Put-in-Bay Island Club #80

We stayed in unit IC80. For the price, we couldn’t beat it. Spacious, easy to get to, close to everything. The only downside, no fire rings. We have camped at the State Park for years and also rented several homes on the island. After Labor Day, you basically have the island to yourself.

Anonymous from Ravenna - Posted: 9/20/2025

Thank you for your review! We’re glad to hear Unit IC80 was spacious, convenient, and a great value for your stay. We appreciate your note about fire rings and will keep that feedback in mind. You’re right—after Labor Day, the island really does have a peaceful charm, and we’re so happy you got to enjoy it. We’d love to welcome you back for another visit!

Island Club staff

Check in was easy, cabin was clean and well kept. Area was nice and quiet.

Anonymous from Rocky River - Posted: 7/28/2025

Thank you for the great review! We're happy to hear check-in was smooth and that you found the cabin clean, well-kept, and in a peaceful location. We hope to welcome you back for another relaxing stay soon!

Island Club staff

everything working as expected. nice deck and patio to relax.

Anonymous from Hilbert - Posted: 5/12/2025

Thanks for the review! We're glad everything met your expectations and that you enjoyed the deck and patio—perfect spots to relax. Hope to host you again soon!

Island Club staff

Good house for our needs

Anonymous from Oshkosh - Posted: 5/12/2024

We're glad everything was good for you and your groups needs. We appreciate the feedback and hope to see you again soon!

Island Club staff

I have been going to Island Club for many years for the spring fishing season. Plan to return again next year.

Anonymous from Mitchell - Posted: 5/8/2024

We are so happy to hear that you keep coming back and always have a great fishing season every time! Thanks for the review and we will see you next year :)

Island Club staff

For our family annual trip to put in bay we decided to go up during Halloween weekend. Most generally there is 6 to 8 of us that go on this fall trip. We always stay at the island club. Easy to book our stay and super friendly. Our cabin is always ready when we get there and the best part is we rent our golf carts from them too. That way they’re there when we get there and we just have to leave them when we leave. Always a nice place to stay and nice people to deal with. That’s why it’s our go to when we go to put in Bay for the weekend.

Anonymous from Caldwell - Posted: 11/28/2023

Thank you so much for your wonderful review and for choosing to stay with us at the Island Club for your annual family trip to Put-in-Bay, especially during the exciting Halloween weekend! We are thrilled to hear that your experiences with us have consistently been positive and that booking your stay and renting golf carts have been convenient and hassle-free. Our team takes great pride in ensuring that everything is ready for your arrival so that you can start enjoying your vacation right away. We hope to see back with us again for another great trip!

Island Club staff

It was a nice large cabin with lots of beds.

Anonymous from Fairfield - Posted: 9/7/2023

Thanks for the feedback and we are happy everything was good during your stay!

Island Club staff

Excellent experience

Anonymous from Rittman - Posted: 7/4/2023

We are so happy to hear that we were able to provide an excellent experience for you and your group! Hope to see you again next year!

Island Club staff

Our place was clean, the people we contacted for help were always helpful. Would definitely rebook and recommend!

Anonymous from Zanesville - Posted: 7/1/2023

Thanks for the great feedback, Ashya! We are glad we were prompt and the place was clean enough to fit your needs. We would love to see you back in our rentals for your next trip to the Island!

Island Club staff

We come ever year at the same time. We really enjoy the rental of the cabin and plan on coming next year.

I came twice this year and will be back next year twice

Anonymous from Mitchell - Posted: 4/27/2023

Hi Jack, glad to see you back with us twice this year! We hope to see you even more next year!

Island Club staff

Convenient booking and check in. Quiet and relaxing stay. The pool was refreshing and the ease of a golf cart delivered to the front door for excursions around the island. The staff were quick to assist with the slightest concern. Would highly recommend!

Anonymous from Mcconnelsville - Posted: 7/31/2022

Kathleen, Great to hear the wonderful compliment to our staff! We really appreciate that and are glad that they made your trip wonderful!

Island Club staff

We were very satisfied with our stay the. Cabin was clean and comfortable
Everything worked and the location was fine.

Anonymous from Daggett - Posted: 4/19/2022

We are so glad you enjoyed yourself and had a good time. We look forward to hosting/ having you again soon!

Island Club staff

we use the same property every year.

