Put-in-Bay Waterfront Condo #202

Overall a very good experience. The kitchen could use a few more pieces of cookware and a cutting board. The oven was pretty outdated for the stovetop. The bugs from being near the water is hard to control but the patio doors and screens could use a wipe down. Otherwise very clean with minimalist decor in bedrooms. Great location and amazing views! Would recommend.

Anonymous from Canonsburg - Posted: 8/14/2026

Thank you for taking the time to leave such thoughtful feedback! We’re glad you had a great overall experience and enjoyed the location, cleanliness, and especially the amazing waterfront views. We also appreciate your suggestions regarding additional cookware, a cutting board, the oven, and cleaning around the patio doors and screens. We’ll be sure to pass these items along to our team and the property owner. Thank you for the recommendation, and we hope to welcome you back to Put-in-Bay again! ️

Island Club staff

First time to the island. Stayed the 2nd week October. We weren't aware that the island closes everything up for the season, seemed like a ghost town. Still had a nice, quiet time.

Loved the view from both balconies and hearing the the water hit the shore. Plenty of space for two couples. Would be a great place for a girls trip too. Four bedrooms and 3 bathrooms.

I only cooked one meal but had all the essentials we needed in the kitchen. Overall place was nice and clean. Only recommendations would be to add a TV in every bedroom, only the master had one.

Anonymous from Indianapolis - Posted: 10/16/2024

Thank you for sharing your experience! We're glad you enjoyed the peaceful, quiet time on the island and loved the views from both balconies. It’s great to hear that the condo had plenty of space for your group and was well-equipped for your needs. We appreciate your suggestion about adding TVs to the other bedrooms and will take it into consideration. We hope to welcome you back for another relaxing stay—perhaps during the busier season next time!

Island Club staff

The room was spotless and the set up was ideal for 3 families. The kitchen was fully stocked with all the necessary items. Staying at the condo saves us money since we can cook some meals there and not depend on restaurants.

Anonymous from Chandler - Posted: 8/1/2024

Thank you for your wonderful feedback! We're delighted to hear that the room was spotless and the setup was ideal for your three families. It's great to know that the fully stocked kitchen helped you save money by allowing you to cook some meals. We hope to welcome you back for another enjoyable and cost-effective stay soon!

Island Club staff

Family of eight stayed for 4 days/3 nights in a 4 bedroom condo. The unit was clean and kitchen is well equipped. It was wonderful having 3 full bathrooms. The deck patio has a nice 8 person table but there were so many spiders, we didn’t spend much time out there. Also, this property is “waterfront” as opposed to “beach” front. There are sewage treatment release pipes that empty out to the lake right in front of the condo. I’m sure the water is clean but aesthetically, it was unpleasant. Staff was wonderful and very attentive to requests. Nice location and downtown was a short golf cart drive away. Overall, we enjoyed our stay and will be back

Anonymous from Queen Creek - Posted: 9/25/2023

Dear Guest, Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback about your recent stay at our property. We're pleased to hear that your family had an enjoyable experience overall. We appreciate your positive comments about the cleanliness of the unit, the well-equipped kitchen, and the convenience of having three full bathrooms. Your mention of the deck patio and the issue with spiders is duly noted. We will take steps to address this concern to ensure a more comfortable outdoor experience for our guests. Regarding the waterfront location, we apologize for any inconvenience caused by the sewage treatment release pipes. We understand your aesthetic concerns, and we will work to find solutions to improve the visual aspect for our guests. We're glad to know that you found our staff wonderful and attentive, and that you appreciated the property's nice location and proximity to downtown. We look forward to welcoming you back in the future. If you have any further comments or suggestions, please feel free to reach out to us. Your feedback is important, and we are here to assist in any way we can. Thank you for choosing our property, and we hope to have the opportunity to host you and your family again soon.

Island Club staff

Our Stay in Put in Bay Condos was excellent! Condo was clean with plenty of room! Check in and check out easy and convenient! Staff goes above and beyond to help with any questions or mishaps! Even our golf carts rental was quick and easy! Great job! And would highly recommend!

Anonymous from Buffalo - Posted: 8/20/2023

We are so happy to hear that your stay was excellent and everything was perfectly clean for you and your group. We appreciate the comment on our staff beyond beyond helpful with everything you needed during your stay. We thank you again for staying with us in our rentals and hope to see you again soon!

