Put-in-Bay Poolview Condo #3

Great place to stay my second year and everything was ��
Hope to be back next year for another great time....

Anonymous from Green Bay - Posted: 5/4/2026

Yay!! So happy to see that memories were made and will never be forgotten! Can't wait to see you again for another great trip!!

Island Club staff

We had a really good visit and location of the area was nice, we had door handles that was not on the closet doors lights, flickering in the kitchen and in the bathroom I never did really talk to the staff and the two days we were there.

Anonymous from Shelbyville - Posted: 9/29/2025

Thank you for your feedback! We’re glad you had a good visit and enjoyed the location. We appreciate you noting the closet doors and light fixtures—we’ll have our team take a closer look at those items. We also want to remind all guests that if you ever need anything during your stay, please don’t hesitate to call us—we’re always happy to help. We hope to welcome you back again soon!

Island Club staff

Excellent condo with all necessities.

Anonymous from Elizabeth - Posted: 9/20/2025

Thank you for your kind words! We’re glad the condo had everything you needed, and we’d love to host you again.

Island Club staff

The pool view condos are breath of fresh air starting our vacation, very clean, all bells & whistles included that are required for a group of 8 to stay, fully equipped kitchen, grill outside, and a pool to enjoy. Everything as promised was made available, they even accommodated check-in when we arrived early.

Anonymous from Fishers - Posted: 7/13/2025

Thank you for the fantastic review! We’re so happy to hear that the Pool View Condos provided a refreshing start to your vacation. It’s great to know the space met all your group’s needs and that you enjoyed the clean accommodations, fully equipped kitchen, outdoor grill, and pool. We’re especially glad we could accommodate your early check-in. We hope to welcome you back for another great stay soon!

Island Club staff

Very clean place, very spacious. Having a golf cart definitely meet getting into town easier because it is a doable walk but still about a 15 minute into town.

Anonymous from Somerville - Posted: 7/7/2025

Thank you for the great review! We're glad you enjoyed the clean, spacious place and found the golf cart helpful for getting into town. It definitely makes exploring the island easier! We hope to welcome you back soon!

Island Club staff

Had lovely amenities, beautiful home, comfortable living space. Felt safe and had a lovely time!

Anonymous from Lyndhurst - Posted: 10/1/2024

Thank you for your kind words! We're thrilled to hear you enjoyed the amenities, beautiful home, and comfortable living space. We're glad you felt safe and had a lovely time. We look forward to hosting you again soon!

Island Club staff

The stay was great. Clean condo, Nice relaxing pool area. Will be staying again in the future. Very close to everything.

Anonymous from N/A - Posted: 9/12/2024

Thank you for your review! We're glad to hear you had a great stay and enjoyed the clean condo and relaxing pool area. We look forward to welcoming you back in the future!

Island Club staff

Everything was great, perfect location, no issues.

Anonymous from Willoughby - Posted: 8/24/2024

Thank you for the wonderful feedback! We're delighted to hear that everything was great and that you enjoyed the perfect location with no issues. We hope to welcome you back for another fantastic stay soon!

Island Club staff

The location of the rental was great. Overall I wish the place came with more amenities. You basically have to bring everything you need and little is provided. But it was clean and good enough for a weekend stay.

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 7/8/2024

Thank you for your feedback! We're glad to hear that you enjoyed the great location of the rental and found it clean. We appreciate your suggestion regarding amenities and will take it into consideration to improve future stays. We're happy that it was sufficient for your weekend stay and hope to welcome you back again soon!

Island Club staff

Honestly Dotty is on top of everything. We had no gas for grilling and called Dotty and she had it taken care of ASAP No paper towels, toilet paper, garbage bags and Ice machine was not working. I made one call to Dotty and she took care of it

Anonymous from Coal City - Posted: 5/2/2023

Hi Tim, Dottie is the best and always on her A game! Glad everything was great for you besides the little bumps that Dottie fixed!