Very good experience

Anonymous from Mitchell - Posted: 4/12/2022

Always a pleasure to you host you guys! Glad you enjoyed your rental, and we look forward to seeing you again :)

Island Club staff

The home is exactly as described. Nothing fancy but we were not going to spend a ton of time in the house anyway. The beds were comfortable. The kitchen was minimally equipped with enough stuff to cook if you want to but again nothing fancy. Location is great in a community with other similar hoes. They are a little close together so if you have noisy neighbors you will know but we were fine and the community has rules regarding noise. The pool looks very nice and neat. The community is neat and clean and in the woods which is nice. I stayed here with my 16-year-old son and 2 of his friends. We had plenty of space and the washer and dryer made it nice so we didn't have to pack too much. I would stay here again in a heartbeat. The reservation process and check-in were easy, smooth, and fast. I literally reserved the place less than 24 hours before we left for Put in Bay and I had absolutely no issues. I received my security deposit check returned to me in the mail about 10 days after our stay.

Anonymous from New Albany - Posted: 11/2/2021

Gregory, Thank you for staying in our property! It was great to host you and your group and we hope that you come back again soon!

Island Club staff

I enjoyed staying at this property! The community was private and felt very safe. The house was perfect for a fun party weekend on the island.

Anonymous from Indianapolis - Posted: 8/10/2021

Alice, Glad you enjoyed the pool! Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

it was the perfect location, i loved this cabin will defiantly come back.

Anonymous from Martins ferry - Posted: 6/15/2021

Sunshine, We are glad you had a good time on the island and look forward to hosting another trip for your in the future!

Island Club staff

The rental was in a great location. Everything was as described. We had a great time. Property is a little dated but clean and everything was in working order.

Anonymous from Dayton - Posted: 4/27/2021

Hi Yvonne, Glad you enjoyed the location! We look forward to hosting another trip for your group again in the future!

Island Club staff

I have been staying at Island Club rentals for several years. Beautiful, clean Island homes! An amazing time as always! Thank you

Anonymous - Posted: 7/18/2020

Hi Karen, Thanks for staying with us and we are glad you enjoyed your stay! Your group was wonderful and we would be happy to host another vacation for your group in the future!

Island Club staff

Sliding doors would not lock. We usually rent early, only to see deals pop up that we can't take advantage of.

Anonymous from Brooklyn - Posted: 7/3/2020

Hi Joseph, We apologize for adding last minute deals. We normally have our deals set early in the season but with our unpredictable opening, we had some challenges doing that. Call me directly next time you stay and I'll be happy to find the best deal for you and your group! -Kelly

Island Club staff

nice place

Anonymous from Downers Grove - Posted: 6/21/2020

It was fun relaxing. The only complaint was that the events for the weekend were a little confusing as we were told and it was noted that food was included Friday and sat and Friday the event had no idea what we were talking about. The rest of the trip was great.

Anonymous from Celina - Posted: 10/22/2019

Great place to stay. Cabin was great outside grill could be replaced.

Anonymous from Garfield Heights - Posted: 9/1/2019

We love it there... So beautiful.

Anonymous from Arcade - Posted: 8/21/2019

From the time we got off of the fairy, till we got back on the fairy to go back onto the main land we had a wonderful time. We always felt safe and comfortable. the lodging was great, beds were comfortable. Looking forward to going back next year.

Anonymous from Pittsford - Posted: 8/9/2019

Very cool place to hang with family and friends!

Anonymous from Tampa - Posted: 6/28/2019

Always a great time when we stay in Island Club #80. House was clean, staff is amazing as usua, some of the furniture could use updating in living room but over all good!

Anonymous from Kirtland - Posted: 5/8/2019

It was secluded but still close to the town which was great

Anonymous from Cleveland - Posted: 6/19/2018

Hi Justine, we are glad you enjoyed the secluded, quiet location of this Island Club home!

Island Club staff

This makes our 10th year staying at the island club rental and as always the stay excellent and we had a blast! Great property and service

Anonymous from Garfield Hts - Posted: 6/5/2018

Hi Samuel. Thanks for staying with us for such a long time. We really appreciate it! We're glad you enjoyed the property and had some fun!

Island Club staff

Good

Anonymous from Naperville - Posted: 5/30/2018

Hi Prathyusha, Thanks for staying at the Island Club. We're glad you enjoyed your house!

Island Club staff

#80 is great

Anonymous from Kirtland - Posted: 5/8/2018

Hi Lisa, thanks for staying with us. We think #80 is a great house and we're glad you enjoyed it!

Island Club staff

Very pleased with our overall stay, Dottie and her were very help full with any of our concerns.

Anonymous from Tilley Park - Posted: 5/6/2018

Hi Joe, thanks for choosing the Island Club! We're glad you enjoyed to property!

