Put-in-Bay Island Club #6 Su-Th $150-$300/nt, Fr-Sa $225-$1000/nt

"Stayed here with 7 girls. Great open area for entertaining. A few more hooks in the bathroom for towels would have been great! In the master there is an open area that another mirror could go or counter with a mirror. Would make is more convenient for multiple girls to get ready in at the same time. The staff is absolutely wonderful here! Will definitely return!!"

"We had only stayed one night but it’s perfect for a little vacation ! Has a lot more in it than expected but very appreciated. Very clean and neat. "

"The house was great as for location in reference to getting to attractions, paper supplies provided, and other items that were provided. We had a great time. A disappointment was the items that were wrong with the building. I understand that unless a renter informs you, you are unaware of it. But someone comes to clean and should notice it. I called to let you know of a # of items wrong with the building. Just saying. It was a great vacation to the area."

"Overall pretty good experience, would definitely like to visit again! The only negative was that the WI-FI didn’t work and the futon bed in the main area was broken. "

"The customer service was excellent, and the house and furniture were great. "

"Had a GREAT 3 nights !! Place was great , clean , Ac and lots of room will definitely be back next year ❤️"

"My family and I had a great stay. The rental was clean and comfortable. The staff was incredibly friendly and accommodating. They were constantly up keeping the landscaping and grounds. The pool was great. We would stay here again! "

"As usual we had a fabulous time at the Island Club. Looking forward to 2023."

"Really enjoyed our stay. Have been fishing at Put in Bay for over 30 continuous years now and Island Club has the best to offer on the Island. Always a clean and well accommodated house and easy access to everything we need as fisherman."

"The property description was accurate. The house was clean and well maintained; it was the nicest one that I have stayed in so far. I definitely recommend this house. Perry's Cave was very cool. "

"What a great time we had... the house was perfect for the 6 of us. The location was the best - we were able to greet everyone when they came into the Island Club! "

"Good experience "

"The island clubs was very nice, there were a couple minor things that were broken and dinged up from previous guest but other than that the place was very clean and the A/C worked great on those last couple August muggy days."

"Perfect except for clogged bathroom sink."

"Me and my kids have enjoyed staying the the Island Club. This year was our third year and we had another fun 4th of July Weekend. "

"Had a great time. Loved the cabin, it was clean and close to everything"

"The stay was pleasant and quiet as usual. The pool was clean and relaxing. The workers were nice and professional. The house was clean and everything in working order. Would stay again."

"Our accommodations were very roomy, pool was clean and quiet and cabin was in great location. Would recommend a cabin broom and mop as the floor was not cleaned between renters. Will return everyone was super friendly!"

"As always, we had a great time. The staff are all so accommodating. We have been coming for at least 15 years for this event and plan to continue. "

"All guests enjoyed their time up at the island. It was more enjoyable than expected with the current situation. All kept us update on everything. The house was perfect for all 10 of us."

"Wonderful!"

"We enjoyed our stay in the Island Club #6. The house was clean, and in a very convenient location for our stay."

"we came with 2 other couples for a birthday and had a great time! was a little inconvenient to have to bring your own sheets,towels...etc. next time we will be more prepared. overall great experience and would stay again!"

"The stay was nice."

"Good time. Prompt Taxi's to downtown which is convenient"

"The house was very roomy and clean. Although we did have a little mouse problem. There was some Garbage under one of the beds. We could have used more garbage bags and toilet paper. Our overall stay was great and we will probably come back next year."

"Great place! Had so much fun. right across from the pool. Rent a golf cart and tour the island, it is so worth it!! Clean, grill was great. "

"Girls trip! 7 of us. Villas were very roomy and clean. Staff was great too. Loved sitting out on the deck at night. Can’t wait till next year! "

"Very clean and maintained house, couldn’t ask for a better location on island with a bunch of good neighbors. Will be back again this year if not this year next year. I’ve been to put n bay for 4 straight years.
"

"Great size for our family. Very convenient to pool. Only wish there was wi-fi in cabin."

"The rental unit was as expected and described, with nice amenities and accommodations and recently renovated. It was in a good location (pool is basically right next to it) and it was easy to take a taxi from the development to anywhere we wanted to go. Wi-Fi and reception were not good but we weren't there to play on our phones and computers. Easy process to rent and good price, would recommend for families and (more so) getaway weekend for a group of friends. Thanks for a good weekend.
-Ben"

"The cabin was renovated in a nice location. Staff was pleasant, but when they said they would bring more paper towels and trash bags, they were not received. Overall great experience."

"It was all good as always "

"Great value and amenities. Would definitely rent again."

"This was our 2nd year in this cabin, I find your staff to be very accommodating we love the location and the furnishings of this place. The house in general was clean except the floor both times was filthy, thankfully there was a mop and bucket in the laundry room."

" Phenomenal staff & very clean cabin! It was perfectly placed off the main strip for a family to stay! We will definitely be coming back next year :) we even rented two golf carts that were dropped off right at our cabin, huge convenience when you're traveling with little ones "

"I would stay here again. Great location by the pool. Close to perrys cave. We ran out of paper towels and property staff brought us more within 5 minutes of our call."

