Put-in-Bay Waterfront Condo #205

PIB Condos is a fabulous place to stay. Great lake view, convenient to everywhere, professional staff, and very clean and roomy condos! Will definitely be back!

Anonymous from Broadview Heights - Posted: 5/4/2026

Thank you for the great review! We’re glad you enjoyed the lake views, convenient location, and the space and cleanliness of the condos. Our team works hard to make sure everything runs smoothly, so we appreciate you recognizing that. We truly appreciate you staying with us and look forward to having you back again soon!

Island Club staff

Super convenient golf cart rental and process. Lodgings were great and the view can't be beat. Everything was clean and all necessities were provided.

Anonymous from Cleveland - Posted: 9/9/2025

Thank you for your kind words! We’re glad to hear you enjoyed the convenience of the golf cart rental, the clean and well-stocked accommodations, and of course the unbeatable view. We truly appreciate your feedback and look forward to hosting you again!

Island Club staff

We have come the past three years and our experience has been great each time. They are so helpful and responsive when issues arise! Would highly recommend

Anonymous from Westlake - Posted: 7/5/2025

Thank you for the wonderful review! We’re so glad you’ve chosen to stay with us for the past three years and that each experience has been great. We appreciate your kind words about our helpful and responsive team. Thank you for recommending us, and we look forward to welcoming you back again!

Island Club staff

We had a condo for 10 of us and it was perfect! The location was close to the pool and golf cart parking. We’d stay again!

Anonymous from Eastlake - Posted: 6/5/2024

Thank you for your wonderful review! We're thrilled to hear that the condo was perfect for your group of 10 and that you appreciated the convenience of its location close to the pool and golf cart parking. It's great to know that we can look forward to welcoming you back for another stay. Thank you for choosing us, and see you again soon!

Island Club staff

Nicely equipped with full kitchen and appliances. Very clean and in good repair. Any issues we had were promptly handled in a friendly and professional manner. Definitely having a balcony overlooking the lake was perfect. Definitely will return.

Anonymous from Chillicothe - Posted: 9/14/2023

Thanks for the kind words and great feedback about our beautiful condos! We are glad you had an amazing stay and hope we can provide another one for your next trip with us!

Island Club staff

Everything was great except that you cannot lock the door from the inside and my grandson got out during the night. Thank God some kind stranger knocked on doors until he found where he belonged. This could have ended so terrible. Please put locks on doors high up so children can’t reach them

Anonymous from Cloverdale - Posted: 8/22/2023

We deeply appreciate you sharing your feedback about your recent stay with us. We're truly sorry to hear about the concerning incident involving your grandson. Your safety and comfort are our top priorities, and we take this matter very seriously. We sincerely apologize for any distress this situation may have caused. Your suggestion to add locks on doors higher up to prevent such incidents is greatly appreciated, and we'll certainly consider implementing this for the safety of our guests, especially children. We're relieved that a kind stranger was able to help and that your grandson was safely returned to you. Your experience serves as an important reminder for us to continuously improve our accommodations to provide a secure and worry-free environment. Thank you for bringing this matter to our attention, and we're grateful that the situation didn't result in a worse outcome. We hope you'll consider staying with us again in the future, where we'll strive to make your experience a much more positive one.

Island Club staff

We had a great time in this very nice condo.
Everything we needed was there and the location was so nice! The pool was great but the pool bar was not open as stated. Overall everything was great!

Anonymous from Buffalo - Posted: 8/12/2023

We are glad to hear that you guys had a great time in the condos. We appreciate the feedback and are happy everything was there that you needed! We hope to see you again soon!

Island Club staff

Great lake view, comfortable beds, pleasant surroundings.

Anonymous from Dayton - Posted: 7/31/2023

Thanks for the wonderful feedback and glad the view was great along with the beds in the unit. Hope to see you again soon :)

Island Club staff

Amazing and love the condos! Would do it again!!

Anonymous from Brookpark - Posted: 7/18/2023

Thanks for the great feedback and we hope to see you in our rentals again soon!

Island Club staff

We truly enjoyed the place we stayed, it was very accomodating!

Anonymous from West Lafayette - Posted: 6/25/2023

Thanks for the great feedback and we are happy you enjoyed the place! We hope to see you again soon!

Island Club staff

We arrived on Tuesday bit of a shaky start .There was no parking space open we had been assured we had a spot . After a bit all was good and we went on our way doing what we were interested in . Sitting on the deck each morning having coffee looking out at Lake Erie was priceless ! Any thing we needed refilled was done quickly. Very clean and would stay there again . There was 8 of us and we all enjoyed !

