Put-in-Bay Waterfront Condo #211

Second year and it was great! Not as clean as last year, but still good.

The dryer did t dry well and was showing an error code D90
The oven smokes and sets off the alarm within minutes of turning before it fully heats- needs cleaned

Anonymous from Middleburg Hts - Posted: 8/1/2026

Thank you for staying with us again! We truly appreciate your continued loyalty and are glad you had another great visit. We also appreciate you letting us know about the cleanliness concerns, the dryer, and the oven. Our maintenance and housekeeping teams will address these items right away. Thank you for your valuable feedback, and we look forward to providing you with an even better experience next year!

Island Club staff

We definitely enjoyed our time at this property. Sunsets were amazing on the balcony! Everything was cleaning and nicely decorated. Thanks for an enjoyable vacation!!

Anonymous from N/A - Posted: 7/15/2026

Thank you for your wonderful review! We're so happy to hear you enjoyed your stay and that you loved the amazing sunsets from the balcony. It's great to know you found the property clean, beautifully decorated, and comfortable. Thank you for choosing to stay with us, and we're delighted we could be part of an enjoyable vacation. We look forward to welcoming you back to Put-in-Bay again soon!

Island Club staff

Nine of us spent a long weekend on the island over 4th of July. There was plenty of space for all of us and we enjoyed the outdoor table on the balcony. The pool was nice but we didn’t swim in the lake as it smelled a little fishy. The condo location was great. We liked being close to all the action downtown but far enough to have some quiet time. We used the grills on site which worked great. I would recommend packing foil and spray oil. We rented golf carts which is a must. It was easy to book through the rental company. The only downside was that we arrived to the island early and had to kill time downtown until everything was ready. We ended up taking the bus downtown for $3.50/person and had lunch. It worked out great, but we didn’t realize the ferry was on the opposite side of the island from downtown. Bring cash for the bus ride. The condo complex was well maintained with lovely flowers. We would recommend this property to anyone with a large group staying on the island. The owners were responsive and friendly!

Anonymous from Milan - Posted: 7/7/2026

Thank you so much for your thoughtful review! We're thrilled to hear your group had a wonderful Fourth of July weekend and that the condo provided plenty of space for everyone. It's great to know you enjoyed the balcony, the pool, the outdoor grills, and our convenient location that offers the perfect balance of being close to downtown while still providing a peaceful place to relax. We're also glad the golf cart rental process was easy and that our team was responsive and friendly throughout your stay. We appreciate you sharing helpful tips for future guests as well. Thank you for your feedback regarding your early arrival. We understand it's never ideal to wait before check-in, especially after traveling. During holiday weekends, we have many same-day departures and arrivals, so our housekeeping team works hard to prepare every property as quickly and thoroughly as possible. We're glad you were able to enjoy lunch downtown while everything was being readied. Thank you again for your recommendation. We truly appreciate you choosing to stay with us and hope to welcome your group back to Put-in-Bay for another memorable getaway!

Island Club staff

We had a wonderful time.

Anonymous from West Chester - Posted: 7/6/2026

Thank you for your kind review! We're so happy to hear you had a wonderful time during your stay. We truly appreciate you choosing to stay with us and hope to welcome you back to Put-in-Bay for another memorable getaway soon!

Island Club staff

The condo we rented was clean, well appointed and well maintained. We loved to lake front location. The staff at Island Club are amazing. Everyone was very nice and very helpful.

Anonymous from Chesapeake - Posted: 6/5/2026

Thank you for the wonderful review! We’re so happy to hear your extended family vacation was such a success and that everyone had a blast together! It’s great to know the property gave your group plenty of space to relax, spend time together, and make great memories. Thank you again for staying with us, and we hope to welcome your family back to Put-in-Bay again soon! ️

Island Club staff

Another great time at a great venue

Anonymous from HUNTINGTON - Posted: 10/6/2025

We love hearing that! Thank you for choosing us again — we’re thrilled you had another great stay and can’t wait to welcome you back for the next one.

