and conveniently located to downtown area. Staff was very friendly and courteous

Anonymous from Coraopolis - Posted: 8/28/2018

Nice home to have for a couple days at PIB.

Anonymous from Mentor - Posted: 8/14/2018

Great place, very comfortable and a ton of fun!

Anonymous from Huron - Posted: 8/7/2018

Pleasureable, relaxing time for all. Great suggestion to rent a golf cart to get around. Property was in excellent location and easy to get to town, monument, restaurants and etc.. We really enjoyed the great weather, too!

Anonymous from Lincoln - Posted: 7/8/2018

Hi Nancy, we are glad you had such an enjoyable trip and took our recommendation of renting a golf cart!

Island Club staff

Once again it was a great place to stay

Anonymous from Fort Pierre - Posted: 4/30/2018

.

Anonymous from Tarentum - Posted: 10/17/2017

Went to the fall fest and had a great time. The rental was very nice but needed a few upkeeps. We plan on going back.

Anonymous from Monaca - Posted: 10/11/2017

we enjoy the experiance. house #65 had an AC issue but was fixed quickly.
thanks

Anonymous from Elkhart - Posted: 9/26/2017

clean when we showed up and everything was in good condition. Cabs rides are easy to come by and very convenient. Great stay once again.

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 8/24/2017

Home was large and well equipped,two small maintenance issues were fixed within less than a hour. Rent a golf cart, they have it waiting at your door when you arrive, it's the only way to get around on the island.

Anonymous from Cleveland - Posted: 8/18/2017

The Cabin was great, just has pictured on the website. Would recommend to anyone that asked. This is the first time in this cabin but have been renting cabins for several years. Have not had any complaints in all the years we have stayed there.

Anonymous from Perrysville - Posted: 8/11/2017

We had a great time. I enjoyed having a privacy of our own little house but still surrounded by a nice community of people.

Anonymous from Ossian - Posted: 8/11/2017

Excellent place with an excellent staff. Always a great time. The location and setup of the homes is great.

Anonymous from Wheeling - Posted: 6/6/2017

We enjoyed a wonderful weekend with our group at our vacation home. Our home was very well clean and had new carpet which made our place look very nice and well taken care of. The manager provided good service and helped us out very quickly when we had a flat tire on our golf cart. We enjoyed playing putput golf and riding around the bay. Decorating our golf carts was a lot of fun. We would recommend this trip to all of our friends and family. We had a great time.

Anonymous from Utica - Posted: 9/15/2016

Upon arrival house looked a little rough, screens were torn in windows and back deck was covered in leaves. Inside house looked nice and clean, just a little dated. The oven didn't work, but maintenance came and said they would order a new one but wouldn't arrive before we left. The sink in the master bath constantly drips. The sweeper doesn't work very well and when I went to move the coffee table the right back leg fell off. Other than that, we had a great time and there was plenty of room for all.

Anonymous from Hartville - Posted: 8/23/2016

The cottage was clean and perfect for our families needs! We were close to the pool and cart rentals ! We will be back again!! Thanks

Anonymous from Acworth - Posted: 8/13/2016

Overall a good stay as usual. Didn't have to wait long for cabs to get downtown. Not much to complain about.

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 8/2/2016

I have stayed with the island club before and really enjoyed it,however this time around we did not have hot water in the entire condo for the whole weekend and a couple of the rooms did not have lighting that was working. We still made due and had a great weekend but I will be checking these things when I get into the island first thing.

Anonymous from Cuyahoga Falls - Posted: 7/11/2016

Our experience with Island Club Rentals was great. The staff was very friendly and helpful with any questions I had. Our house was exactly as described, great location, and very clean. It was a short golf cart ride to anywhere we wanted to go. I would highly recommend Island Club Rentals to anyone going to Put in Bay.

Anonymous from New Castle - Posted: 7/8/2016

Was a great place to stay for a bachelor party. Enough room for everyone to sleep. Spent all day outside playing corn hole and cooking on the grill. Close enough to walk to the pool while carrying a cooler.