Anonymous from Lebanon - Posted: 6/19/2023

Thanks for the feedback feedback Debbie, and apologies for the no parking spot at first. Some people are stubborn and bring more than one car, which is why we have enforced parking passes for the condos now. So, if anyone brings more than one car, they will be towed. We are glad that this didn't ruin the trip and that the views from the deck were priceless to see! Glad everything was handled right away and we hope to see you again for your next stay at the Bay!

Island Club staff

This place was absolutely amazing! Our golf carts were there ready and waiting for us! Check in was so simple. As well as check out. We will most definitely be staying on our next trip. Too chilly for us to use the pool, but was clean and well kept.

Anonymous from Newport - Posted: 5/8/2023

Hi Brooke, thanks so much for the amazing feedback! We are so happy everything was amazing and hopefully next trip it will be nice and warm!

Island Club staff

Everything was perfect for my bachelorette, very clean, accommodating and it fit all 12 of us very comfortably.

Anonymous from Jeannette - Posted: 9/25/2022

Thanks so much for your feedback Sabrina! We hope to host you again next season!

Island Club staff

The condo was nice & spacious w/a great view . There were a few cosmetic issues that could have been fixed . The washer was awful sounding but got the job done .

Anonymous from Indianapolis - Posted: 8/9/2022

Hi Renisha, thanks for your feedback and we will let the owner of the condo owner know of your suggestions. We hope to see you again next year!

Island Club staff

Excellent stay as always.

Anonymous from Middletown - Posted: 7/6/2022

Hi John, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

What a beautiful condo. Everything was awesome. Stayed 1 night and not enough.

Anonymous from Cleveland - Posted: 6/26/2022

Jackie, Thanks for visiting our little island of Put-in-Bay on your recent getaway. You were definitely a 5-star guest and we are glad that we provided a 5-star experience! We hope to host another vacation for your group in the future.

Island Club staff

I was very pleased to accommodate my family here. Everything was clean and it is a beautiful place.

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 9/27/2021

Carlos, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

Family/Friend trip, Amazing!

Anonymous from Rochester Hills - Posted: 7/26/2021

Michele, So glad you had a great time during your stay. Thanks you so much for staying in at the Island Club Rentals and enjoying our beautiful little island! We look forward to hosting another trip for your group in the future.

Island Club staff

Nice condo, lovey relaxing view, all the must needs of home but not the responsibilities.

I would offer the suggestion to separate the smokers from the non-smokers, As the smokers make the beautiful decks un-usable for the non- smokers.

Anonymous from North Ridgeville - Posted: 6/19/2021

Jennifer, We appreciate the feedback. Our desks are non-smoking. We email the rules to all guests prior to the stay. We certainly wish you would have called us during your stay so we could have addressed the group not following the rules. In the future, please contact our office so we can send a staff member over immediately to help. We were so glad to host your trip and love to hear that you had a good time. We look forward to having your group back in the future!

Island Club staff

Condo met and exceeded our expectations! Great place to stay! A must stay for families. Great views of lake!

Anonymous from Ottawa - Posted: 11/4/2020

It is a very nice and updated condo.plenty of space. It would be nice to have a dining table inside as there are a lot of bugs at night and cannot eat on the balcony.

Anonymous from Perrysburg - Posted: 7/18/2020

The best thing about the condo was the views of the sunrise! The condo was clean (except coffee grinds were left in the coffee pot) and comfortable. The only ‘flaw’ is the kitchen is not well stocked if you are planning on doing any real cooking/baking (ex no measuring cups, measuring spoons, rubber spatula). Onsite golf cart rental is convenient but the golf cart was not there when we arrived, nor was it cleaned, was VERY slow. Overall the condo was great! I would definitely recommend it/stay there again!

Anonymous from Waldorf - Posted: 9/25/2019

nice

Anonymous from Hamilton - Posted: 9/25/2019

Very relaxing with a great view. The Ladies taking care of the golf carts were super friendly, and the maintenance man thanked me for letting him know about a lose faucet in the kitchen.

Anonymous from Swanton - Posted: 8/1/2019

we had a great time - the ease and conveniences of the location, the size of the condo itself, and the ability to just have the golf cart waiting there for us was great.

Anonymous from Chagrin Falls - Posted: 7/30/2019

Condo was amazing. Beautiful views. Very clean. Comfortable bed linens. All around perfect place to stay on the island.

Anonymous from solon - Posted: 7/26/2019

We loved the spaciousness of the new unit. Everything was very clean and nicely appointed. Would love to stay there again.

Anonymous from Springboro - Posted: 7/7/2019

We were very pleased with the condo. It was clean, smelled fresh and was in great condition. The location was perfect since it was away from the downtown area.

Anonymous from Kalida - Posted: 5/21/2019

We had a fantastic time. Great place. Clean. New. Great view! Great location. Close to downtown.