Island Club staff

Clean, well kept. Near airport. As described on line. Perfect for us as base for Put-in-Bay Sports Car Races at the airport. A little far to downtown, but that's not we came for. At little large for a couple but good for a family

Anonymous from Stow - Posted: 10/11/2022

Hi William, we appreciate the great feedback from you and we are happy to here that it was a perfect stay for you and your group.

Island Club staff

Awesome trip

Anonymous from Perrysburg - Posted: 9/25/2022

We are so happy you had an awesome trip Allen! Thanks for staying with us!

Island Club staff

Pleasantly surprised at how clean & well maintained property was. Staff was very helpful & accommodating.

Anonymous from Newark - Posted: 7/17/2022

Shelia. Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

The place was in a perfect location for our family. We loved the pool and enjoyed our three night stay

Anonymous from Fostoria - Posted: 7/16/2022

Amanda, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

By far the best property that we have rented on the island. Will definitely come back.

Anonymous from Rocky River - Posted: 6/8/2022

Kenneth, Thanks for visiting our little island of Put-in-Bay on your recent getaway. You were definitely a 5-star guest and we are glad that we provided a 5-star experience! We hope to host another vacation for your group in the future.

Island Club staff

So I love Scott there he was a humongous help! My conformation magically disappeared and he was so helpful to give us numbers for us to call to get everything taken care of. Need more people in the world like him!

Anonymous from Zanesville - Posted: 10/8/2021

Kayla, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

Two families, two years in a row and both times we all have had a blast.

Anonymous from Morrow - Posted: 8/16/2021

Kathy, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

Great place! Great location!

Anonymous from Plain City - Posted: 8/3/2021

Rissa. Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

No complaints my entire group of 16 had a great time every single day!

Anonymous from West Seneca - Posted: 7/22/2021

Amber, So glad you had a great time during your stay. Thanks you so much for staying in at the Island Club Rentals and enjoying our beautiful little island! We look forward to hosting another trip for your group in the future.

Island Club staff

Wow, this was an amazing experience! The condo was so clean and accommodating. The rooms were beautiful and the staff that was onsite was super helpful with hooking us up with a golf cart and giving recommendations for food locations, etc. I did not feel crowded or inconvenienced like I do at a hotel. This was truly a comfortable, nice experience. Will be back!

Anonymous from Madison - Posted: 10/19/2020

Overall this was a very good experience. The condo is up to date, clean, and in a nice location. We used the pool and the grill outside. Both were great. The $3 shuttle to anywhere on the island is quick and convenient from this location. The only complaint we had was that some of the kitchen utensils were dirty and/or broken.

Anonymous from Northfield - Posted: 7/30/2019

Everything was well organized and hassle free. The place was really nice, spacious, and very clean. It was located in a good spot as far as Put in Bay was concerned. Pool was very nice as well.

Anonymous from Twinsburg - Posted: 7/25/2019

We absolutely loved staying at the Put-in-Bay condos!

Anonymous from Manteno - Posted: 6/30/2019

We stayed here for a weekend and had everything that we needed for our stay there and also had plenty of room for all of us very close to the downtown area of the island

Anonymous from Holland - Posted: 6/4/2019

Clean but in need of TLC

Anonymous from Lagrange - Posted: 10/13/2018

The 2 BR condo was a nice place to stay. We enjoyed our stay. Good location and nice to be able to rent golf cart on site.

Anonymous from Pittsburgh - Posted: 8/26/2018

We had a great time. This location was perfect! Not too far from town and it was so much fun to sit outside our condo at night and chat with the neighbors as well. I would recommened this to anyone who just wants to get away for the weekend or if you are having any kind of party (bachelorette trip, anniversary, or just getting out of town). I wouldn't necessarily recommend bringing kids during the weekend because this is more of a party island.

Anonymous from Elkhart - Posted: 8/15/2018

Fantastic Staff, great location, always a good experience!

Anonymous from St.Michael - Posted: 4/16/2018

The condo was very clean and modern.
The condo was very clean, modern and spacious. The pool was nice but at this time of year too cold to actually swim. Our golf cart was there waiting for us and staff was nice and helpful. You need to bring sheets and towels including for the kitchen. It is not walking distance to town so a golf cart is recommended. We had a very nice stay.