Anonymous from Blairsville - Posted: 6/29/2016

Very satisfied

Anonymous from Oshkosh - Posted: 5/8/2016

Great time as usual !

Anonymous from Warren - Posted: 10/20/2015

We were very satisfied with our rental house at Put In Bay. We really loved having the house on the corner. We enjoyed joking with our friends that we live in the corner house. Our house was clean, the carpet looked nice, it was painted nicely, had lots of supplies, and was very comfortable. The beds were also very comfortable. We would love to take our family back again.

Anonymous from Utica - Posted: 9/24/2015

I have never been to PIB before, but it was exactly as it has been described to me, as well as the Island Club. Perfect place to host my sister's bachelorette weekend getaway. However, the prices seem incredibly high for the quality of the home and what comes in the home. Over $1,000 per night was extravagant for a home near Lake Erie.

Anonymous from mayfield hts. - Posted: 9/15/2015

Place was in excellent condition. I had 3 properties rented for a weekend and all were in good shape and the staff was very accommodating.

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 9/2/2015

We have stayed at Island Club every summer for the last 3 years. House #67 was the best house but we also had a bigger group of girls, so it accommodated us well. We loved how it was so close to the pool. Tony (cab driver) is ALWAYS wonderful as well as his mom!!!!! We will never stay any other place on the island (unless Tony and his mom quit!!!)

Anonymous from Bridgeville - Posted: 7/31/2015

We had a great time

Anonymous from Curtice - Posted: 7/24/2015

Had a great time.The cottage was clean and was everything I expected and would definitely book again with Island Club ,thanks again for a very enjoyable stay.

Anonymous from Charlestown - Posted: 7/18/2015

The house was very clean and conveniently located. The beds were comfortable and clean. It was nice to have a dishwasher and a washer and dryer. I didn't get to sit on the porch because of the bugs - a screened in porch would be a plus for the homes in the Island Club especially with the wet lands around it. The golf cart trip into town took about 8-10 minutes. The negative things - no towel bars/hooks in the bathrooms to hold wet 456towels and no WiFi. They say you can get WiFi at the pool but that is hit or miss - so don't expect that you will be able to hook up.
The furniture was OK - it has clearly seen some good parties on the weekends. The A/C system worked very well but the bedrooms could use a ceiling fan as it got very stuffy at night. The maintenance staff was very responsive. Overall we had a nice time for a reasonable price!

Anonymous from Pittsburgh - Posted: 6/28/2015

PERFECT! STAFF HELPED QUICKLY AND OFTEN WHEN NEEDED.

Anonymous from Akron - Posted: 6/23/2015

We had a great time, perfect location, close to pool, tony the taxi guy was the best. The only thing that was wrong- shower in master bath was very small

Anonymous from Beaver Falls - Posted: 5/12/2015

The unit was very basic but adequate overall. Mid-week, after Labor Day, it's very quiet in the complex and on the island. Unlike a hotel, these units have space to play cards, cook food together, and adequate seating to watch tv. There are annoyances-no ice cube trays, bright garish lighting, no lamps in the bedrooms to read by, and you can tell it has gotten a lot of use.,we would never stay here on a weekend before Labor Day. The most important thing is, the price is right. Also, the management is easy to deal with.

Anonymous from Bay Villiage - Posted: 9/14/2014

I was glad I called to make a reservation. The nice folks there recommended the home that was just right for our family. 67 was very nice and clean, plenty of space and nice lot. I would request this one again, would just be nice to see a few dollar store hooks in the bathrooms to hang a towel or washcloth. Staff was attentive and the gentleman that helped us with our golf carts was great. Thanks IC for making our first trip to PIB and great one.

Anonymous from Cincinnati - Posted: 9/9/2014

I give the Island Club an overall 6/10. I stayed with my family (ages 3 - 74) and we all had fun. The pool was great, they bring property-rented golf carts to your door, which is convenient. The houses (we rented 2) were not very clean. In the one house, there was no battery in the smoke alarm. Our back patio overlooked an algae pit. It didn't help that it rained much of the time (not the Island Club's fault). OK for a short stay or partying with friends.