"The owner was arround and asked if we needed anything .. Also staff helped us move our freezer back in to our truck Doty was also arround to c if we needed anything ....Very nice helpful people ...My 12th year there ...C u guys NXT year ...Bob Singler..."

"A bit group of us went out to PIB for my husband's 40th birthday. We rented two houses to house. I assumed that they are typically "party" rentals, but this one was much more modern and clean than I was expecting! I was very pleasantly surprised."

"Overall, I was satisfied with the total Put in Bay experience"

"Rented house #6 it was the nicest house I've stayed in at Island Club. Everything was great!"

"We were very pleased with our house, it was very nice with a very nice setting. The price was very reasonable compared to hotel pricing on the island."

"will be back every year. change nothing one of the most funnest places to go in the whole Midwest i always recommend it. "

"I split a cabin with several people, and it was clean and spacious! Looks to have been renovated since my last stay 3 years ago. Well worth the price, definitely recommend!"

"The home was newly renovated and clean. Far enough away from the loudness of downtown but quick to get to through the taxi service. "

"Had a few minor problems but management took care of fairly quickly. loved location. Pool was just the right temperature and we could swim at night"

"This was our first time at Put-In-Bay, and we could not have picked a better place to stay. We will be returning next year."

"We were quite impressed with the homes nice renovations, however when my kids were barefoot in the house their feet were black with dirt, not sure if the floors/carpets have ever been scrubbed. Also the wifi never worked for us which was frustrating, when I called they said it would be reset and would only work by the never worked."

"First of all the booking process was fantastic! Super friendly and efficient. The property was clean. There was a broken picnic table when we arrived that was repaired within 10 minutes of our arrival. We cannot say enough positive things about our experience!"

"Cottage #6 is the best location, The cottage was immaculate. Kitchen is well stocked. Beds are comfy-cozy. Plenty of space for everyone to sit n watch TV, also to sit and enjoy a meal together. A few minor things needed to be taken care of, other than that, it was a great experience. The staff was so very very friendly :) "

"We loved staying here, it's so clean and beautiful, I love how we r farther from downtown but not that far! It was a blast I can't wait to come back next year!!!"

"I had a nice time. The unit I had was recently renovated and very nice. I would also like to mention Dean. He was very helpful when something needed attention. Thanx Dean."

"Everything was nice the cottage was nice and clean I love the way you guys have all the cleaning supplies and everything we needed already there it was a beautiful place to stay and I can't wait to stay again"

"We had a wonderful time in Put- in- Bay! We loved the big deck and being right across from the pool! The golf cart was great for going to get ice or sightseeing around the island. Having so many beds was perfect for all 8 of us to be together in one house."

"Been staying there for 11 years ...could CV not b more impressed with the staff ...Dotie and the guys r like family and will do anything possible to help out ...liki getting boat parts from mainland ...they will go above and out of there way to help people ...thank u ...Bob singler"

"No real issues with the rental at all. The only real issues we had were that the fridge stopped working at one point, but was addressed. There was a rip on one of the couches and there was a slight odor that was noticeable at first, but wasn't a huge deal. Might be nice to have a walk through checklist upon check in to address any issues. Would hate to be charged for these things."

"We couldn't have been happier with the property and the excellent staff at Island Club. The staff (Tracy, Kelly and especially 'Doc') were so personable and responded immediately to any request we had. We will definitely come back and are planning on bringing more friends and family with us next time!!!!"

"The onsite management called ahead to make sure our room was clean so we could go in and get settled. Everything was clean and we had plenty of space, plus it was right across from the pool. We we're very pleased with our stay"

"The place was perfect, located right across from the pool. I think there could be some "newer" renovations that could be done to the bathrooms (especially the floors). The staff was extremely nice, they did a fantastic job cleaning and taking time to bring us things we needed. Definitely will come back again next year to the Island Club! Also, Jerry was extremely helpful with scheduling and allowing us to come in a little earlier than the 4 pm check in due to travel arrangements. "

"It was a nice stay for 2 nights. Air conditioning was terrible, as it never got under 74 degrees in the house, but we weren't too concerned since it was only 72 outside. We just opened up the doors. Close to the pool, but also close to the you hear many golf carts go by all day/night. Was a nice equipped home. One of the better locations in the whole club."

"Great location nice deck across from the pool"

"This is the second year we have stayed in this rental. We did bring a table along because there would not be enough room to seat 9. Other than that...great time, love the deck area, especially with kids! Will probably be back next year!!"

"My friends and I rented this property for our annual girls getaway. It was perfect for what we were looking for. It had plenty of space and is right across the srteet from the pool. I would definitely recommend this property and we are looking forward to returning next year. "

"We had a great time at Put in Bay. The staff was all very helpful and professional and one member (sorry we did not get her name) went above and beyond to help us out. The unit was roomy and the beds were comfortable. However, there was a lot of obvious wear and tear. The ceramic tile in the hallway was cracked in several places and it made a sound every time we stepped on it. At least one kitchen cabinet and one drawer was broken. Most notably, not one towel rack in the house was intact and there was no place to hang a towel before or after a shower. Admittedly we did not call and complain, but it was annoying that such a minor thing was not noticed and repaired. It was also interesting that the rental company did not have an office on the premises. Very unusual. There was a maintenance shed and there were obviously multiple employees riding through the complex but there was no office. We were not the only ones who were confused by this.
In spite of the few shortcomings, we had a great vacation and we would definitely consider renting again from Island Club. It was a decent value considering what we paid."