Anonymous from Island Lake - Posted: 9/17/2017

Condos were nice, but worn for being new. We would not recommend staying on the bottom floor. The guests staying above us moved furnishings across the floor most of the night, very frustrating. The pool is beautiful and the chairs are very nice by the pool. The surroundings are nice, but the lake side is for viewing only.

Anonymous from Albion - Posted: 8/17/2017

Nice amentities and very spacious. Grilling outside was a big plus!

Anonymous from Longmont - Posted: 8/15/2017

We enjoyed our condo. It was clean and had plenty of room for our girls' trip. The pool was spacious for our needs, had plenty of deck chairs and lounges, and we enjoyed swimming in clean water. Doty attended to our call when we needed new batteries for the smoke detector and also took care of us when we requested a golf cart. There were plenty of activities to keep us busy on the island. The only suggestion I would make would be to design a path to the lake and upgrade the dock/pier. But that could still be in the plan since it looked as if grass was planted and things were still under construction along the side and back at the lake. Overall we had a great stay!

Anonymous from Whiteland - Posted: 7/15/2017

Had a great weekend. Couldnt have picked a nicer place to stay

Anonymous from Marblehead - Posted: 7/13/2017

I have been very happy with the Island Club since first using them in 2012. This year we had a problem with the air conditioner the first night, and early morning email resulted in a service technician being there at 8 am when we were leaving for the day's activities, problem was solved when we returned for lunch. Nice people and a nice place to stay.

Anonymous from Batavia - Posted: 9/14/2016

Great relaxing weekend with some friends. Ac did not work. Though we hung out at the pool.

Anonymous from Coraopolis - Posted: 8/30/2016

Condo was nice but not the cleanest. The microwave door was broken and duct taped on. The closet door in one of the bedrooms was off. The handles on a couple of the cupboards were broken. The floors were not freshly mopped. The seat in the master shower had a large crack in it and dirty. Many of the pots and pans were greasy and dirty and we had to wash them before we used them. In the list of items to bring you should list: hand soap, dish soap and dishwasher detergent, and extra toilet paper, along with the sheets and towels. We had eight people and were given 2 rolls of toilet paper for the entire weekend. Tony was very helpful and accommodating. For the cost of this condo, I guess we just expected more.

Anonymous from Jackson Center - Posted: 8/2/2016

Condo #3 -Nice unit but needed some attention to be worth what we paid per night. No Pool, under construction, lots of construction noise and staff. I didn't see that mentioned on website when I made reservations. We were given a free golf cart due to the construction which was very nice. Main light was out in Kitchen, reported first day but never was fixed. Microwave handle was held together with duck tape. Tile floors needed a good professional cleaning. We had to mop first thing. I would recommend a fence between the condo and the neighbors property and hair dryers in the bathroom. Needs a little attention.

Anonymous from Jamestown - Posted: 7/15/2016

Condo was pretty beat up. Lots of missing lightbulbs inside and outside - which was very dangerous considering the construction. We had to ask 4 times for propane for the grill. Outside was very dangerous. I would not return until construction was complete. Parking lot was full of debris and not lit. We had a hard time even finding how to get to the condo. No signs at all. We could see it, we just couldn't believe we had to park in the middle of construction vehicles. The construction workers were very nice people and more helpful than the management company.

Anonymous from North Olmsted - Posted: 6/20/2016

The property site was currently under major renovation, so the pool was completely gone at the time of our visit. Location is 5 minutes from the heart of town, bar and restaurants. I would recommend bringing car over on ferry, parking at condo, then rent a golf cart for easy access around town. Our condo did sleep 10 people, however, its a 2 bedroom with 2 beds in each room, plus a pull out couch. Great for groups, not the best set up for more than 3 couples. Bachelor or bachelorette pary easy 10 people.