Island Club staff

Very good

Anonymous from Mitchell - Posted: 4/19/2018

Always a great stay in #80 this was our 6th yr in this house we love it!! this year there was a new fridge, stove & microwave. Only thing that was missing was a grill outside!

Anonymous from Kirtland - Posted: 5/9/2017

As usually we enjoyed great accommadations. The fully equipped cottages were truly appreciated especially the washer and dryer which came in handy with the wet weather we had. Maintenance and the cleaning staff were quick to respond to all are request (thanks Dottie). Wonderful trip except for wind and rain, plenty to do in town on the weather days

Anonymous from Tilley Park - Posted: 5/8/2017

The house was spacious and clean. A few things should be addressed with the rental. The outlets in the house need updating because our chargers wouldn't stay plugged into the walls. There should be an iron (we had to wear wrinkled clothes) and a vacuum cleaner available, the house was mostly carpet and that is hard to sweep. Overall the property was great and our dedicated Taxi made getting around the island easy.

Anonymous from Willoughby - Posted: 10/25/2016

We had a very nice time! Dogs are allowed - no charge during the week, so our 2 came along. We all had a very nice stay. This unit is clean, well maintained. Town is quiet this time of year, esp during week. Very peaceful

Anonymous from Cuyahoga Falls - Posted: 10/1/2016

The rental was okay, trouble with the was either a sauna or an ice box. Other than that, the house served the purpose of shelter for volleyball players :)

Anonymous from Ravenna township - Posted: 8/17/2016

We had such a great time again. We are making plans ro extend our PIB trip for 2017.

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 8/9/2016

Dottie is awesome and she deserves a raise!!

Anonymous from Perrysburg - Posted: 8/2/2016

Clean

Anonymous from Chagrin Falls - Posted: 7/20/2016

Great! Accommodations were perfect and staff was friendly!

Anonymous from Parma - Posted: 7/5/2016

We used a Groupon for our stay and feel the price was right. There were 4 adults and 3 children and we had plenty of room. We did have to work in a very poorly lit kitchen. Only 1 light over sink and it was not working well. The house appeared clean when we arrived and it was well stocked with all we needed in the kitchen. We soon learned that if we walked around in the house barefoot, our feet were black on the bottom. One only wonders if that was not coated on the furniture as well. As I stated, our price was good but can not imagine paying more during the summer. We may have had a special unit because of Groupon but I am not sure. The location was great and children enjoyed the pool, and it was quiet. I would take advantage of a special again but not full price.

Anonymous from Trenton - Posted: 7/1/2016

Rented for the weekend, it did the job and we had no issues. Pricing is a little high but of course it's put-in-bay in the summer and the interior is outdated but would recommend

Anonymous from Lorain - Posted: 6/29/2016

We had a wonderful time on this trip! The beds are extremely comfy and the home was clean and pretty. Customer service was helpful. No one bothered us so we were glad to come and go as we pleased. One note: we used the over for pizza and a piece of toast must have been in the top broiler and dropped onto our pizza ewwww! but other than that surprise the house was neat and clean. We did not use the grill because it had quite a bit of cobwebs and things stuck to it. We could have cleaned off but just didn't make it appetizing for the others on our trip. All in all it was a wonderful place to stay and we loved it!!

Anonymous from Lafayette - Posted: 6/25/2016

Experience was OK - had to ask for linens and towels for right amount after help had NOT provided proper amounts. Grill Gas bottle was completely empty and had to ask for new bottle. Staff (Dotty, Brandy and Tony) are the best in the world!! They worked very hard to accommodate the issues above. It is clear that your golf carts are NOT in the best repair as we had two break down - Again, Dotty was most accommodating, but she cant fix broken down carts. they are clearly under-maintained, in my opinion. I know that Dotty has a HARD job making everyone happy and she is to be commended for that. The pool is completely inadequate for weekends - we never tried to get to it as it was shoulder to shoulder. It might be fine during the week, but we were a family on a weekend and had no desire to enter such a crazy packed area.

Anonymous from Independence - Posted: 6/23/2016

Cottage was clean and had plenty of room. Staff was very nice when I called to ask questions. Overall, very good experience.

Anonymous from Whitehouse - Posted: 6/16/2016

Overall very good. Home could have been a bit cleaner upon arrival but overall no issues

Anonymous from Uniontown - Posted: 5/31/2016

I will recommend this villa to anyone planning on proposing and staying the weekend. Everybody had a blast!