Island Club staff

My friends and I had a good time at the condo. Patio was wonderful. Beds and pillows comfortable but living room furniture is tired. Would have appreciated wine glasses of some sort and the towels provided were very hard - fabric softener would help.

Anonymous from Humble - Posted: 9/22/2025

Thank you for sharing your feedback! We’re glad to hear you and your friends enjoyed your time at the condo, especially the patio, and that the beds and pillows were comfortable. We appreciate your notes about the living room furniture, wine glasses, and towels—this input is very helpful as we continue to make improvements for our guests. We’re happy you had a good stay overall and would love to welcome you back again!

Island Club staff

This is the 2nd time we have stayed in a condo with Island Club. We returned for the quality and location.

This is not a downtown accommodation and that's such a plus! The condo was clean and appointed as described. We did not need to do our own cleaning before feeling comfortable. The smoke alarms work- as we found out from preparind dinner (another plus to a condo over a hotel room!) The beds were comfortable. There's no need to be hesitant to sit on the living room furniture because this isn't the party scene, as they have a strict policy of what types of groups are on property. For that reason, the pool was clean and there was the opportunity for all guests to enjoy- families with small children included. Plan time to take advantage of the lake-side deck. With the lapping of the waves you can close your eyes and be in any waterfront destination! We will be back!

Anonymous from Ottawa - Posted: 7/20/2025

Thank you so much for your wonderful review! We're honored that you chose to stay with us again and truly appreciate your kind words about the quality, cleanliness, and peaceful atmosphere of our condos. We're especially glad you felt comfortable and at home—from the well-appointed interior to the relaxing lakefront deck. It’s great to hear our policies helped create a calm and enjoyable environment for all guests, including families. We’re also glad the smoke alarms passed the "dinner test"! We look forward to welcoming you back for your next island escape. Until then, thank you again for staying with us!

Island Club staff

We have stayed in the waterfront condos numerous times and always have a great experience/time. This was the first time we used the common area grills and they were extremely clean.

Anonymous from Uniontown - Posted: 7/17/2025

Thank you for being a loyal guest! We’re thrilled to hear you always have a great experience at the Waterfront Condos. It’s especially great to know you found the common area grills clean and well-maintained during your most recent stay. We truly appreciate your continued support and look forward to welcoming you back again soon!

Island Club staff

Enjoyed our weekend stay!

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 5/5/2025

Thanks so much! We're glad you enjoyed your weekend stay and hope to see you back again soon!

Island Club staff

Excellent experience

Anonymous from Belle Center - Posted: 8/26/2024

Thank you for your feedback! We're thrilled to hear that you had an excellent experience. We look forward to welcoming you back for another great stay soon!

Island Club staff

Everyone we have worked with was great! Bobby was an exceptional help from the moment we got there. The rental was clean and had a beautiful view of the lake. I would highly recommend!

Anonymous from Middleburg Heights - Posted: 8/3/2024

Thank you for your kind words! We're delighted to hear that you had a great experience and found everyone helpful, especially Bobby. It's wonderful to know that you enjoyed the clean rental and the beautiful lake view. We appreciate your recommendation and look forward to welcoming you back in the future!

Island Club staff

Great

Anonymous from Follansbee - Posted: 6/30/2024

Thank you so much for the great review, hope to see you again soon!

Island Club staff

our family met a friend’s family for a 5 day vacation. everything worked out great with the unit itself, especially the space it offered. we knew it was a “party town” so we purposely booked monday thru friday. we had some noise issues at the property on thursday night and one downside is there wasn’t any onsite staff (after 2 hours of noise on the patio i called but it was an answering service). i would recommend maybe adding someone on thursday nights as we’ve heard they have on fridays and saturdays. chocolate cafe is great for breakfast sandwiches. the upper deck had fantastic dinner service and views. kids loved the perry’s activities and the playground “downtown”. the candy store with ice cream was a big hit too. definitely get a golf cart!