Anonymous from Dayton - Posted: 9/29/2015

The condo was fairly clean, and close to what was described. The condo needs signs from the road so you can find it, we drove around and happened to see it.the location was OK, the only problem we had was everyday the construction crew came around 7:3 0 and worked all day. It was loud and very dusty

Anonymous from poplar grove - Posted: 9/19/2015

It would be nice to have a few more cleaning options such as paper towels and cleaner. We had a spill and had to ration the use of paper towels because we used them to clean up the spill. Therefore when it came time to clean before we left, we had no paper towels to assist in the process.

Anonymous from Canton - Posted: 9/15/2015

The condo was clean, quiet, and comfortable. Upon arrival, we had no paper towels, dishwasher soap, dish detergent. I called the office, and within 10 minutes, the supplies were delivered.

The only thing I can think of to make the stay better would be permanently installed park-type benches beside the water. Our condo had no lawn chairs. When we asked our "neighbors" to borrow theirs, they refused. I missed relaxing outside by the lake.

I will stay here again in the future.

Anonymous from Wheelersburg - Posted: 8/24/2015

My family had 6 of the 8 Condos from 7/26-7/30.
Liked the location, quiet and away from downtown, on the water with pier, overall decent pool basically to ourselves and nice outdoor patio area and lawn space for family games.
Was very upset that a group of local workers came down to the beach/pier one evening for a 'work party and campfire'. We were told they had permission and this was their 4th year at this location. Our family/group was very uncomfortable with this and I expressed our displeasure. We actually cooked s'mores on our grills as we were told campfires were not allowed and yet this group of strangers utilized the property/pier that we were paying for, and had a fire. There were no problems that occurred from the group and the 2 guys that I spoke with were very nice, but still this should not have been allowed.

Anonymous from Eden - Posted: 8/3/2015

This place was great! About 1 mile from the Miller Ferry and 2 from the Main strip. It was really clean and the grill & patio was perfect. 24-hour Security too! A bit expensive but worth it!

Anonymous from Perrysburg - Posted: 7/30/2015

Very happy with everything! A sign at the road and again at the drive would have been helpful. Staff was wonderful! Will definitely stay again!!

Anonymous from Findlay - Posted: 6/28/2015

This place was perfect to stay with a group of friends. Having a kitchen was a plus, and there was plenty of space for all of us. We loved the outdoor space and seating. Having a taxi that could come and get you was also very convenient.

Anonymous from Lakewood - Posted: 6/25/2015

Condo was clean, lots of amenities like a full kitchen, grill, and pool. Walking distance to the lake with great fishing. Was not in town so very quiet and great for kids but you need a car or golf cart to get to the center of town (not walking distance) but plenty of parking on the grounds and they do rent golf carts.

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 6/21/2015

As always, A very nice stay and great vacation.

Anonymous from Sioux Falls - Posted: 5/11/2015

Another fantastic experience at the Put-In-Bay condos. The best play on the island for fisherman to stay without a doubt. Clean rooms and good parking. Thanks again Island club crew for a great experience!

Anonymous from St.Michael - Posted: 5/6/2015

Had a great time at the condo. Beautiful area so close to the lake. Had an amazing sunrise one morning! The condo was really cute but the floors were filthy. We had to vacumn up the spiders and flyers in the window ledges and the pool was so full of buds we could not use it or the chairs by the pool. It could have been a great place.

Anonymous from Malvern - Posted: 10/10/2014

The condo was a great location for a week away! We enjoyed the location as it was just a quick drive to town but we were also able to walk to the shoreline to see the water. Would definitely recommend to a friend!

Anonymous from Erie - Posted: 10/4/2014

Property was mostly well maintained. Our unit did have a baseboard tile off the wall in kitchen but it was in closet so I assumed it was to be reinstalled soon. If that is a tornado shelter by Unit 3, it needs help. We had a watch and when one of our party checked it out, it was full of water. Furniture was adequate and we understand that wear and tear is pretty severe at a beach or water resort so we were happy with it tho units are very drab.

I would recommend this site though. Location is wonderful since it is on the lake. Pool looks nice but weather was not good for us. The personnel, including cart guys were wonderful. Jerry and Tracy, in the office, were so helpful, personable, and answered all inquiries really fast. Dottie was great, too. Am impressed with Island Club Rental.

