Put-in-Bay Waterfront Condo #201

Great location! Communication was great - they answered all questions, always willing to help and the few days before check-in they sent several text messages preparing you for your stay and even the details for the ferry and getting to the condos. The pool was nice and our condo was waterfront for great views and relaxing. Easy cart rental on the property for our entire stay! Will stay here again!

Anonymous from Spring Lake - Posted: 8/12/2026

Thank you so much for the wonderful review! We’re thrilled you enjoyed the waterfront views, pool, convenient on-site golf cart rentals, and especially the communication from our team. We want our guests to feel prepared before they even arrive, so it’s great to hear that the check-in and ferry information was helpful. We truly appreciate you choosing to stay with us and look forward to welcoming you back to Put-in-Bay again! ️

Island Club staff

Pleasant, clean and quiet

Anonymous from Port Clinton - Posted: 6/12/2026

Thank you for your review! We're so glad to hear you found the property pleasant, clean, and quiet. Our team works hard to provide a comfortable and relaxing experience for every guest, and we're happy to know you enjoyed your stay. Thank you for choosing to stay with us. We appreciate your kind words and look forward to welcoming you back to Put-in-Bay again soon!

Island Club staff

Our group of 10 LOVED our stay! The condo and our view of the lake were beautiful! Everything was very clean and in great condition. The kitchen had everything we needed to cook a couple times and we used the grills in front of the condo. It was nice to have the necessities provided. We ran low on paper towels but more were promptly delivered to our room. We enjoyed the pool several times. It was clean with plenty of chairs for our group. The location was perfect because it was quiet but just down the road from the general store (which had a good selection was very reasonable) and just a few minutes to downtown. We were also very close to the family fun center and the golf course. Steps for check out were very clearly explained and very smooth. We will DEFINTELY stay here again!!

Anonymous from Canton - Posted: 7/8/2025

Thank you so much for your wonderful review! We’re thrilled your group of 10 loved your stay and enjoyed the beautiful lake views, clean condo, and well-stocked kitchen. We’re glad you were able to enjoy the grills, the pool, and the convenient location close to everything while still being in a quiet area. Thank you for mentioning our clear check-out process and the prompt delivery of extra paper towels – we’re always happy to help! We would love to welcome you back on your next trip to Put-in-Bay. Thanks again for choosing to stay with us!

Island Club staff

Condo was very nice and roomy

Anonymous from Enon - Posted: 6/10/2025

Thank you for the kind review! We're happy to hear you found the condo nice and roomy—comfort and space are definitely key to a great stay. We hope to welcome you back again soon!

Island Club staff

We had a beautiful weekend. The condo was very nice, clean, comfortable and a great location.

Anonymous from Baltimore - Posted: 9/30/2024

Thank you for your lovely feedback! We're so glad to hear you had a beautiful weekend and enjoyed the clean, comfortable condo in a great location. We hope to host you again soon!

Island Club staff

Everything was great! We had so much fun! The staff is friendly and helpful. We stay there again.

Anonymous from Hudson - Posted: 7/15/2024

Thank you so much for your kind words! We're thrilled to hear you had a great time and enjoyed our friendly and helpful staff. We can't wait to welcome you back for another stay at Island Club Houses. See you again soon!

Island Club staff

My Family and I really Enjoyed my stay in the Condo. It was an Easy Check In and an Easy Check out.The Condo was Very Clean.

I was able to Rent 2 Golf Carts very Easily from the Condo Sight and didn't have to go searching for a Golf Cart Company. When I picked up the Golf Carts I was greeted so well and was given the keys without a delay.

The Pool was Very Wonderful and We didn't have to walk for miles to get there.

I definitely will Setup a Vacation again.

Anonymous from Williamstown - Posted: 6/22/2024

Thank you for taking the time to share your fantastic experience! We're thrilled to hear that you and your family enjoyed your stay in the condo and found the check-in and check-out process easy. It's great to know that the condo's cleanliness met your expectations. We're also pleased to hear that renting golf carts directly from the condo site was convenient and that our team provided prompt and friendly service. It's wonderful that you enjoyed the pool and its easy accessibility. We look forward to welcoming you back for another enjoyable vacation soon!

Island Club staff

Sail Crew

Anonymous from Ortonville - Posted: 9/26/2023

Thanks for the review!