Island Club staff

We had such an awesome time! This is my 2nd or 3rd time renting a condo at Put in Bay Condos, and I have not had one bad experience at any time! Love the condos I have stayed in thus far! Very clean and love the decor and rooms. Sitting out on the balcony and overlooking the water makes you feel like you're not even in Ohio. It makes me feel like I'm in Florida! Oh! And we loved swimming in the pool! We will definitely be back!

Anonymous from Toledo - Posted: 8/10/2023

Thank you so much for the wonderful review and we appreciate the kind words. We are so happy that the condo is always clean and perfect for you and group when coming. Thank you once again and we hope to see you back with us again next year.

Island Club staff

We stay here every year. Plenty of room with beautiful lake views and only a five minute golf cart ride to downtown. Only drawback is paper thin walls so plan on getting woke up by loud neighbors on occasion. I like that you can rent golf carts for entire stay rather than daily.

Anonymous from Northfield - Posted: 7/28/2023

We are so happy to see returning guests coming back for a little vacation! Glad to hear everything was great besides the walls not blocking out your neighbors being loud. Thankfully that didn't completely ruin your stay with us and we hope to see you returning again for your next stay! t

Island Club staff

Very nice rooms. The unit was clean and the staff was awesome. Everything was very simple.

Anonymous from Crawfordsville - Posted: 7/3/2023

Thanks for the great review, Karey! Glad our staff was awesome and everything was clean and comfortable for you! Hope to see you soon!

Island Club staff

We had a great time visiting Put in Bay April 2023. It was early in the season, so not everything was open, but we still had fun.

Would recommend that the condo add a dresser and mirror to the 2 upstairs bedrooms. There was no where to set anything but on the floor.

Anonymous from Industry - Posted: 5/4/2023

Thanks so much for the great feedback and all the recommendations. It is all greatly appreciated and we hope to see you again next stay with us!

Island Club staff

We had a great stay. Condo was beautiful and very clean. Plenty of space and all amenities. We will book this unit again next year!

Anonymous from Broadview Hts. - Posted: 8/11/2022

Hi Shelley, we are happy to hear that you had such a great stay with us! We cannot wait to host you again next year!

Island Club staff

The condo was so beautiful and very clean! We celebrated a bachelorette party with a group of 12 here and loved it! Plenty of space for all of us. Staff were so helpful, even helped us carry a large cooler up the stairs. The balconies looking over the lake were the perfect place for morning coffee! We did have an issue with the garbage disposal not working and backing up into the sink but after calling, the maintenance man was up in 20 minutes and had it fixed for us in no time. Would highly recommend staying in condo 202!

Anonymous from Nashville - Posted: 8/10/2022

Hi Alisa, we are so happy you had fun celebrating the bachelorette party with us in our condos. We are also so happy our staff was quick and responsive for you!

Island Club staff

It’s a great place for a group of people. Beautiful view from the balcony.

Anonymous from New Vienna - Posted: 7/29/2022

Jackie, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

The view of the lake from the bedroom with balcony was wonderful! Great location, close to everything but enough distance to be relaxing!

Anonymous from Waynesville - Posted: 6/12/2022

Bridgette, Thanks for visiting our little island of Put-in-Bay on your recent getaway. You were definitely a 5-star guest and we are glad that we provided a 5-star experience! We hope to host another vacation for your group in the future.

Island Club staff

The rental was exactly what we imagined it would be! Spacious, beautiful views, close to the Miller ferry, and a shirt ride to downtown put in bay. The condo was clean, and well stocked with plates, cups, silverware, and ice. The pool had plenty of seating and the water was a perfect temperature.

Anonymous from Mount Vernon - Posted: 9/7/2021

Jayme, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

Spacious, clean and great location. We all enjoyed it and will return!

Anonymous from Oregon - Posted: 8/29/2021

Tracy, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

This condo is great to bring a large group of friends. Very clean and easy check in process. Located a 5 min golf cart ride from all the action and about 3 min to Miller’s Ferry.

Anonymous from Pittsburgh - Posted: 7/7/2021

Anthony, So glad you enjoyed your stay on our quaint little island of Put-in-Bay! We look forward to hosting your group in the future!