We got around to quite a bit. Highlights were numerous: Visitors Center for Perry Monument, nature Center on Meecham, State Park and glacial grooves, eagle's nest on Terwilliger's Pond, Frosty's (I am a Stone Lab alum!), Mojito Bay(!), Heinemann's, lecture on geology at Town Hall, The Goat! Lots of stuff to do "after season". Would have done more but weather was bad for half our stay; but we did park the carts Wed. afternoon and used the cars.

Anonymous from Dayton - Posted: 9/14/2014

Overall, I would give your condos an excellent review. The location was perfect-near the lake with a pool and far enough away from the night life for a family vacation! The only complaint was the lack of WI FI. With a family of professionsl, we needed to have WI Fi connections. Definitely would return.

Anonymous from Lyndhurst - Posted: 8/17/2014

This is the second time that I have stayed there. I like the location and the Island Club Staff. There were a few issues with maintenance this trip but a phone call was made and the issues were resolved. I will stay ther again.

Anonymous from Richmond Heights - Posted: 8/17/2014

We are a group of women (family & friends) who have been going to Put-in-Bay every year for over 40 years. It has grown from 3 women to 44 women! I believe this year was one of the best times we had!!! We had great customer service. We used the mobile app to ask for more paper towels, garbage bags & toilet paper and they were, as they say, on it! The only "complaint" would be outdoor lighting, there wasn't any. It was really dark when the hard core partiers came back from town. Other than that everyone loved everything about Island Club Rentals!!!

Anonymous from Lexington - Posted: 8/14/2014

It was a lovely location by the water. Beautiful flowers all around the outside.Just some minor maintenance issues, but maintenance promptly came out to take care of it.

Anonymous from Buffalo - Posted: 8/10/2014

Our group had four adults a 2 year old and one year old. Good family location. Building both interior and exterior was very nice. Great modern appliances and furniture. Only drawbacks were noise of people walking upstairs, didn't hear back about cart rental and hard to find (no street or complex signs). Overall would recommend.

Anonymous from Strongsville - Posted: 8/7/2014

Condo was very clean and comfortable. Pool looked very nice, but weather was too chilly to swim. Location was great as long as you had a golf cart. Would have been great getaway without 2 days of rain!

Anonymous from Fort Wright - Posted: 7/17/2014

I rented this for a bachelorette party and loved it! This was way nicer than any other places I looked at on the island. The staff were very friendly and accomadating!

Anonymous from lakewood - Posted: 7/15/2014

We had a great time.

Anonymous from McMurray - Posted: 7/13/2014

Spent a few nights with another couple at this super clean, well-furnished, and quiet condo. Close enough to downtown (just a short bike ride away), but far enough away to have some down time.

Anonymous from Westerville - Posted: 7/3/2014

The rental was in a great location and was very quiet. There were some minor concerns as we arrived the door to the washer and dryer were off the hinges and I replaced, the headboards to the beds were dusty and the grill dirty and hard to start. The pool on thursday had not been cleaned until about 3 pm. The staff were great we had a golf cart delivered to us and it was super. The staff we met and or spoke to were great. Hope we can stay there again next summer.

Anonymous from Norwalk - Posted: 6/30/2014

the condo was very nice. however we were very disappointed with the lakefront. garbage and weeds surrounded it. you have prime lakefront property. I dont understand why it cant be more appealing and user friendly. The pier is alson in need of repair

Anonymous from Sylvania - Posted: 6/27/2014

This place is great, nice, clean and good size condo. When you check in and missing any items such as extra bedding etc, they provide them promptly.

Anonymous from Honolulu - Posted: 6/25/2014

I loved the condo itself. Having a full kitchen and washer/ dryer was famtastic. I felt the condo was very clean, and I love the outdoor cooking area. I did not like the water area there was old drywall ,old mattress and a lot of garbage along the edge of the water. I like the pool I just wish the grass surrounding the pool was cut down more. All in all we enjoyed our stay

Anonymous from Independence - Posted: 6/17/2014

My group and I were extremely impressed with this condo. It was modern and clean, and allowed us all to have a perfect vacation.