"I love the island and we had a great time. The golf cart included was great. The pool was nice, albeit quite crowded. The grounds seemed relativelt well maintained. That being said I have a laundry list of complaints with unit 6... Broken cabinets missing doors, broken floor tiles, good luck finding a towel rack they're all broken, no drain stops, filthy drains, broken tv remote (not just batteries), poor job cleaning (chips and food on floor, really?), crawling with ants, screens missing, front door locks broke, etc. Really we didn't stay inside much so it wasn't that big a deal but I was pretty disappointed in the property itself."

"Had a little wear and tear but we expected that Pool was super clean and close to town"

"It was an overall good experience and stay at our vacation house. There were definitely several things that needed replaced in the home from past guests that were just left broken. The place did meet our needs for the stay. We liked the code so we didn't have to keep track of a key. We would've liked a plug for the bath tub so I could've given my daughter a bath. It was very close to the pool and close enough to downtown. Some people were heavily intoxicated while we were there and they were recklessly driving their golf cart around the club."

"Nice location right by the pool! Island Club cab drivers are the best in the island! We have stay at the island club 10+ years now. This house was pretty beat up, but it worked for what we needed! Broken cabinets, tiles, couch end, etc. "

"great time and great people at the island club we will be back thanks "

"Nice place for the money and perfect complex for what we wanted. "

"Had a blast!!! House needs some updating but weekend is so much fun, we overlook that. :)"

"All good as always ...have been coming to island club rentals for about 12 years now "

"The Island Club was a wonderful place to stay. It was clean, spacious, and the staff was friendly and helpful."

"The rental was nice but had I known that literally nothing was open during the week after labor day, my friends and I would not have chose this location for a getaway. Went into town on Monday night and everything was closed. The place itself was nice but could have been a little cleaner. The floors were very dirty and the carpet is very worn. The one bathroom was missing a drain cover in the shower and none of the towel racks had the bars on them. It is in a very good location right across from the pool but our weather did not cooperate. Very nice large deck. I would recommend for the summer."

"Everything was good with a few exceptions. When we arrived there were a bunch of flies inside. We spilled a coke and had to clean it up with paper towels. A mop, bucket, and broom would have been nice."

"Nice place, met expectations. Would go back for another party type house."

"Love cabin 6 because of the overhanging roof that can protect you from rain on the deck unlike other cabins. Bring your own Kleenex and bath rug, everything else is provided other than sheets and towels. Nice and close yo the pool. Propane grill worked well."

"Went with my friend for four days, August 31 through sept 4. Loved the island club rentals. Loved rental #6. Nice location right by the pool. Very spacious. It was pretty clean... except for the floors... make sure you where slippers. Golf cart much cheaper through the island club. We got to keep it overnight for just $40 per day. And they delivered the cart to us, and picked up when we were leaving. Great location only 1 mile from down town. Overall great trip! Going back next year:)"

"Although it could use a face lift the unit was clean and the management was quick to respond to a minor faucet leak. Great location and the grounds were very well taken care of. Will recommend to friends"

"It was everything we wanted."

"Better than I expected based on some of the other reviews I read. I wouldn't take a young family here but for me and 7 dudes it was perfect. It isn't close to much but the taxi service is super quick and cheap. This place is a 24/7 party!"

"We planned a short vacation to Put-In-Bay with the family....which included 3 small children. Island Club #6 was a perfect fit for all of us. The outside deck is wonderful for small children and just gave us some extra space. The only downside was the kitchen table which only seated 4. We did bring a table along, and moved the patio chairs inside, so we could all eat together, which worked perfect. Overall, we had a great mini-vacation and would absolutely stay at #6 again!!"

"Fantastic"

"I haven't been to the Island in over 20 years. We were 3 senior citizens wanting a little getaway. We enjoyed the island and sightseeing & the golf cart was fun. We stayed in #6, the only thing I would suggest is putting some gravel/mulch on the walkway from the driveway to the door. We got there in a downpour and it was all mud on the walkway. Next time, we would choose a home further back in on a cul-de-sac or dead end. #6 was a very busy location with a lot of traffic, although Island Club is a great location. The grill did not work, but we just decided to cook inside as we were too hungry to wait. I have recommended Island Club to several friends since our return. It was a great time!"

"Easy reservation process. Everything was ready when we arrived including golf cart. The staff was attentive and answered any questions we had. It was great having a washer and dryer in the house and all the cooking utensils you need. It is nice being able to cook on the grill rather than going out for every meal. My only problem was that the property did not have internet and we were told it was at the pool. Even when sitting at the pool, all 6 of us could find the WiFi but could not get any web sites to come up. Staying with 4 teenagers this was an issue. Overall, great experience and plan on returning."