Island Club staff

I rented a waterfront condo for my bachelorette party and it was perfect! It fit all 12 of us comfortably, location was great, the condo was clean, and checking in/out was super easy! Would recommend this to anyone staying on the island!

Anonymous from St. Clair Shores - Posted: 9/7/2023

Thanks for the great feedback and we are happy to hear you had a great time at our location/ rentals! We are also pleased to hear that your bachelorette party went amazing as well! Thanks for lodging with us an we hope to see you again with us soon for another great stay!

Island Club staff

Chill place. Pool was great, Rent golf carts right there. Reasonable prices! ��
Overall a wonderful time always

Anonymous from Chardon - Posted: 8/8/2023

Thanks for the great review and we are happy to hear that you had a wonderful time with us in our rentals! We hope to see you again soon!

Island Club staff

Overall, pretty great! The interior layout was very good for a large family except there was no indoor eating space. Bathrooms were huge, bedrooms nice size and everything very functional. Very clean!!! Not much of a “beach” by the the lake, wished they could have done more with that. The star though is Lake Erie which was gorgeous and just as I remembered it!

Anonymous from South Hero - Posted: 7/29/2023

Thank you for sharing your positive feedback about your recent stay with us! We're thrilled to hear that you had a pretty great experience overall and that the interior layout was well-suited for your large family. Your satisfaction is our priority, and we're delighted that the bathrooms were spacious, bedrooms were comfortable, and everything was functional for your needs. We're also glad to know that you found the property very clean. Our dedicated housekeeping team takes great pride in maintaining a high standard of cleanliness to ensure a pleasant and comfortable stay for all our guests. Regarding the indoor eating space, we appreciate your feedback, and it will be taken into consideration as we continually look for ways to enhance our accommodations. We understand the importance of having suitable dining options, especially for large families. While we apologize for the limited "beach" by the lake, we are glad to hear that you still enjoyed the gorgeous Lake Erie, which served as a beautiful backdrop to your stay. Your appreciation of the natural surroundings is heartening, and we take pride in providing our guests with access to such stunning sights. Thank you for choosing to stay with us and for taking the time to share your thoughts.

Island Club staff

We were blown away by house nice our condo (Unit 201) was when we arrived. The place was clean, well kept with beautiful views. The Island Club made everything easy and it was very easy to work with them. Every time I called, they answered all my questions and made the move-in and move-out process seamless.

Anonymous from Chicago - Posted: 10/5/2021

Samantha, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

We have stayed at Put-In-Bay Condos for the last 5 years. We love the space and that we can invite friends to enjoy the island. We also love that it is close to the winery and not a bad walk into town.

Anonymous from Mount Vernon - Posted: 9/23/2021

Cindy, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

Clean. Plenty of space for the full 12 people. Friendly staff and good location for a group of friends!

Anonymous from Fort Wayne - Posted: 7/21/2021

Alex, So glad you had a great time during your stay. Thanks you so much for staying in at the Island Club Rentals and enjoying our beautiful little island! We look forward to hosting another trip for your group in the future.

Island Club staff

Rental experience was great. The only issue we had was upon arrival. The parking is a real issue. Only one way in/out no turnaround. Only 2 handicapped assigned parking spaces. We are a family with a handicapped member. I would hope parking would be addressed in the future. Maybe designated parking passes provided to guests along with assigned parking space. Guests shouldn't have to walk nearly a football field length when coming & going due to the lack of parking spaces. Another suggestion is to move the golf cart return area. It's too congested. Never had to contact management. House was in great condition. Would definitely recommend and stay again in the future.

Anonymous from DAYTON - Posted: 6/28/2021

Hi Tennile, We appreciate the feedback. There is one parking space for each condo rented. We were so glad to host your trip and love to hear that you had a good time. We look forward to having your group back in the future!

Island Club staff

Our condo was beautiful, clean, and updated. The fully stocked full kitchen allowed us to have all of the comforts of home. What an awesome view...like a little paradise in Ohio. My friends who joined me plan to book the same condo in the future.

Anonymous from Northfield - Posted: 6/1/2021

Tanisha, Glad you enjoyed a little paradise in Ohio! Your group was wonderful and we look forward to hosting another trip for you in the future!

Island Club staff

Perfect getaway and a "short" 4 hour drive. Grounds well kept and pool in excellent condition.

Anonymous from Johnstown - Posted: 10/1/2020

Glad you had such a good time Stephen! Please keep us in mind for future PIB visits, we'd love to host you again!