Anonymous from Lakewood - Posted: 8/16/2014

Our vacation rental experience was exceptional and staff were very prompt with any request or problems within the cabins. We look forward to next year!!!

Anonymous from Dayton - Posted: 8/10/2014

Overall very good experience. The only complaint would be that the floor in front of the master bath was in need of repair and didn't feel it should be left in that manner. Enjoyed the stay!

Anonymous from Franfort - Posted: 6/30/2014

The only issue we had was when there was a problem with our golf cart, We called at 8am and didn't get a call back until 9 at night. Other than that.. had a great lot .. great stay. Thanks

Anonymous from Galloway - Posted: 6/19/2014

Our family had a great time!

Anonymous from Middleburg Heights - Posted: 5/30/2014

Great fun May Bash was a blast

Anonymous from Sioux Falls - Posted: 5/21/2014

We enjoyed the fishing, which was great and also the accommodations. Everything was neat and clean and the people were very friendly and helpful.

Anonymous from Brillion - Posted: 4/23/2014

Horrible weather , and the time of year pretty much ruined our much looked forward to trip to Put In Bay... But the owner of the house we were supposed to stay in was very sympathetic and understanding of our situation and did not hesitate to reimburse all of our money back. He even went one step further and got us a discount deal at another (awesome) resort since he knew my kids, who were on fall break, were very disappointed. I would not hesitate to book another trip to Put in Bay and I will definitely be staying at Island Club Rentals again.

Anonymous from Westfield - Posted: 11/10/2013

The house was clean and had everything we needed. There was plenty of room for 8 people. It really helped us enjoy our trip to Put In Bay. This is where we will stay from now on!

Anonymous from Kent - Posted: 10/22/2013

The island club rental was nice and it was great to get coupons but if you go in the off season many of the attractions are closed so the coupons are not useful. Pretty area, close to the downtown area. Definitely more for adults without children, although there are some things for families to do.

Anonymous from Hobart - Posted: 9/26/2013

Everything was fine . Would make a few changes such as having a vacuum cleaner on premises, trash can moved to be more accessible. Light bulbs did not all work and need to be repaired small things that would help in the overall stay. Waste can in the bedrooms would also be nice as well as some smaller glasses in the kitchen. This is an older rental and has seen some wear but overall very nice.

Anonymous from Jackson - Posted: 9/22/2013

Great rental location. far away enough from Pool noise. Yet close enough too nap at pool.

Anonymous from Eastlake - Posted: 9/13/2013

This is the third time our group of friends has rented this house. Great location on the property and close to the pool. The cabs are also plentiful and the best on the island!

Anonymous from Chicago - Posted: 9/6/2013

Nly probblem the bed were very unncomfortable

Anonymous from Frankfort - Posted: 8/16/2013

We loved the staff. They greeted us right away and communication was a breeze before we arrived. There was some confusion on how to enter the home with how they lock up and they were available for help immediately.
We stayed with kids and our parents and it was perfect for us. We had a small yard for the kids to run and a pool within walking distance even for potty breaks(it was close). I definately recommend this company and this home in particular. Having a tv with cable was really awesome too. full kitchen and grill to help cost. We LOVED cruising the island with the golf cart.

Anonymous from Cedar Rapids - Posted: 8/4/2013

The cabin was a little beat up but ultimately I really enjoyed my stay at Island club. Every summer a group of us go to PIB and there is no other place we prefer to stay than with IC. Thanks for a good time as always

Anonymous from Elyria - Posted: 8/4/2013

I was expecting the place to be a little bit more cleaner. At the end of our stay we cleaned it up better than it was when we came in.

Anonymous from Westlake - Posted: 6/11/2013

The Island club is a great place to stay. My unit had large amounts of damage when i checked in. Not one person in my group smoked but I spent the weekend picking up left over butts to avoid a fine... Cleaning staff obviously took shot cuts!

Anonymous from Lakewood - Posted: 6/4/2013

We had a excellent stay at Island Club Rentals. The manager was very helpful. The house was in a great location and was very clean. We go back here year after year. They are the best place to stay on the island!

Anonymous from Whitelaw - Posted: 4/23/2013