Island Club staff

Awesome!!

Anonymous from Hebron - Posted: 6/27/2021

Deborah, We were so glad to host your trip and love to hear that you had a good time. We look forward to having your group back in the future!

Island Club staff

The condo was very clean and spacious with plenty of room for 10 woman. The decks were awesome providing stunning views of Lake Erie.

Anonymous from OREGON - Posted: 5/4/2021

Sue. So glad your group had a great time! We look forward to hosting another trip for your group again in the future!

Island Club staff

Simply put this condo was worth the money! Views from the upper deck was amazing! Very clean and nice location.Will definitely be back !

Anonymous - Posted: 10/6/2020

It was clean indoor and out. We felt very safe! Will definitely come back and stay at that location.

Anonymous from Munroe Falls - Posted: 7/19/2020

The Put-in-Bay Waterfron Condo's were newly remodeled and definitely one of the nicer properties on the Island. The pool was clean and nice. There were little things like a lot of spiders on the deck/patio furniture, all of the towels were in the downstairs bathroom instead of evenly dispersed between the bathrooms, no garbage cans in the bathrooms, so there was some trash that pervious people threw under the sinks, but overall the property was nice and I'd stay again.

Anonymous from Miamisburg - Posted: 9/24/2019

Loved the digs! Loved the amenities!
Loved the ease of check in and out?
Will return!

Anonymous from Norwalk - Posted: 9/17/2019

Thanks for the kind words Chris, hope to see you in 2020!

Island Club staff

We had 8 girls here for a weekend and had plenty of space. Porch seating and furniture suits a big group. Kitchen and seating areas for meals were also well fitted. Given it is a condo style building, privacy is tough when nearby units are occupied and also using the outdoor deck. Taxis were very easy to get around the island. It was worth staying away from downtown for the view and updated building. We had a light bulb out and within 20 minutes it was fixed by security, great service!

Anonymous from BAY CITY - Posted: 9/11/2019

5 of us went to put in bay all for the first time.

The accommodations were nice, clean and all what we expected.

Lots to do for everyone of all ages, good food, live music and fun bars in the evening.

Anonymous from Wallacetown - Posted: 8/20/2019

Very Nice except for the turd factory near the pool wall. Disgusting when the wind shifts to the east.

Anonymous from Lakewood - Posted: 7/31/2019

Very clean condo Nice views. Wish they would invest in some bicycle racks. There were bikes everywhere. We chained our bikes to our truck.

Anonymous from Hudson - Posted: 7/21/2019

Great overall. Could use some lamps for better lighting for reading. Have the balcony completely covered so you can sit outside in the rain without getting wet.

Anonymous from Petersburg - Posted: 7/19/2019

Arrived to a beautiful layout overlooking the lake. Everything was as it was advertised and when we did have one hiccup (flat tire on the golf cart) it was repaired right away.

Anonymous from Canal Fulton - Posted: 6/28/2019

Great location and property for large groups. We rented two adjacent units and it worked out wonderfully for our birthday celebration.

Anonymous from West Bloomfield - Posted: 6/16/2019

Check in was a breeze, the views are awesome, located out from everything but close enough to get a taxi. We will be back for sure as the place is a great stay.

Anonymous from Sandusky - Posted: 9/2/2018

Our group of women have been going to Put-in-Bay every July for the past 30+ years. We’ve been staying with Island Club Rentals for the past 5 years and are booked for next year already! Our group was the first reservation for the water front condos! We love staying here!!! Everyone! And I mean everyone is super nice!

Anonymous from Lexington - Posted: 8/1/2018

We stayed the week of 4th of July, checked in on Sunday the 1st and out Saturday the 6th. The location was easy to find, just right down from the Ferry and Airport. When we arrived, there weren’t any parking spaces in the lot so it seemed that some people broke the parking space limit rule. We parked temporarily in an accessible spot to unload and then eventually were able to move our vehicle. We thought there was an elevator and there is but it is on the other side of the building from where our Condo is located so we ended up carrying everything up the stairs. Not a huge deal but FYI.

The view from the balcony in the master bedroom and the main balcony is just amazing. You can hear the waves crashing and enjoy a cup of coffee in the morning or drinks in the evening right on the lake. This side of the lake doesn’t get the most amazing sunsets but they are still beautiful.