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 5/26/2016

We always have a blast at Island Club...We've stayed in #80 during spring fling for 5 years now and we love were it is located on the property. Only downfalls are a shelf in the fridge has been broken all five years & this year the shower in the master bath was backed up during the first use so we decided to just use the other shower. I did notice a few upgrades also....new stove & new sliding doors. We'll definitely be back next year!

Anonymous from Kirtland - Posted: 5/10/2016

We had 13 ppl. last year and due to our bragging of the great fun this group had in 1 overnight experience it grew to 30 ppl and 2 nights this year! The treatment from Island Club was and is fantastic and EASY to work with getting our now annual trip put in place. THANK YOU ISLAND CLUB!!!!

Anonymous from Mount Vernon - Posted: 10/8/2015

The house was clean, the area outside was clean and the Island club people were fantastic!

Anonymous from Galloway - Posted: 9/22/2015

Clean, accessible, accommodating

Anonymous from Parma - Posted: 8/25/2015

get place for 3 couples to stay. house was great to relax, sleep & cook.

Anonymous from Tilbury - Posted: 8/23/2015

Pros -

1. It was clean when we arrived.
2. Nice location.
3. Comfortable beds and furniture.

Cons -

1. Water pressure is quite low. There is an extra large bathtub, but it took like 20 minutes to fill it to the point you could get a bath in it.
2. The hot water is actually more like WARM.
3. The grill had food on it and obviously had not been cleaned in a while.
4. There were one or two lights that were burned out.

***The onsite staff was very helpful once we got there. On the downside however, the young people that answered their phones were usually in too much of a rush. We asked where we could get a pizza delivered and the girl pretty much blew us off and hung up. Also, I specifically asked before the trip if the hot water was HOT and if the water pressure was good in this home as I'd seen comments that there had been problems in the past with water pressure. I asked about this both over the phone as well as in my registration email. I was assured it would be good. Obviously, no one bothered to take my request seriously and inform me this place does have low water pressure in the bathrooms.

That being said, we had an enjoyable stay, but I wouldn't stay in this property again.

Anonymous from Mason - Posted: 8/2/2015

We had a great time staying at the Island Club for the weekend. Good people, nice cottage and lots of good times.

Anonymous from Corunna - Posted: 7/29/2015

Great house, great location, fun atmosphere!

Anonymous from Hilliard - Posted: 7/14/2015

All-in-all a great time. We had two properties side by side at the island club and both were perfect for our 19-man bachelor party. Much better than staying in 4-5 hotel rooms. Dottie (and the rest of her management crew) were very very nice and always helpful if we needed anything. Only downside, the bugs are really bad at night.....which isn't anything negative about the island club....you just have to make sure that all the doors are closed at night.

Anonymous from Bethel Park - Posted: 6/10/2015

As always another great week at Island
club. Very nice fully furnished cabins and great location.

Anonymous from Tilley Park - Posted: 5/26/2015

We enjoyed our stay and had great fishing

Third year for us and we are coming back next year. Thanks

Anonymous from Mitchell - Posted: 5/7/2015

Always have a great time in #80. Been staying in #80 for 4 years now....one issue is the fridge.....bottom shelf is broken...there is duct tape holding the door guards on. Other that that we love it. People are always helpful and friendly.

Anonymous from Kirtland - Posted: 5/5/2015

All good except the weather.

Anonymous from Galena - Posted: 4/28/2015

We had a great time staying at the Island Club! Fun, safe and affordable this property is a great deal and has all the amenities one would expect while on Pu-in-Bay. The staff is very helpful and attended to our every need and request!

Anonymous from Willoughby - Posted: 9/11/2014

Love these houses!

Anonymous from Youngstown - Posted: 8/22/2014

Overall I was pleased with the Island Club. The location was right in the middle of the island about an 1.5 miles outside of the village. The condo was clean with all of appliances working fine, but did show a few signs of wear. The pool was nice, but on the small side. Biggest complaint was the lack of wi-fi in the condo. The location isn't ideal for cell phone coverage.

Anonymous from Hilliard - Posted: 8/14/2014

This cabin was easy to find and easy to check into using the keypad on the door. There was lots of sleeping space and the cabin was relatively clean, except for the bbq which we decided not to use. It would have been helpful to have some handsoap and coffee filters supplied and more than one dishtowel - these are ususally standard items in most rentals. Overall, we were happy with the cabin rental and would recommend it to others.

Anonymous from Waterloo - Posted: 8/10/2014

This survey only gives me a yes our no option on if I would recommend the property and I'm not sure. I was not unhappy with Island Club but not thrilled with that particular cottage. Not very clean. Things broken.