Anonymous from Hamburg - Posted: 7/31/2023

Thank you for choosing our property for your recent 5-day vacation with your friend's family. We're delighted to hear that overall, everything worked out great, and you enjoyed the spaciousness of the unit. It's wonderful to know that your group had a fantastic time during your stay. We appreciate your understanding and consideration in booking Monday through Friday to avoid the livelier atmosphere of a "party town." However, we sincerely apologize for the noise issues you experienced on Thursday night. We understand the importance of having a peaceful and relaxing environment, and we regret that it wasn't the case during that time. Your suggestion about having onsite staff on Thursday nights is a valuable one, and we will certainly explore options to enhance our services during those periods. We're glad to hear that you found great breakfast sandwiches at the Chocolate Cafe and enjoyed the fantastic dinner service and views at the Upper Deck. It's wonderful that the kids loved the Perry's activities and the playground downtown, as well as the candy store with ice cream – creating unforgettable memories during their vacation. Additionally, we couldn't agree more about the convenience and fun of getting a golf cart. It's a fantastic way to explore the area and add to the overall experience. Thank you for your kind recommendations and for taking the time to share your feedback. We truly value your comments as they help us continually improve and tailor our services to meet the needs of our guests. Should your future plans bring you back to the area, we would be honored to welcome you and your family again for another enjoyable stay. If you have any specific preferences or requests for your next visit, please do not hesitate to reach out to us directly, and we will be more than happy to assist.

Island Club staff

We had a nice stay at these waterfront condos with awesome views of the lake. Fun pool with other groups and convenient to the bars and the ferry. Would recommend for any groups staying on the island.

Anonymous from Gibsonia - Posted: 7/25/2023

Thank you for your wonderful review! We're thrilled to hear that you had a nice stay at our waterfront condos and enjoyed the awesome views of the lake. It's always a pleasure to provide our guests with beautiful scenery to enhance their experience. We're delighted that you had fun at the pool and enjoyed mingling with other groups. It's great to know that our location was convenient for you to explore the bars and access the ferry. Thank you for your recommendation! We truly value your endorsement and are grateful for your support. Thank you for choosing our waterfront condos for your stay, and we can't wait to welcome you and your group again in the future.

Island Club staff

This unit was great. The condos are always a great way to stay on PIB but the upper unit was really a great way to go.

Anonymous from Highland Heights - Posted: 7/17/2023

So happy to hear that the unit and everything was great! Thanks for the kind words and great feedback! We hope to be seeing you back with us again soon!

Island Club staff

Beautiful and clean stay! Amazing views and loved gathering around the outside table! Will be booking again!

Anonymous from Shippenville - Posted: 6/6/2023

We are so happy to hear that you had an amazing stay with the beautiful views from our Waterfront Condos! They are to die for especially at sunrise and sunset! We appreciate everything and hope to see you again soon!

Island Club staff

A great home base while visiting the islands! Good location for launching your day into town. Stellar location for attending Bash on the Bay. In good shape. True to pictures. Could use a more thorough cleaning between renters or at least toward end of season. Overall very good!

Anonymous from Lancaster - Posted: 10/10/2022

Hi Hope, we are so happy to hear you had a great time in our condos with us! Bash on the Bay is always a great time to come out because it's always fun! I have also let my staff know about the cleaning so things can change for next time.

Island Club staff

The best part of the condo was the breeze coming in from the lake and the sound of the waves lapping the shore.

Anonymous from Mishawaka - Posted: 7/11/2022

Hi Jeffrey! Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

We enjoyed this get a way. Condo was clean, roomy and quit.

Anonymous from Apex - Posted: 6/26/2022

Hi Don! Thanks for visiting our little island of Put-in-Bay on your recent getaway. You were definitely a 5-star guest and we are glad that we provided a 5-star experience! We hope to host another vacation for your group in the future.