We were told that the kitchen was fully stocked but there were some things missing that would would have liked to have had.

The condo was clean for the most part but we did find someone else’s baby item in a drawer and the kitchen floor was dirty. Otherwise, we found the condo perfect for our family - I have a toddler and although the condo was decorated, I didn’t feel like he was going to hurt himself on nicknacks every 5 seconds.

We were able to park our golf cart right on the property and taxis were easy to get too!

The pool closes at 7pm. I thought that was ridiculous. 7pm? We showed up when it opened in the AM and they were still power washing after it opened which was kind of annoying. If you are going to limit hours - shouldn’t the cleaning be done outside of operating hours? There were often unaccompanied kids in the pool. Not sure what the owners can do about that.

Overall, we would come back. The condo was spacious, in a great location with beautiful view. It was a great place to enjoy PIB with our family.

Anonymous from Lebanon - Posted: 7/10/2018

The management was very nice and so was all the staff. Close to everything

Anonymous from Mansfield - Posted: 6/24/2018

Hi Linda, we are glad that our staff provided excellent service during your stay! Thank you for staying with us!

Island Club staff

We had a family of 11 and it worked well for us. Good location, great views

Anonymous from Marysville - Posted: 10/17/2017

the views were nice and the unit was clean. upstairs balcony doors did not lock and we had small children so i was a little concerned about them trying to open them out of curosity- had to block it with a night stand. i thought the beds were randomly set up with only 1 bathroom to share on the top level with the 3 bedrooms. the pool house bathroom was also a little messy.

Anonymous from Westlake - Posted: 8/5/2017

Awesome time at Put In Bay. This is the place to be.

Anonymous from Watseka - Posted: 7/18/2017

Property location and size was amazing. Pool was cery nice. The condo was not the cleanest. We saw hairballs rolling out from under furniture and our feet were black from walking around with no shoes on. I would recommend this place and stay here again.

Anonymous from Fremont - Posted: 7/1/2017

This condo was beautiful, spacious and had awesome views overlooking the water. I really wasn't sure if when booking the space that I could trust the pictures, since it looked so nice, but they are 100% accurate and the place was actually nicer in person! Beds are new and super comfy - actually everything is brand new. Tony was awesome in taxiing our bunch of girls around for the weekend and was super easy to get a hold of. Overall, we had a great weekend at the Put-in-Bay Condos!

Anonymous from Wakefield - Posted: 5/25/2017

Gorgeous view! Info online not accurate. Did not know it was two-story condo, but no problem. Thought there was one king-size bed, but only queens. Not **** and span, but acceptable. Feet very black from dirty floor. Living room seating for five, condo for twelve, had to use bar stools. All in all, okay, and would recommend. On the management company question, we got a different person each time we called, did not receive promised email one time, but all turned out well.

Anonymous from Bluffton - Posted: 9/21/2016

The condo was very roomy and clean and the beds were comfortable. Eating breakfast on the balcony overlooking the lake was amazing, as was the sunset. The kitchen was great and had everything you needed. The pool was perfect. When I had a question the gentleman on duty answered the phone immediately and responded quickly. I can't wait to go back next year.

Anonymous from Struthers - Posted: 9/12/2016

The condo we stayed in was a perfect spot to hold a group of our size,12. We had enough sleeping space, the back deck looking out onto the water and the living space was all we needed. The pool was an added bonus for us. Location was tough at times because we needed to taxi or rent golf carts just to go eat. The taxi was cheap, which was good, but difficult to organize for a group this size to organize rides for when we were all going in different directions or wanted to eat at different times.

Anonymous from Wexford - Posted: 9/6/2016

Great location, love having a pool, condo was spacious and updated... lots of bugs, but you'll have that by the lake. Since the building is new there are a few kinks to work out (outlets not working), but no doubt those things will be taken care of considering how helpful and on top of it the staff is. Great experience, would come back.

Anonymous from Carnegie - Posted: 8/30/2016

We rented two condos for a mini family getaway to Put-n-Bay. These new condos are very spacious with all of the necessary amenities making traveling feel like a home away from home. We are definitely considering a return to these condos next year. I highly recommend a stay.

Anonymous from Wadsworth - Posted: 8/16/2016