Anonymous from Poland - Posted: 5/27/2014

The condo was all one needs for a place to rest and get out of the rain. I was there late in April so not everything was up and running for the season which is the way it is, ie. satelite tv. The biggest concern for a fisherman is that there is no on site fish cleaning allowed. This requires you to travel a 1/2 mile to an outdoor fish cleaning table. No lights or roof so leave your rain gear on and bring a couple 5 gallon buckets and a head light if you need to clean fish after the sun goes down.

Anonymous from Blaine - Posted: 5/11/2014

I will definitely recomend it to my friends

Anonymous from Willoughby Hills - Posted: 10/22/2013

Went with 3 other couples, very comfortable for us all. The staff responded promptly to all our needs when we got there.

Anonymous from Chicago - Posted: 10/16/2013

the staff was very nice and helpful! the condo was very clean. one request would be to get more comfortable beds. we liked having the view of the lake.

Anonymous from Clinton - Posted: 10/10/2013

Some cleanliness issues upon arrival. Stained bed cover and trash on floor and dirty kitchen utensils. Staff was attentive and professional and replaced bed cover quickly, we handled the rest. Overall a good stay.

Anonymous from Creston - Posted: 9/30/2013

Nice

Anonymous from St. Marys - Posted: 9/26/2013

Look exactly like the photo's.

Anonymous from Toledo - Posted: 9/20/2013

It was a relaxing and pleasure stay at this Condo. Even through the cost was high for a two day stay but the location, convenience and stay was great and made my weekend a memorable one. It was next to the Lake so anytime you can go and sit around and relax

Anonymous from MORRISVILLE - Posted: 9/17/2013

Condo was great once we found it! No street signs to find address, its a good job my hubby has a great sense of direction.
Lovely place, we will return.
Staff very nice and helpful.

Anonymous from Highland - Posted: 9/14/2013

Overall, a nice place to stay and great location. A few minor things that looked cheap/not well done: 1. No screens on the windows so you couldn't really open them and if you did, the bugs came in. 2. Looks like they put in new sprinkler heads for fire safety but left the open hole with wires on the ceiling where there used to be smoke detector. Could use a light by the grill for late night grilling. Overall, we really enjoyed ourselves.

Anonymous from Rocky River - Posted: 9/3/2013

The dock area could use ALOT of improvement. Also, it would have been better if the pool were heated. For these reasons we dont think we would plan a second stay.

Anonymous from Hermitage - Posted: 9/1/2013

I must say the folks at the Island club rentals go out of there way to make sure that you enjoy your stay! My friends and family have always booked with Island club rentals because you can expect the best and never be let down. From granite counter tops to spacious clean room's with island atmosphere and a private pool. It's like home away from home but on vacation. I would always recommend The Island Club when planning your next PIB vacation.

Anonymous from Cleveland - Posted: 8/7/2013

The TV in our unit was damaged and had lines going through the screen. The amount of channels was limited. No WiFi is an issue. The dishes in our unit were dirty and had to be rewashed upon arrival along with one of the bed spreads which had white stains on it. For the amount of money per night bed linens and towels, etc... should be provided. Spacially the unit was ok, but definitely was not worth the money.

Anonymous from Pickerington - Posted: 8/4/2013

Awesome place to stay!

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 7/16/2013

We enjoyed our stay and would recommend this lodging location to others. We plan to return.
VERY NICE CONDO - CLEAN and well equipped.The management was eager to please and accommodate. Thank you

Anonymous from Cincinnati - Posted: 6/25/2013

The island was great the condo was very clean upon arrival. Would plan to stay there again!!

Anonymous from Heyworth - Posted: 6/16/2013

We had a fantastic time. What a great change in the property! Updated and very nice! Fishing was great! Will return!

Anonymous from Troy - Posted: 5/23/2013

Nice place to stay, right on the lake, great view. Clean rooms.

Anonymous from Pipestone - Posted: 5/8/2013