Island Club staff

He had a great time with family and friends. This was our third trip to Island Club Condos. It is a short walk to the winery and a nice walk into town. We love staying here and enjoying the pool and grills. Plenty of room for our party or 12

Anonymous from Mount Vernon - Posted: 7/19/2020

We had a wonderful week at the Put-in-Bay Condos; we can't wait until we come back next year!

Anonymous from Saint Clair Shores - Posted: 7/12/2020

Spacious, nicely decorated and comfortable. We will stay at the condos again. I liked being in the end unit #201 with a tree on the corner of the deck. I found the Island Rental team helpful and good to work with. My only complaint was that the main slider door windows and deck was dirty and the kitchen floor needed mopped, no just sweeped. I cleaned the windows when I arrived so we could enjoy the view. Overall, the unit is great!

Anonymous from Perrysburg - Posted: 7/3/2020

Hi Laura, We apologize for that. If you ever have am issue during your stay, we would be happy to send housekeeping or maintenance to solve any issues. We are glad you enjoyed your stay! Your group members were excellent guests and we look forward to having you back in the future!

Island Club staff

xxx

Anonymous from Alachua - Posted: 10/3/2019

The staff brought you whatever you need with in 10 minutes. We didn’t have to check in at all. They email the key code before arrival. The condo was beautiful. We loved the balcony and staring out at the water. We ordered our golf carts before arrival. That was nice. They came and did the paperwork and it was ours. The only negative thing was the floors were dirty and lots of cob webs. I don’t think they could keep up with all the tiny spiders. We would definitely go again. Josh was helpful any time we called.

Anonymous from Corsica - Posted: 8/27/2019

The condo was advertised and the location was perfect for our family if 6. We rented a golf cart too and that made getting anywhere on the island simple. The staff was helpful and I appreciated the text communication from the company. Our trip was the beginning of August and we didn’t think about how bad the nighttime bugs would be on the patio. I recommend anyone coming up to bring citronella candles.

Anonymous from GAHANNA - Posted: 8/23/2019

Stayed at the 12 person condo for 2 nights. Immaculate view of the lake in the back. The condo is very spacious and well stocked. Great stay for 4 adults and 5 kids. Condo was the highlight. Put-in-Bay did not really “work for me”

Anonymous from Fort Wayne - Posted: 8/15/2019

This was perfect for our first time at PIB! My sister wanted her Bachelorette weekend here so I found this place and it could not have been more perfect. Everyone was amazing, it was a little noisy but that’s the only fault we could find. I wish I would’ve understood more about the way transportation worked but it was my fault for not paying much attention to the emails and alerts sent out by the company. If you’re able to do that, you’ll have no issue. Such a fun place to stay!

Anonymous from Powhatan Point - Posted: 5/21/2019

This is a very well appointed hospitable condo which we enjoyed for five days. The views of the lake were amazing, and we really enjoyed our stay there. It was Very relaxing in the evening to open up the sliders from the communal area out to the lake and enjoy the breeze while we chatted on the deck and the inside area. This is a great location at Put in Bay and we would really recommend it to anyone.

Anonymous from Alachua - Posted: 9/29/2018

8 couples, needing a place to stay together, this was a great choice for us! Beautiful view of the lake, clean, updated, very comfortable. Definately a great choice!
The downside, we did have to clean the patio furniture before we could sit out there and the bug carcasses on the screens and doors were not recent. Looked like it was not touched for a long time.

Anonymous from Macomb - Posted: 9/8/2018

Perfect location for three generations of our family to stay during the week days. Great location right on the waterfront. The employees of the condo were very quick to respond to our requests.

Anonymous from Wilmington - Posted: 8/11/2018

Great location & lake view! Perfect for bachlorette party for 10-12 people! All the amenities were provided & beds so comfortable!

Had issues with golf cart rentals, there was a double booking with our golf cart & my daughters golf Cart kept going missing.

Anonymous from New Palestine - Posted: 7/5/2018

Hi Cynthia, we are glad that you had a wonderful time and enjoyed the amenities. Since the golf carts look similar, we recommend locking them after each use to avoid the confusion of guests confusing golf carts.

Island Club staff

Our condo was very clean and the furnishings were very nice. Usually kitchens are stocked with the bare minimums, but this kitchen had more than enough. Let's not forget the location. Being on the water was the best. We slept with our doors open and going to sleep and waking up to the waves was so relaxing and peaceful. This was our 1st time at Put-In-Bay and we've decided to make it an annual trip and we'll definitely being staying here during our future trips! This place exceeded our expectations!