Anonymous from Kent - Posted: 7/24/2014

We enjoyed staying here and will definitely return next year.

Anonymous from Avon Lake - Posted: 7/22/2014

Great for our stay!

Anonymous from stonecreek - Posted: 7/14/2014

The vacation rental was ok, there were ants crowling all over the counter,the refrigerator wasnt cold enough, if your coming with a large family they have plenty of room to acomidate. The beds were comfortable,bathrooms were clean.i would definitely rent again.

Anonymous from Lockport - Posted: 7/13/2014

When we first arrived we saw there were bugs everywhere, coming to find out that was nothing. They were mayflies a whole lot of them. Apparently we came during the 2 weeks they come to put in bay too! We would ride around in the golf cart and get hit with them, by the end of the trip it actually was funny it was like nothing we had ever seen before. The island club did a great job for us we needed a 6 person golf cart and they did not have any available but they ended up giving us 2 four person golf carts that worked out very well. We thank you a lot!!!Good times

Anonymous from East Canton - Posted: 6/21/2014

Great time

Anonymous from South Euclid - Posted: 6/20/2014

My girlfriends and I have stayed in #80 for the last 3 years on spring fling weekend and we love it!! Only 2 small issues this year....the second bathrooms toilet wasn't flushing well & one of the sliders in the fronts curtain rod was just balanced on the brackets and kept falling off. Other than that we love it and wouldn't want to stay anywhere else!

Anonymous from Kirtland - Posted: 5/20/2014

Lamps are few and broken.
Missing lightbulbs.
Microwave trips circuit breaker.
Refrigerator broken.
Refrigerator freezes food.
No screens on windows.
SLiding glass doors off track.
Few bureaus to store stuff.
Direct TV didn't work first day.
AC didn't blow cold air.

Anonymous from Galena - Posted: 5/13/2014

I have one huge complaint about my stay. We were promised wifi access, but did not have any which proved to be a huge disadvantage. I will be contacting the company for a follow up on this.

Otherwise, we really liked the place. It was disappointing how much of Put-in-Bay was closed during Easter weekend, but we were warned. We had a great time hanging out, the place was very clean and the beds were extremely comfortable! Definitely would reccommend it to anyone.

Anonymous from Cleveland - Posted: 4/22/2014

everything was very organized and everyone was very friendly and helpful

Anonymous from Englewood - Posted: 10/16/2013

I've been visiting PIB since I was 5 or 6 yrs old. I've stayed on boats at the marina, hotels in town, and camped multiple times as well. With a group over 5 people, the Island Club rentals is a great place to stay. It's rather costly, but what on the island isn't? I would say even with the cost that it was one of the more fun stays I've had. It was late in the season and we had 7 people in the house. It never felt crowded and with 2 full baths, itwas more than adequate space. I'll be renting there again.

Anonymous from Cedar Park - Posted: 10/9/2013

It was a nice rental with accomodations we need. The grill was fantastic to make all of our food on. The air conditioning felt good after a long day of walking around. The pool was clean and the kids enjoyed swimming. It was a nice and relaxing stay. Thank you!

Anonymous from Grove City - Posted: 8/12/2013

Kitchen ware had no variety. Bathrooms were not as clean as could be.

Anonymous from Brunswick - Posted: 8/3/2013

We had a blast. The Island Club had everything we needed and more. There were a couple blemishes as far as previous tenants but that had nothing to do with the owners. They brought the golf cart to us and picked up. It was like Enterprise on the island! We were able to grill out everyday due to them providing a gas powered grill and the patio was large enough to accommodate a couple dozen people. Thank you so much for making our trip a truly special one.

Anonymous from Akron - Posted: 8/1/2013

We had a great time as always, every year were here at Put-in-Bay!

Anonymous from Amherst - Posted: 7/29/2013

Actually, was pleasantly surprised at the value of this property in this high traffic vacation location, and (on the weekdays at least) how pleasant and quiet it was for our family group of 5 seniors, 65-81. The value, especially compared to a motel room, was excellent. The entire Island Club was well maintained, the staff was friendly and helpful.

Anonymous from Loveland - Posted: 7/27/2013

The cabin was a little worn - but, very clean and livable! furniture and TV had been updated and was nice. Beds very comfortable. Everyone was very accomodating and pleasurable to deal with! we sould stay here again for sure!!

Anonymous from Shelbyville - Posted: 7/9/2013

We have an annual girls weekend in #80 and we love it.

Anonymous from Kirtland - Posted: 5/7/2013

Very Helpful!

Anonymous from Brillion - Posted: 4/25/2013