Island Club staff

Well needed vacation it was great loved every moment will b back very soon

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 8/19/2021

Shirkara, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

We had a great time staying at our water front room. The home was spacious and clean. We enjoyed our neighbors and the access to the taxi van to head down town for the night. The pool was also great

Anonymous from DUBLIN - Posted: 8/17/2021

Emily, Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

It was awesome.. we enjoyed every moment of our stay.

Anonymous from Euclid - Posted: 8/8/2021

Johniece, We will see you soon for round two! Thanks so much for visiting our beautiful little island in Put-in-Bay, Ohio! We look forward to having your group visit again in the future!

Island Club staff

My family really enjoyed our stay. Condos were very nice and clean. We rented 2 Condos side by side for 19 people in our family as a graduation celebration. Condos had everything we needed, and we loved the decks and pool. Wilp definitely stay here again if we make it back to PIB.

Anonymous from Abilene - Posted: 7/5/2021

Heather, So glad you enjoyed your stay on our quaint little island of Put-in-Bay! We look forward to hosting your group in the future!

Island Club staff

Great location and set up for a couple families. We have been back every year for 3 years.

Anonymous from Clarkston - Posted: 7/5/2021

Amanda, So glad you enjoyed your stay on our quaint little island of Put-in-Bay! We look forward to hosting your group in the future!

Island Club staff

The view from this condo was amazing! Easy to get to and provided nice place to stay at Put in Bay! Only negative was condo was not very clean and balconies had huge piles of mayflies that looked like they had been there awhile.

Anonymous from Circleville - Posted: 7/19/2020

This is my second time in the waterfront condos, always so nice. Cannot get away from the may fly issue though, they were everywhere all over deck furniture. But still had an amazing time!

Anonymous from Akron - Posted: 7/14/2020

We had such a great experience this past weekend while staying at the put-on-bay waterfront condos. The view off our balcony was incredible, updated kitchen and bathrooms, clean, plenty of space, definitely the nicest place we have stayed at put-in-bay. We need some additional towels at one point, we called the office and they had them to us within 5 minutes. Great location as it was only a mile to the downtown area, We are customers for life and could not have been happier, highly recommend!!

Anonymous from Columbus - Posted: 10/29/2019

Our family has been coming to Put-In-Bay for many years. My children were small and we used to go to Cedar Point three days a week and Put-In-Bay two days. As the kids got older, we enjoy the island so much, we decided to stay on the island. We have been staying at the Put-In-Bay condos for the last two years and we love it. We like the idea that everyone gets a bed to sleep in, and there is a full kitchen. There is nothing like having breakfast out on the porch overlooking the lake. In the evening after a busy day the living area is very comfortable for the whole family. We come up to the condos twice a year and we will continue to do so.

Anonymous from valparaiso - Posted: 10/3/2019

Awesome!

Anonymous from Wadsworth - Posted: 9/4/2019

Family reunion was great. Perfect place for a lrger group.

Anonymous from Birdsboro - Posted: 8/12/2019

Perfect! The condo was beautiful!!

Anonymous from EUCLID - Posted: 8/8/2019

EVERYTHING WAS AS GOOD AS HOPED AND EXPECTED

Anonymous from MENTOR - Posted: 8/23/2018

We loved our stay at Put-in-Bay Waterfront Condos. The units are new and clean, and have everything you need. The pool was awesome, and the whole complex was quiet and relaxing. A great place to take the family.

Anonymous from Grove City - Posted: 7/27/2018

Thanks for your glowing review Tracy! Please come back next year for another relaxing island getaway.

Island Club staff

The condo was fantastic and more than we expected. The deck on the lake was a great place to escape to eat, read and nap. Put in a Bay is a delightful community with activities for all ages, our group ranged fro 7 to 68. So many restaurants on the island made it easy and o find a quality meal.

Anonymous from louisville - Posted: 7/1/2018

Hi Dennis, nice to hear that your group was able to enjoy all the that our property and the island have to offer. The family-friendly atmosphere is great for all ages. We hope to have you stay with us again in the future!