Anonymous from Clinton Township - Posted: 8/15/2018

Our group of women have been going to Put-in-Bay every July for the past 30+ years. We’ve been staying with Island Club Rentals for the past 5 years and are booked for next year already! Our group was the first reservation for the water front condos! We love staying here!!! Everyone! And I mean everyone is super nice!

Anonymous from Lexington - Posted: 8/1/2018

We had a group of 10 staying and were pleased with the size of the bedrooms and bathrooms. You have to be comfortable sharing rooms though, as 3 of them had 2 beds each for sharing. Veey clean and Great views too. Recommend getting a golf cart for travel into town.

Anonymous from Powell - Posted: 7/17/2018

Thanks for the great review, Karen! We are glad you enjoyed the cleanliness of the condo and the beautiful views. We also agree that renting a golf cart is the best way to get around the island.

Island Club staff

My whole family stayed and we had a great experience. Condos are brand new very clean. Nice pool and beautiful lake views. The condos are located on the quite side of the island but a short golf cart ride away from bars and restaurants. I am looking to book for next year already

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 7/10/2018

Hi Courtney, thank you for the glowing review! We are glad that you enjoyed the beautiful lake views at our condos. We will be happy secure your stay for next year. Give us a call! :)

Island Club staff

Very impressed with condo. Very spaceous, great view of lake

Anonymous from North Royalton - Posted: 6/12/2018

Hi Jackie, thanks for staying with us. We're glad you liked to condos!

Island Club staff

It was a wonderful experience!! We were there to celebrate our daughter’s 21st birthday with family and friends. There were 10 of us staying at the condo. We had plenty of room, the beds were comfortable. Everything was very clean and in good working order. The grills outside were a nice option. Only suggestion would be to add a few more kitchen essentials, larger spoons, a measuring cup were some things we could have used. But overall a very enjoyable experience. Also appreciated the shuttle service!

Anonymous from Butler - Posted: 6/5/2018

Hi Denise, happy birthday to your daughter! We're glad you enjoyed your stay at the condos.

Island Club staff

We loved everything about our rental! From the lake views on 2 of the 3 balconies to the full kitchen and updated design, it was awesome and exactly what our Bride to Be wanted. The condo could sleep up to 14 people if necessary altho we only had 11. Also, super easy to get around the island and easily call the taxi!

Anonymous from Dayton - Posted: 5/30/2018

Hi Chelsea! Congrats to the bride to be! Thanks for choosing the condos to celebrate. We're glad you enjoyed your stay!

Island Club staff

Great property. Rooms were big and 7 or 8 could stay comfortably. Comfortable furniture including the beds. Had an issue with one of the locks but management came out right away to fix. Noticed it was a bit dirty on the porch and in doorways/sliders. But bathrooms, floors, refrigerator and furniture were clean. Would definitely recommend staying here. View was beautiful!!!

Anonymous from Pittsburgh - Posted: 10/1/2017

The cleanliness, accommodations, and overall experience exceeded my expectations. The condo was very spacious and had great views with close access to downtown.

Anonymous from Arlington Heights - Posted: 9/27/2017

Loved everything about the stay accept the wifi. It was terrible.

Anonymous from Westerville - Posted: 8/12/2017

Location was further away from main attractions that we had to take a taxi to and from but not necessarily a bad thing if you want to 'get a way' a bit. Gorgeous view of lake from balconies. Definitely a party scene, would not recommend for a family environment. Ice machine did not produce a lot of ice. Spoke to repair person and he informed us it was issue they were having with multiple units. Construction work occurring next to condos caused the entire area to smell like sewerage. Lots of dead bug in unit by doors and window seals.

Anonymous from Canfield - Posted: 8/8/2017

We had a great time. The condo was very clean and even bigger than I thought it was. Called for a refill on the propane grill and he was there before I even got back downstairs.

Anonymous from CLEVELAND - Posted: 7/9/2017

We comfortably housed 12 people at the new Put-in-Bay condos. Close enough to downtown for a cart ride down and/or far enough away to relax away from all of the chaos. I would definitely stay here again!

Anonymous from Tonawanda - Posted: 9/6/2016

We had a memorable trip and stay at the island club condo's. The 12 person Room we rented was on point! The place was brand new and the staff was great! The pool and party atmosphere was a blast as well. Transportation to and from to downtown was on point as well! Thanks Island club for a wonderful time!

Anonymous from Novi - Posted: 8/17/2016

I liked it very much. But would not reccomend to high maintence women. Lol!! Only issue i had was with the male bartender on sat the 23rd. He was drunk very rude and down right nasty over my friend asking for iced tea.

Anonymous from Oak Dale - Posted: 8/27/2014