Anonymous from Pickerington - Posted: 6/15/2018

Hi Vikki, we are so glad you enjoyed your stay! Being on the water with the calm, relaxing sounds of the waves is one of the best perks of the waterfront condos. We look forward to having you back next year!

Island Club staff

I booked and stayed here with 11 other girl friends to celebrate our friends Bachelorette weekend. The place was beautiful, clean, and all of the staff was so helpful. Tony responded to every question. Everything was perfect! Thank you for a great weekend!!!

Anonymous from Lakeview - Posted: 8/8/2017

As a family we enjoyed our stay very much and the only problem we had was that the elevator was not working upon arrival for our son's wheelchair. We had a condo on the second floor, but because of the management's professional attitude, together we worked it out. If the elevator had been working we would have rated everything a 5 star rating. Our condo was beautiful and there were 13 people who enjoyed their stay at Put-In-Bay.

Anonymous from Alexandria - Posted: 8/5/2017

Very clean and beautiful view from the balcony. The location was great and easy to get a ride into town. Our A/C was not working when we arrived and they sent someone out to fix it very quickly

Anonymous from Toledo - Posted: 7/11/2017

Only concern is there was no way to remove the mayflies from either the upper or lower deck. A broom or something, preferably a water hose, as you know mayflies pile up quite quickly during the hatch season

Parking spots limited in front of condo, my father has had double knee replacement so his mobility is limited, golf carts were constantly parking in the few close full size parking spots

Anonymous from Hendersonville - Posted: 6/30/2017

I brought my team to the Put in Bay Waterfront condos for a work retreat in early May before the summer rush. The condos facing the water are brand new and a great location. The amount of beds were perfect for a large family or group of 7+ people, although all of the beds are full size. The only thing we struggled with was the fact that the kitchen was very poorly stocked of equipment for making meals. The view and the double decks definitely are well worth it. If you travel back and forth to the mainland with a group, prepare to spend a lot of money on ferry rides. 6 people and 1 car round trip is over $118.

Anonymous from Loveland - Posted: 6/4/2017

This condo was perfect for our group of 11. Very spacious and clean. The management group was very helpful and accomodating. The only issue we had was that the elevator was not operational at the time. This was really only an issue though when unloading and loading our vehicles. The waterfront view was gorgeous. We will be back!

Anonymous from White Lake - Posted: 10/26/2016

This condo was great for our family vacation. We were with 10 people and the size of the condo was perfect. Very spacious, the kitchen, entertainment room and deck were all somewhat connected so we were able to visit well with everyone regardless of where you were in the condo. We would highly recommend this condo, it has a beautiful lakefront view and the condo was very clean. Tony the manager was wonderful, he informed us of things to do and also recommended an awesome taxi driver.

Anonymous from Maria Stein - Posted: 10/12/2016

The brand new property had lots of room. Pool was great. Needed reading lamps. The mayflies were in season so a screened in deck would have been great. the 2 decks over looking the lake are GREAT but when the bugs are there what good are they. I do not think bug spray is the answer. Can hardly wait to see the condo when all the landscaping is done. I know it will be beautiful..

Anonymous from N Huntingdon - Posted: 9/11/2016

Couldn't have been more perfect!!

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 9/7/2016

Out Condo was in a perfect location, away from the hub bub of activity, but so close to it when we were ready to shop, eat, and take in the sites.

Anonymous from Cincinnati - Posted: 9/3/2016

We had a bachelor party and rented out one of the new Put in Bay waterfront condos for the weekend. We had a great time and fit 12 people comfortably! It is not to far of a drive from the downtown area. I do wish the bar area was completed for our stay but we still had a great time. We would come back for sure!

Anonymous from parma - Posted: 8/30/2016

The condo was Beautiful, except for a brand new condo, the towels and wash cloths were badly stained. Communication was really our only complaint. The pool was not finished, therefore, not usable, and construction was still going on. If only they had communicated to us, we would have been fine, but the street was not marked to get to the location and there was construction going on so we were not even sure that we were at the right place. I did call several times before our arrival with questions and no one ever had answers. Despite the lack of communication, the condo was Beautiful and Spacious and I would stay there again. Also Tony was very helpful during our stay. This place will be Great when construction is complete.

Anonymous from Independence - Posted: 8/11/2016