Island Club 4-Person Golf Cart #22 Su-Th $70-$90/nt, Fr-Sa $80-$110/nt

"Just spent a day at the Island Club and had an incredible stay. It’s a community of remodeled cabins that strike the perfect balance between relaxation and social energy. The unit we stayed in was beautifully updated — lots of thoughtful details inside (think “lake life” charm without feeling kitschy), a full kitchen, plenty of beds, and a skylight in the shower that made mornings feel a little extra special.

The layout worked great for both group hangouts and downtime. There’s a spacious living area with sliding doors that open up to the front if you want to mingle with neighbors — which we did, and a more private back deck with a grill that’s perfect for winding down or having a quieter meal.

The pool is a major highlight — it's where you really feel the vibe of the place. Everyone's out there having a good time, music playing, drinks flowing, and yet it never felt out of control. Just good people, good energy, and really great weather while we were there.

Also: huge bonus that the Island Club offers golf cart rentals directly. It made getting around the island super easy — beach, bars, downtown, ferry — everything is just a quick ride away.

Highly recommend for groups or anyone looking to enjoy the full Put-in-Bay experience without sacrificing comfort or privacy."

"Great place to stay very clean"

"It was great! Young man was very helpful and made it quick and easy so we could enjoy our vacation. He was helpful and friendly! Thank you for helping make our stay relaxing and stress free!"

"6 friends and family for long weekend rental. "

"There is no better vacation that a slower-paced environment with plenty of options to d0, a nice place to stay, and sunshine on your shoulders. Staying at an Island Club rental whether a home or condo is well worth it. The homes/condos may not always be in the best shape. However, a simple phone call and they will come fix the issues. They don't always get a chance to do maintenance since the rentals are booked regularly. Another great thing about these rentals is they provide you with a golf cart as part of the deal at a much reduced price than the other golf cart rentals on the island saving you money."

"We used all 3 for the 12 of us. It was easy to get around and they all worked fairly well. Made the vacation easy. The first night was very noisy due to a party going on
Tried to call maintenance and it just rang
They did come the next day and apologized. Otherwise it was simple things such as toilet holders broken in 2 bathrooms. Towel holder in the downstairs was broke. Screen door broke. We did mention all thongs to maintenance and I'm sure they were fixed after we we checked out. We enjoyed our stay."

"We rented a 6 seater originally. Reed provided fabulous customer service.Very efficient check in. Two people in our party had to leave early do to an emergency. We down grated to 4 seater with ease. Reed went above and beyond to make sure we were accommodated with great communication. The Island Club management credited the price difference to my credit card immediately. "

"Golf cart was clean and modern. It was great to have it at the property."

"This condo was clean and has a great location. Having a pool was a plus. "

"Beautiful rental. Everything we needed was there. Great views and great TVs."

"Everything ran smoothly with drop off and pick up."

"Was a little confused about arrival and departutre instructions due to the house not being locked when arriving. Instructions to lock keys up before leaving weren't arrogate either, couldn't get into lock box so called and was told to leave on counter. Besides that staff was awesome, house was clean. They may want to remind housekeeping to leave trash bags we did have to ask for those. "