Island Club staff

The condo was very nice and clean. Had a great waterfront view and exceeded my expectations. Would definitely recommend staying at these condos!

Anonymous from liberty Center - Posted: 6/5/2018

Hi Jessica! Thanks for staying with us. I love the view from the condos too! We're glad you enjoyed your stay!

Island Club staff

We rented the cond for a family get together.
Worked out really well for us. However the elevator is still not working
And our unit was on 2nd floor. Very inconvenient!!!!!
Also, I think all the bedrooms should have a tv

Anonymous from Powell - Posted: 8/21/2017

We had a wonderful time!

Anonymous from Tiffin - Posted: 8/7/2017

The condo was a great place for our family. It was clean and the views were amazing. The maintenance and cleaning crews were always there and very friendly. We never had an issue, but other condos did (light bulbs replaced and minor things), someone was always around to help. The elevator wasn't working and didn't look like it was going to be fixed anytime soon, so with staying so long with a lot of stuff that was a minor pain. Overall a great trip and we will stay again!

Anonymous from Pendleton - Posted: 7/15/2017

Easy check in, clean and well kept unit. Staff was super friendly and helpful.

Anonymous from Pittsburgh - Posted: 6/20/2017

We had such an amazing weekend staying at the waterfront condos. The condo was beautiful, clean, and updated. We had everything we needed. The view was amazing and the pool was so much fun!

Anonymous from Pataskala - Posted: 6/9/2017

We thoroughly enjoyed our stay at the Condo. The view was exceptional and the place was as described on the web. We had a great time.

Anonymous from Nokomis - Posted: 9/7/2016

Our first time to the island we went for my wife's birthday! The condo was huge 4 bdrm 2 bath plus 2 balconies and your right on the water! Nice pool and the staff bent over backwards to make you happy! I know these are brand new and a work in progress but our master bdrm didn't have night stands and the closet was missing the pole you hang your clothes on. No dressers either but that was the only bump in an otherwise GREAT place. We will defiantly be back!!!

Anonymous from Chicago - Posted: 8/24/2016

A booking error led our party to this location. What a great thing to happen. Upon booking we were informed that the pool and some other landscape issues were unfinished. We looked at the alternatives and went ahead with the condo. When we arrived the location was still unfinished and had construction work being done all over. The elevator was not installed, drive and sidewalks littered with materials, and loud noise everywhere. Then we opened our door. All the issues disappeared! What a unit! Honestly the bedding was not done and most furniture and tvs were not installed yet. But WOW THE VIEW AND FINSIHINGS! Gorgeous views of the water and sights! Right out the patio and bedroom door was breathtaking scenery and the calming waves. High end finishings and furniture made it welcome and clean. The staff was only a call away to prepare bedding and resolve any issues. They admitted being a bit behind but were honest and helpful to make anything possible. The outdoor community grills were nice and clean. Bathrooms were excellent, and even in unit washer/dryer!! Overall a great experience that we will make again once they are complete! THere were many bad reviews on Facebook and other sites complaining about issues. Ignore them and book now! By the time you get there, kinks and flaws should be over with and a perfect experience await! Make the trip! Very close to beaches, wineries, downtown, monument, etc! This is the only place to stay on the island!

Anonymous from Strasburg - Posted: 8/5/2016

Every year 24-60 women travel to Put-in-Bay to have fun. For the past 3 years we've stayed with Put-in-Bay condos. We LOVE everything about this place. The new condos were awesome. We were the first official guests! We've already reserved condos for next year!!!

Anonymous from Lexington - Posted: 8/1/2016

These units are very spacious and offer a lot of amenities. The nicest property I've stayed at on PIB. The construction was still taking place on the pool, which was a disappointment. We did not find out about that until just a few days before we arrived. All in all, I believe it was a very good rental for the money.

Anonymous from NA - Posted: 7/29/2016